POLISCOPE
Back to feed

The civic record

Read. Follow. Verify.
High Impact

House Judiciary Committee Hearing on Donald McGahn Subpoena

Original title: OVERSIGHT OF THE REPORT BY SPECIAL COUNSEL ROBERT S. MUELLER III: FORMER WHITE HOUSE COUNSEL DONALD F. MCGAHN II

Record date · January 1, 2019

Track this bill to get notified when it advances a stage. One tap to stop, anytime.

What This Bill Does

This document is the transcript of a May 21, 2019, House Judiciary Committee hearing regarding the oversight of the Special Counsel Robert Mueller report. The hearing focused on the committee's attempt to compel testimony from former White House Counsel Donald F. McGahn II, who did not appear due to a White House claim of .

Why it matters

The hearing addresses the legal conflict between Congressional power and the executive branch's claim of for senior presidential advisors, which determines the extent of legislative oversight into executive actions.

Who It Affects

Groups the bill's text affects, as described in the record. Being affected is not a position for or against it.

Directly affected

Donald F. McGahn II

He was the subject of a congressional subpoena and a White House directive regarding his testimony.

Directly affected

House Judiciary Committee

The committee is attempting to exercise its oversight authority through the subpoena process.

Key Facts

  • The hearing was held on May 21, 2019, in the Rayburn House Office Building.
  • Donald F. McGahn II did not appear at the hearing despite being subpoenaed by the committee.
  • The White House directed Mr. McGahn not to appear, citing 'absolute immunity' for senior presidential advisors.
  • Chairman Nadler stated that the committee rejects the claim of absolute immunity, citing a 2007 judicial ruling by Judge John Bates regarding Harriet Miers.
Show all 6 facts
  • The hearing was convened to conduct oversight regarding the report by Special Counsel Robert Mueller III.
  • The committee record includes opening statements from Chairman Nadler and Ranking Member Doug Collins.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Donald McGahn testify at this hearing?
No, he did not appear.
Why did the White House say Mr. McGahn could not testify?
The White House asserted that he was entitled to '' from the committee's .

What else do you want to know?

News Coverage

No news coverage found yet. Articles are indexed twice daily.

Full breakdown

Who this bill affects and the strongest case for and against it, written only from the bill’s own text.

Discoveries

1 pattern noticed across the record

Patterns POLISCOPE noticed across the record. These are observations to investigate, not conclusions.

cross reference100% confidence

Historical Precedent

The committee explicitly relied on the 2007 Harriet Miers case to challenge the current administration's claim of absolute immunity.

Connected Entities

House Committee on the Judiciary, Harriet Miers, Robert S. Mueller III and 4 more
OrganizationHouse Committee on the Judiciary“The committee conducting the oversight hearing.”Map →
PersonHarriet Miers“Former White House Counsel who was the subject of a similar 2007 subpoena disput”Map →
PersonRobert S. Mueller III“Special Counsel who authored the report on the investigation into the President.”Map →
PersonJohn Bates“Federal Judge who ruled on the 2007 executive privilege case.”Map →
PersonDonald F. McGahn II“Former White House Counsel whose testimony was sought by the committee.”Map →
PersonNadler, Jerrold“Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee.”Map →
PersonDoug Collins“Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Committee.”Map →

Sources

Open source document

www.govinfo.gov

Analysis Score

0–100
  • Significance90
    How much this matters to a regular citizen
  • Controversy95
    Intensity of disagreement among stakeholders
  • Entertainment75
    Compellingness for a non-policy-wonk reader
  • Buzz80
    Current news / social attention level

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record