
NewsSFistOctober 30, 2026San Francisco County
Defense Attorney Argues 77-Year-Old Defendant Was Unaware of Husband's Plan to Murder Son-In-Law
Photo: SFist
In a court filing ahead of a November 4 bail hearing, the attorney for 77-year-old Shili Chen asserts she had no role in the killing of her son-in-law, Jonathan McKinsey, and claims her husband kept her in the dark. The motion seeks to remove a "lying in wait" special circumstance that currently keeps Chen held without bail.
Read the full story at SFistWhy It Matters
The legal shift alters the defense strategy in a high-profile murder case, directly impacting whether a defendant remains incarcerated without bail prior to trial.
Key Facts
- Curtis Briggs, attorney for 77-year-old Shili Chen, filed a court motion ahead of a November 4 bail hearing arguing his client should be freed.
- The filing asserts that Chen's husband, Shouyong Zhang, kept her in the dark about his plan to shoot Jonathan McKinsey.
- The defense motion claims Chen was told to bring a gun because they were going to a shooting range.
- The filing states Chen only got out of the car to protect her husband from a perceived assault after the fatal shot had already been fired.
- Witnesses and police previously suggested the couple took turns shooting McKinsey "in concert" on September 26.
- Police reportedly found 18 shell casings at the scene, with many coming from Zhang's gun, though the motion acknowledges Chen also fired her weapon.
- The defense motion suggests Zhang suffers from advanced stages of dementia.
- The legal maneuver aims to clear Chen of the "lying in wait" special circumstance that allows the court to hold her without bail.
- Both suspects are currently held at Santa Rita Jail.
- The victim, Jonathan McKinsey, had recently been granted visitation rights with his three children, who share parents with Candice Jang.
Who's Mentioned
PersonCandice Jang“Daughter of Chen and Zhang, former spouse of McKinsey”OrganizationChronicle“Publication cited regarding court filings”OrganizationSanta Rita Jail“Facility where suspects are being held”PersonShili Chen“77-year-old defendant accused of murder”locationDublin“City where the shooting occurred”OrganizationCalifornia Post“Publication cited regarding court filings”PersonJonathan McKinsey“Slain son-in-law”PersonCurtis Briggs“Defense attorney for Shili Chen”PersonShouyong Zhang“77-year-old husband and co-defendant”
