
NewsWFLA (NBC 8) — Local NewsOctober 28, 2026Hillsborough County
Witness testifies in Tampa murder trial about seeing sludge-filled bins tossed into McKay Bay
Photo: WFLA (NBC 8) — Local News
During the third day of a Tampa murder trial, a witness testified he saw a man unloading storage bins containing a black substance from a vehicle and throwing them off a bridge near McKay Bay in November 2021. The testimony relates to the prosecution's case against Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Stephanie Crone-Overholtz and disposing of her body parts in the bay.
Read the full story at WFLA (NBC 8) — Local NewsWhy It Matters
The proceedings determine criminal liability and potential sentencing in a high-profile homicide case involving the discovery of human remains in a local waterway.
Key Facts
- The murder trial entered its third day covering evidence that shifted Stephanie Crone-Overholtz's status from a missing person to a murder victim.
- Witness Lazzaro Castro testified that on Nov. 9, 2021, he saw a man throw storage bins containing a black sludge-like substance off a bridge near McKay Bay.
- Prosecutors allege the man Castro saw on the bridge was Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Crone-Overholtz.
- Fisherman Stuart Welch discovered what appeared to be the lower half of a human leg floating in the water near the 22nd Street bridge on Nov. 11, 2021.
- Investigators searched the bay using drones, boats, dive teams, and cadaver dogs following tips from fishermen.
- Castro identified Robert Kessler in a police mugshot four days after observing the incident.
- Defendant Robert Kessler waived his right to appear in person and listened to the Wednesday proceedings via Zoom from jail.
Who's Mentioned
location22 nd Street bridge“Bridge near the shrimp docks where evidence was found”locationFlorida“State where prosecutors are trying the case”PersonScott Harmon“Prosecutor questioning a Tampa Police officer during the trial”locationTampa“City where the trial and alleged crimes took place”PersonRobert Kessler“Man accused of killing Crone-Overholtz”locationMcKay Bay“Location where body parts and bins were allegedly dumped”PersonStuart Welch“Fisherman who reported finding a human leg in the bay”PersonStephanie Crone-Overholtz“47-year-old victim whose disappearance and death are the subject of the murder t”PersonLazzaro Castro“Witness who testified to seeing a man throw bins into McKay Bay”
