POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsLos Angeles Times – CaliforniaNovember 2, 2026Los Angeles County

Former Angels executive Eric Kay files new appeal to overturn conviction in Tyler Skaggs overdose death

Photo: Los Angeles Times – California

Former Los Angeles Angels media relations executive Eric Kay filed a 75-page federal appeal asking a judge to vacate his 2022 conviction and order a new trial in the fentanyl-related overdose death of baseball player Tyler Skaggs. Kay argues his trial attorney pressured him to reject a plea deal and that evidence from Skaggs' phone was unreliable or mishandled by law enforcement.

Read the full story at Los Angeles Times – California

Why It Matters

The legal filing challenges a federal conviction that resulted in a prison sentence extending to February 2041, raising questions about police handling of digital evidence and trial counsel effectiveness.

Key Facts

  • Eric Kay filed a 75-page federal appeal in Texas requesting that his 2022 conviction be vacated and a new trial ordered.
  • Kay is currently serving a sentence with a scheduled release date of Feb. 18, 2041, at the Federal Correctional Institution in Englewood, Colorado.
  • The appeal contends that Kay's trial attorney, Michael Molfetta, pressured him to turn down a prosecution plea offer of five to 10 years in prison.
  • The filing alleges detective Delaney Green gave inaccurate testimony regarding who extracted data from Tyler Skaggs' phone.
  • The appeal states that police lost or no longer have the external hard drive containing raw data extracted from Skaggs' phone.
  • Kay's attorneys argue that Skaggs' phone continued to receive messages after his death, indicating potential evidence tampering or alteration.
  • Toxicology reports showed Skaggs had alcohol, oxycodone, oxymorphone, and fentanyl in his system at the time of his death on July 1, 2019.
  • Judge Terry R. Means previously ruled that Kay could introduce new details regarding the evidence from his conviction.
  • A previous appeal by Kay was denied three years ago by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.
  • Federal prosecutors have until Dec. 31 to respond to the latest appeal.

Who's Mentioned