POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsWFLA (NBC 8) — Local NewsOctober 28, 2026Hillsborough County

Witness testifies in Tampa murder trial about seeing sludge-filled bins tossed into McKay Bay

Photo: WFLA (NBC 8) — Local News

During the third day of a Tampa murder trial, a witness testified he saw a man unloading storage bins containing a black substance from a vehicle and throwing them off a bridge near McKay Bay in November 2021. The testimony relates to the prosecution's case against Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Stephanie Crone-Overholtz and disposing of her body parts in the bay.

Read the full story at WFLA (NBC 8) — Local News

Why It Matters

The proceedings determine criminal liability and potential sentencing in a high-profile homicide case involving the discovery of human remains in a local waterway.

Key Facts

  • The murder trial entered its third day covering evidence that shifted Stephanie Crone-Overholtz's status from a missing person to a murder victim.
  • Witness Lazzaro Castro testified that on Nov. 9, 2021, he saw a man throw storage bins containing a black sludge-like substance off a bridge near McKay Bay.
  • Prosecutors allege the man Castro saw on the bridge was Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Crone-Overholtz.
  • Fisherman Stuart Welch discovered what appeared to be the lower half of a human leg floating in the water near the 22nd Street bridge on Nov. 11, 2021.
  • Investigators searched the bay using drones, boats, dive teams, and cadaver dogs following tips from fishermen.
  • Castro identified Robert Kessler in a police mugshot four days after observing the incident.
  • Defendant Robert Kessler waived his right to appear in person and listened to the Wednesday proceedings via Zoom from jail.

Who's Mentioned