POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsWUSF — Tampa Bay NPR (Local & State)October 28, 2026Hillsborough County

PolitiFact rates David Jolly's claim about Byron Donalds and Jim Crow as Half True

Photo: WUSF — Tampa Bay NPR (Local & State)

PolitiFact evaluated a claim by Florida gubernatorial candidate David Jolly that U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds suggested there were good parts of Jim Crow. The fact-checking organization found the statement missing context because Donalds' remarks focused on marriage rates and family structure rather than praising racist laws. PolitiFact ultimately rated Jolly's statement Half True.

Read the full story at WUSF — Tampa Bay NPR (Local & State)

Why It Matters

Voters evaluating candidates running for office receive a factual assessment of political claims regarding historical race relations and policy impacts.

Key Facts

  • Florida Democratic gubernatorial candidate David Jolly stated during a campaign stop that U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds suggested there were good parts of Jim Crow.
  • PolitiFact rated Jolly's claim 'Half True', concluding it lacked crucial context.
  • Byron Donalds stated at a 2024 event in Philadelphia that 'During Jim Crow, the Black family was together' and that more Black people voted conservatively during that era.
  • Donalds later clarified that his remarks focused on higher marriage rates among Black Americans during that historical period rather than endorsing discriminatory laws.
  • Research shows that the percentage of Black women ages 40 to 44 who said they have ever been married fell from 94% in 1930 to 63% in 2012.
  • Researchers note that multiple factors influenced family structure changes, including job shifts in manufacturing during the 1970s and 1980s and changes in women's employment.
  • Experts state that determining whether Black people voted more conservatively during the Jim Crow era is difficult because Black people were largely disenfranchised in the South at the time.

Who's Mentioned