POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsSFistOctober 30, 2026San Francisco County

Defense Attorney Argues 77-Year-Old Defendant Was Unaware of Husband's Plan to Murder Son-In-Law

Photo: SFist

In a court filing ahead of a November 4 bail hearing, the attorney for 77-year-old Shili Chen asserts she had no role in the killing of her son-in-law, Jonathan McKinsey, and claims her husband kept her in the dark. The motion seeks to remove a "lying in wait" special circumstance that currently keeps Chen held without bail.

Read the full story at SFist

Why It Matters

The legal shift alters the defense strategy in a high-profile murder case, directly impacting whether a defendant remains incarcerated without bail prior to trial.

Key Facts

  • Curtis Briggs, attorney for 77-year-old Shili Chen, filed a court motion ahead of a November 4 bail hearing arguing his client should be freed.
  • The filing asserts that Chen's husband, Shouyong Zhang, kept her in the dark about his plan to shoot Jonathan McKinsey.
  • The defense motion claims Chen was told to bring a gun because they were going to a shooting range.
  • The filing states Chen only got out of the car to protect her husband from a perceived assault after the fatal shot had already been fired.
  • Witnesses and police previously suggested the couple took turns shooting McKinsey "in concert" on September 26.
  • Police reportedly found 18 shell casings at the scene, with many coming from Zhang's gun, though the motion acknowledges Chen also fired her weapon.
  • The defense motion suggests Zhang suffers from advanced stages of dementia.
  • The legal maneuver aims to clear Chen of the "lying in wait" special circumstance that allows the court to hold her without bail.
  • Both suspects are currently held at Santa Rita Jail.
  • The victim, Jonathan McKinsey, had recently been granted visitation rights with his three children, who share parents with Candice Jang.

Who's Mentioned