POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Rules

Tuesday, February 3, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

This document is a record of a meeting held by the Florida Senate Committee on Rules on February 3, 2026. The meeting lasted approximately two hours and three minutes.

Why it matters

This record confirms the occurrence of a legislative committee meeting, which is a required step for bills to advance through the Florida Senate process.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

People and votes

Clay Yarborough

State Senator District 4

Open person dossier

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 28, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 94,901 stored characters

>> GOOD MORNING EVERYONE. THE COMMITTEE ON RULES WILL NOW COME TO ORDER. CINDY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. >> CHAIR PASSIDOMO >> HERE >> VICE CHAIR JONES SENATOR AVILA SENATOR BERMAN SENATOR BOYD SENATOR BRADLEY SENAOTR BRODER SENATOR BURGESS SENATOR BURTON SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. QUORUM PRESENT. >> Chair: YOU KNOW THE DRILL. SILENCE ELECTRONIC DEVICES AND IF YOU'RE WISHING TO SPEAK COMPLETE AN APPEARANCE FORM AND HAND IT TO A MEMBER OF THE SERGEANTS OFFICE. IF YOU WANT TO WAIVE YOUR SPEAKING TIME YOUR POSITION WILL BE INCLUDED IN THE COMMITTEE MEETING RECORDS. OKAY WE WILL START WITH SENATOR MAYFIELD TAB 16. SB 7024 ON OGSR CYBER SECURITY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY OPERATIONAL BY GOVERNMENTAL ACCOUNTABILITY. >> Senator Mayfield: THANK YOU FOR PUTTING THIS ON YOUR AGENDA. SPB 7024 THE BILL SAVES THE REPEAL FROM CURRENT PUBLIC RECORDS AND PUBLIC READING DISH MEETING PROJECTIONS FOR CYBERSECURITY INFORMATION BY DELAYING THE REPEAL DATE OCTOBER 22nd, 2031, AND CONSOLIDATE SEVERAL AGENCY SPECIFIC CYBERSECURITY EXEMPTIONS INTO ONE AGENCY BY EXEMPTION AND THAT'S THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? NO APPEARANCE FORMS. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE. >> Senator Mayfield: WAIVE CLOSE. >> Chair: PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. VICE CHAIR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SB 724 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. NEXT WE WILL TAKE UP TAB SEVENTEEN SB 7026 OGSR TRADE SECRET HELD BY AGENCY BY GOVERNMENTAL OVERSIGHT ACCOUNTABILITY SENATOR MAYFIELD YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> Senator Mayfield: THIS SAVES REPEAL THE CURRENT RECORD EXEMPTION FOR TRADE SECRETS HELD BY NONAGENCY THE BILL ALSO CONSOLIDATE SEVERAL SPECIFIC TRADE SECRET EXEMPTIONS INTO ONE AGENCY WIDE EXEMPTION AND THAT'S THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS? OKAY NO APPEARANCE FORMS. DEBATE. >> Senator Mayfield: WAIVE CLOSE. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL ON SB 7026. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. VICE CHAIR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SB 7026 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. >> Senator Mayfield: THANK YOU CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. >> Chair: SENATOR TRUENOW HAS TWO BILLS. WE WILL TAKE UP TAB 12. CS FOR SB 806 ON CONSUMER RIGHT TO REPAIR CERTAIN WEAPONS. SENATOR TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >> Senator Truenow: THANK YOU. MEMBERS, THIS IS A BILL WE WORKED ON LAST YEAR AND WE ARE BACK AGAIN. SENATE BILL 806 CREATES THE PORTABLE WIRELESS DEVICE REPAIR ACT AIMED AT EXPANDING REPAIR OPTIONS FOR CONSUMERS AND REDUCING MANUFACTURING CONTROLLED REPAIR MONOPOLIES. ALSO ESTABLISHES THE AGRICULTURE EQUIPMENT REPAIR ACT, ENSURING FARMERS AND INDEPENDENT MECHANICS CAN ACCESS THE NECESSARY DIAGNOSTIC SOFTWARE AND REPAIR DATA TO MAINTAIN AND FIX EQUIPMENT. THE BILL SEEKS TO INCREASE CONSUMER CHOICE AND SUPPORT SMALL REPAIR BUSINESS AND ELECTRONIC DOWN TIME REDUCED BY RESERVING PROTECTIONS FOR TRADE SECRETS AND PROPRIETARY INFORMATION AND THAT IS THE BILL MADAM CHAIR. >> Chair: ARE THERE QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? THERE ARE A NUMBER OF APPEARANCE FORMS. CAMERON FINK ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF FLORIDA WAIVES AGAINST. AND KATIE KELLY WAIVES AGAINST. TURNER LOW MADISON INSTITUTE WAIVES AGAINST. IS THERE DEBATE ON THE BILL? SENATOR TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> Senator Truenow: THANK YOU FOR HEARING THE BILL TODAY. I ASK FOR YOUR FAVORABLE SUPPORT. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL FOR CS FOR SB 806. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. VICE CHAIR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE CS FOR SB 806 REPORTS FAVORABLY. NEXT TAB 15 SB 7020 OGSR AGRICULTURE RECORDS HELD BY THE DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE SERVICES. SENATOR TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >> Senator Truenow: MEMBERS, IN 2020 THIS WAS THE PUBLIC RECORD EXEMPTION TO PROTECT CERTAIN PUBLIC'S SHELLFISH FACILITIES AND THE SUBMERGED LAND LEASES HELD BY THE PART OF AGRICULTURAL SERVICES THIS IS SET TO EXPIRE THIS YEAR AND LESS REACTIVE ARE THE LEGISLATURE. AFTER DISCUSSION IT IS RECOMMENDED TO REENACT THE EXEMPTION. THAT IS THE BILL. >> Chair: ARE THERE QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? THERE ARE NO APPEARANCE FORMS. IS THERE DEBATE? SENATOR TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> Senator Truenow: WAIVE CLOSE. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL ON THIS BILL. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. VICE CHAIR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SB 7020 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. NEXT HAVE FIVE SB 308 ON FLORIDA MUSEUM OF BLACK HISTORY BY SENATOR LEEK. SENATOR LEEK YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >> Senator Leek: THANK YOU. THIS BILL IT PASSED UNANIMOUSLY UP ON THE SENATE FLOOR LAST YEAR BUT IT WAS PAST THE 2020 RIGOROUS LIVE SESSION CREATING A BLACK HISTORY TASK FORCE APPOINTED BY THE GOVERNOR AND THE SPEAKER FOR PURPOSES OF PROVIDING RECORDATIONS AND PLANNING OPERATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF FLORIDA'S FIRST MUSEUM OF BLACK HISTORY. SENATE BILL 308 INFLUENCED THE WORK OF THE TASK FORCE DESIGNATING ST. JOHNS COUNTY AS THE SITE FOR THE MUSEUM AND ESTABLISHES THE FLORIDA MUSEUM OF BLACK HISTORY BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND DIRECTS THE BOARD TO WORK JOINTLY WITH THE FOUNDATION OF THE MUSEUM OF BLACK HISTORY. AND IT DIRECTS ST. JOHNS COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS TO PROVIDE ADMINISTRATION SYSTEMS DURING THE PLANNING OF THE PROJECT. THAT IS THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? THERE ARE A NUMBER OF APPEARANCE FORMS. WE WILL START WITH GARY MCINTOSH. I GUESS THEY ARE NOT HERE. THERE YOU ARE. I'M SORRY. COME UP. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> GOOD MORNING. I AM HERE TO SUPPORT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. ONE OF THE GREAT THINGS ABOUT IT IS I LEARNED NOTHING ABOUT THIS IN SCHOOL. AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. I THINK THAT NOT ONLY SHOULD AFRICAN AMERICANS LEARN ABOUT THE HISTORY OF OUR PEOPLE BUT EVERYONE SHOULD LEARN ABOUT IT. IT IS AMERICAN HISTORY FROM THE TIME WE ARRIVED ON THE SHORE OF THIS GREAT COUNTRY UNTIL NOW WHERE WE CAN SIT AND STAND AS BROTHERS AND SISTERS WITH YOU. BUT THE GREATEST THING ABOUT THIS IS NO ONE EVER TAUGHT IN SCHOOL ABOUT THE GREAT HISTORY OF OUR PEOPLE IN AFRICA WHEN WE BUILT THE GREAT PYRAMIDS OR WHEN WE GOT TO THE SHORE AND TRAINED YOUR PEOPLE AND HORSE BREAKING IN THE GREAT COTTON FIELDS OF THIS COUNTRY. CERTAIN THINGS HAPPENED THAT SHOULD HAVE NOT HAPPENED BUT IT DID HAPPEN. SO AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS THE HISTORY OF AMERICA AND, SO, IT IS INCUMBENT UPON ALL OF US TO MAKE SURE THAT THE HISTORY OF OUR PEOPLE ARE PROTECTED MAKING SURE THAT WE TEACH THIS HISTORY TO EVERYONE. EVERYONE SHOULD BE TAUGHT THE GREATNESS OF AMERICA IS THAT WE DON'T ERASE HISTORY BECAUSE WE DON'T THINK IT OUGHT TO BE TAUGHT. ONE OF THE GREAT THINGS ABOUT IT IS THAT I UNDERSTOOD EARLY ON WHEN I GOT IN HIGH SCHOOL WAS THE FIRST AND REALLY HEARD ANYTHING ABOUT HARRIET TUBMAN OR SOJOURNER TRUTH OR FREDERICK DOUGLASS OR CARTER WILSON. A WHOLE HOST OF PEOPLE. GRAND WOULD GREEN THAT IF WE DIDN'T HAVE HIM WE WOULDN'T HAVE THE SIGNALS AND RED LIGHTS AND ALL THE THINGS THAT HAVE SAFETY. WINDSHIELD WIPERS, THE WHOLE GAMUT OF THINGS THAT WE USE. REFRIGERATORS. INVENTIONS THAT HAVE SAVED AMERICA AND SAVED OUR FOOD PRODUCTS. FERTILIZER. CARTER G WILSON. ALL THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE FOR FOOD AND SAFETY AND GAS MASKS YOU KNOW. THE LIST OF THINGS GOES ON AND ON AND ON. I WILL BRING THIS LIST TO THE COUNTRY THAT HAS TAUGHT OUR CHILDREN EVERYONE ELSE'S CHILDREN SO IT IS INCUMBENT UPON THIS BODY. THIS IS A ROBUST BODY MAKING SURE THAT THOSE THINGS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN TAUGHT SHOULD BE TAUGHT AND SHOULD BE HONORED BECAUSE WE HAVE HONORED EVERYONE ELSE'S HISTORY IN THIS COUNTRY AND IT IS INCUMBENT UPON THIS BODY TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR HISTORY IS HONORED AS WELL. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR THE TESTIMONY. DOCTOR ALLISON CLARKE WITH EQUAL GROUND ACTION FUND IS HERE WITH INFORMATION. DO YOU HAVE INFORMATION FOR US? YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> I DIDN'T WANT TO INTERJECT BEFORE. GOOD MORNING. I'M DOCTOR ALLISON CLARKE. I WAS EDUCATED AT THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA. AND I HAVE AN EARNED A PHD FROM MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY. I WANT TO SPEAK ABOUT THE MUSEUM BECAUSE I HAVE CONCERNS GIVEN WHAT HAS COME FROM TALLAHASSEE REGARDING A BLACK HISTORY. AND AFRICAN AMERICANS IN GENERAL. THERE IS AN ARTICLE THAT WAS PUBLISHED ON JANUARY 20 PBS NEWS WITH THE HEADLINE DESANTIS DEFENDS BLOCKING AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSES IN FLORIDA. IN THE ARTICLE QUOTES HIM AS SAYING IT'S OKAY TO TEACH THE HISTORY BUT ADVANCED PLACEMENT COURSES MIGHT INDOCTRINATE. MY CONCERN IS HOW EFFECTIVE AND HOW REFLECTIVE OF HISTORY IS THIS MUSEUM GOING TO BE? WHO WILL BE THE COMMITTEE THAT WILL SELECT WHAT WILL GO INTO THAT MUSEUM? I WAS HONORED TO BE IN WASHINGTON DC WHEN DOCTOR MACLEOD WAS INSTALLED IN STATUARY HALL. SHE STANDS NEXT TO ROSA PARKS. AND I HAVE SPOKEN TO FRIENDS GIVEN OUR CURRENT POLITICAL SITUATION AND WOULD SHE MAKE IT INTO STATUARY HALL, I DON'T THINK SO. WE WANT HISTORY TO BE ACCURATE. TELL THE TRUTH. FEELINGS, CONCERNS ABOUT FEELINGS. PLEASE BE ACCURATE. PLEASE TELL THE TRUTH. THAT'S A REQUEST. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. SARAH NIXON EQUAL GROUND ACTION FUND. >> GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. I AM HERE ON BEHALF OF EQUAL GROUND ACTION FUND TO SUPPORT SENATE BILL 308 AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE FLORIDA MUSEUM A BLACK HISTORY BOARD OF DIRECTORS. IT IS MEANINGFUL THAT WE ARE DISCUSSING THIS BILL DURING BLACK HISTORY MONTH. A TIME WHERE WE PAUSE TO HONOR THE CONTRIBUTIONS, STRUGGLES, AND ACHIEVEMENTS OF BLACK AMERICANS. BUT HONORING HISTORY REQUIRES MORE THAN REFLECTION. IT REQUIRES US TO TELL THE ACCURATE STORY. I COME BEFORE YOU NOT ONLY AS PERSON BUT SOMEONE WHO HAS SHAVED BY BLACK HISTORY. I WAS FORTUNATE TO LEARN TRUE BLACK FLORIDA HISTORY FOR MY GRANDPARENTS WHO LIFTED AND UNDERSTOOD HOW IMPORTANT IT WAS TO PASS THESE STORIES DOWN. GROWING UP IN THE OAKLAND NEIGHBORHOOD IN JACKSONVILLE'S HISTORIC EAST SIDE I ATTENDED AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL NAMED AFTER RICHARD LOUIS BROWN AN ARCHITECT WHO SERVED IN THE FLORIDA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES FROM 1881 UNTIL 84. I WALK THE SAME STREETS WERE A FILIP RANDOLPH WHO ORGANIZED THE MARCH ON WASHINGTON WAS RAISED. I SUNG THE NEGRO NATIONAL ANTHEM I LIFT EVERY VOICE WRITTEN BY JACKSONVILLE'S OWN JAMES JOHNSON AND HIS BROTHER JOHN ROSEMAN. I TELL YOU EVEN NOW AS I WALK THESE CHAMBERS I'M STILL IN AWE THAT I'M WALKING THE SAME PAD IS AS SENATOR KERRY MAKE REPRESENTATIVE WHEN CHERRY, REPRESENTATIVE MARY SINGLETON, AND SENATOR BETTY DORF. IT STILL MOVES ME TO THIS DAY. THAT CONNECTION TO HISTORY HAS TAUGHT ME SOMETHING IMPORTANT. WHO GETS TO TELL THE STORY IT MATTERS. MUSEUMS ARE POWERFUL PLACES. THEY SHAPE HOW WE UNDERSTAND OUR SHARED PAST. THEY DECIDE WHAT STORIES GET PRESERVED AND WHICH VOICES ARE HEARD GOVERNMENT STRUCTURE YOU ARE CREATING FOR THIS BILL WILL DETERMINE WHETHER THIS MUSEUM LIVES UP TO THAT RESPONSIBILITY. IN RECENT YEARS AND HE FLORIDA HAS MADE DECISIONS THAT HAVE MADE US QUESTION HOW BLACK HISTORY WILL BE REJECTING AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES, REVISING SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS IN WAYS THAT CONCERN EDUCATORS AND HISTORIANS. AND INCREASING RESTRICTIONS ON CLASSROOM DISCUSSIONS ABOUT RACE AND HISTORY. GIVEN THAT CONTEXT THIS COMMITTEE HAS AN OPPORTUNITY TO ENSURE THE MUSEUM WILL BE ABLE TO TELL THE FULL TRUTH. BLACK FLORIDA HISTORY SHOULD NOT BE SANITIZED TO MAKE PEOPLE FEEL COMFORTABLE. I LEARNED WHAT THE TRAGEDY ON A SATURDAY DIRECTLY FROM HISTORIAN RODNEY L HURST WHO AT THAT TIME WAS A TEENAGER. THIS IS THAT THEY NAACP IN 1916. I STOOD AT THE OLD SLAVE MARKET AND ST. JOHNS COUNTY IN SAINT AUGUSTINE WHILE CIVIL RIGHTS ACTIVIST HOSEA WILLIAMS, ANDREW YOUNG, AND DOCTOR MARTIN WITH THE KING JUNIOR ALMOST LOST THEIR LIVES WHILE MARCHING AGAINST THIS HELPED LAY THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1964. MY UNDERSTANDING OF BLACK HISTORY GREW DEEPER AT FLORIDA A&M UNIVERSITY WHERE I WAS ABLE TO VISIT THE BLACK ARCHIVES LEARNING FROM THE WORK OF DEDICATED SCHOLARS. I WITNESSED WHAT GOOD LUCK HISTORY EDUCATION LOOKS LIKE AND THEY UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TELLING THE TRUTH AND MAKING IT EASIER TO DIGEST. BLACK FLORIDIANS HISTORY IS ONE OF INCREDIBLE ACHIEVEMENT AND STRENGTH IN THE TREMENDOUS HARDSHIPS BUT YOU CANNOT TELL THE STORY HONESTLY WITHOUT TALKING ABOUT THE INJUSTICES THAT HAVE SHAPED IT. THAT HISTORY INCLUDES SLAVERY AND WE NEED TO CALL IT WHAT IT WAS. A BRUTAL SYSTEM BUILT ON DEHUMANIZATION. IT INCLUDES THE OCOEE MASSACRE OF 1920 WHEN BLACK PEOPLE WERE KILLED FOR TRYING TO VOTE. IT INCLUDES ROSEWOOD WHERE A MOB DESTROYED AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY. IT INCLUDES 15 YEAR OLD WILLIE HOWARD A SUWANEE COUNTY WHO SENT A LOVE NOTE TO A GIRL OF A DIFFERENT RACE AND INCLUDES HARRIET MORE A FLORIDA COUPLE KILLED BY A BOMB IN THEIR HOME ON CHRISTMAS NIGHT IN 1951 BECAUSE THEY REGISTERED BLACK VOTERS. IT INCLUDES DECADES OF JIM CROW SEGREGATION LAWS, VIOLENT TERRORISM, AND ECONOMIC EXPECTATION. IT INCLUDES RESISTANCE. ORGANIZING, PROTESTING, COURT BATTLES AND EVERYDAY COURAGE OF PEOPLE WHO INSISTED THAT WE SHALL OVERCOME. EVEN WHEN. >> Chair: MISS NIXON YOU WERE GOING FOR FOUR AND A HALF MINUTES. >> OKAY I CAN CONCLUDE. YES I CAN. WHAT WE WANT IS FLORIDA TO BUILD ON SOMETHING THAT WE CAN GENERALLY BE PROUD OF NOT SOMETHING THAT FEELS GOOD BUT WE ALSO WANT TO HOLD PEOPLE ACCOUNTABLE TO MAKE SURE THAT THE REQUIREMENT OF THE BOARD MEMBERS PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE IN AN AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY MUSEUM STUDIES AND FLORIDA HISTORY, SECONDLY, THAT THE PUBLIC HAS INPUT HISTORY WILL BE TAUGHT THERE AND LASTLY TO ADD PROTECTIONS TO ENSURE THAT THE MUSEUM EDUCATIONAL CONTENT REMAINS GROUNDED IN HISTORICAL TRUTH. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. LET'S TRY TO KEEP REMARKS DOWN TO THREE MINUTES SO WE CAN GET TO OUR AGENDA TODAY. NEXT DEREK SCOTT. AFTER HIM IS DEREK TRIPLETT. MR. SCOTT YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> GOOD MORNING TO THE CHAIR, VICE CHAIR, GOOD MORNING, AND GREETINGS. TODAY ON THIS THIRD DAY OF THE HUNDRED YEAR ANNIVERSARY OF BLACK HISTORY MONTH I RISE IN SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL 308. A BIPARTISAN EFFORT TO ESTABLISH THE FLORIDA MUSEUM A BLACK HISTORY BOARD OF DIRECTORS A CRITICAL STEP TOWARD REALIZING A LONG AWAITED CULTURAL AND EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION IN OUR STATE. THIS LEGISLATION FORMALLY RECOGNIZES THE DILIGENT WORK OF THE FLORIDA MUSEUM OF BLACK HISTORY TASK FORCE AND THE THOUGHTFUL SITE SELECTION PROCESS THAT HAS IDENTIFIED ST. JOHNS COUNTY AS THE MUSEUM'S HOME. THE PROPOSED MUSEUM WILL SERVE NOT ONLY AS A REPOSITORY OF HISTORY BUT AS A LIVING MONUMENT TO THE PROFOUND CONTRIBUTIONS OF BLACK FLORIDIANS. FROM THE EARLIEST DAYS OF THE SETTLEMENT THROUGH CIVIL RIGHTS ERA INTO THE MODERN AGE BY ESTABLISHING A DEDICATED BOARD OF DIRECTORS TO OVERSEE THE COMMISSION CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF THE MUSEUM THIS BILL ENSURES THAT THE PROJECT HAS THE GOVERNANCE AND THE STEWARDSHIP NECESSARY FOR A SUCCESS. THE STRUCTURE OUTLINED IN THIS A BILL INVITES COLLABORATION ACROSS BRANCHES OF GOVERNMENT AND NONPROFIT PARTNERS, AND COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDERS FOSTERING ACCOUNTABILITY, TRANSPARENCY, AND BROAD PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT. IMPORTANTLY THIS MUSEUM WILL BE IT WILL BE AN EDUCATIONAL CATALYST INSPIRING STUDENTS AND SCHOLARS AND VISITORS FROM ACROSS OUR STATE AND NATION TO LEARN FROM THE PAST AND IMAGINE A MORE INCLUSIVE AND JUST AND FAIR FUTURE. IT IS INVESTMENT IN EDUCATION, TOURISM, HERITAGE, AND MORE IMPORTANTLY UNITY VALUES THAT STRENGTHEN OUR STATE'S SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC FABRIC. SENATE BILL 308 OFFERS FLORIDA AN OPPORTUNITY TO LEAD BY EXAMPLE. TO CELEBRATE OUR DIVERSE HISTORY, HONOR THOSE WHO STORIES HAVE BEEN OVERLOOKED, AND WHITEWASHED, AND TO PROVIDE A SPACE FOR ALL FLORIDIANS FOR THEM TO LEARN AND GROW TOGETHER. I URGE YOU TO SUPPORT THIS BILL AND HELP BRING THE VISION TO LIFE. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY FOLLOWED BY MARY HOLCOMBE. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> MADAME CHAIR AND COMMITTEE, THANK YOU SENATOR LEEK AND OTHER SPONSORS OF THIS BILL FOR BRING IT FORWARD AND I AM ALSO IN WITH THE ACCOUNTABILITY OF WHO TELLS A STORY IS IMPORTANT. QUICK STORY, A MILLION YEARS AGO I'M FROM THE DAYTONA BEACH AREA AND A MILLION YEARS AGO I WAS LEADING A GROUP IN OUR LEADERSHIP ORGANIZATION. DAYTONA 19. SO, WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF DAYTONA BEACH. AND, SO, I CALLED A FRIEND OF MINE AND SAID I NEED A VAN TO TAKE A GROUP OF PEOPLE TO A NEIGHBORHOOD THAT THEY HAVE NEVER BEEN. I TOOK A GROUP OF BUSINESSPEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY DOWN A STREET CALLED QUAY STREET AND IT IS A PREDOMINATELY AFRICAN AMERICAN NEIGHBORHOOD AND I COULD HEAR THE WHISPERS IN THE BACK OF THE VAN. I TOOK THEM TO A PARTICULAR HOUSING PROJECT WHERE THEY DISCOVERED AND I HEARD SOMEONE SAY AN ENTIRE FAMILY LIVES HERE? SOMEONE SAID SOMETIMES TWO TO THREE FAMILIES LIVE HERE. AND SOMEONE SAID I HAVE LIVED IN THE CITY ALL MY LIFE AND I HAVE NEVER BEEN DOWN THE STREET. IT MATTERS WHO TELLS A STORY. IT MATTERS WHO IS IN CONTROL THE NARRATIVE BUT WE DON'T ENSURE THAT BLACK HISTORIANS AND COMMUNITY HISTORIANS WILL TELL THE WHOLE TRUTH THEN WE DON'T ENSURE THAT THEY ARE LEADING THE AND THE TRUTH GETS TWISTED IN 25 YEARS. AND EVERYBODY THEN WAKES UP IN 25 YEARS AND OUR READING, LEARNING, EXPERIENCING INDULGED IN WHAT IS TRUTH BUT DEPENDING UPON WHO TOLD IT 25 YEARS AGO IT COULD BE A LOT DIFFERENT REALLY SO WE ARE ENCOURAGING YOU TO MAKE SURE THE CONTROL AND THE NARRATIVE THAT WE ARE INCLUDING IN OUR HISTORY IS NOT SANITIZED. >> Chair: THANK YOU. DEREK HOLTON FOLLOWED BY GENESIS ROBINSON. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR, VICE CHAIR, I STAND IN SUPPORT OF THIS PROPOSED BILL. I HAVE THE SAME CONCERNS THAT PREVIOUS SPEAKERS HAVE SPOKEN ABOUT. IT IS IMPORTANT WHO TELLS THE STORY. AND IT IS SOMETHING REALLY AS YOU PUT TOGETHER THIS BOARD OF DIRECTORS IS NOT A BOARD OF DIRECTORS WITH ALL DUE RESPECT TO THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE BUT HIS ATTITUDE HAS BEEN VERY CLEAR AND I DON'T THINK THAT PARTICULAR ATTITUDE NEEDS TO FIND ITSELF ON THIS BOARD. TO BE FRANK. AND WE HAVE TO BE TRUE TO THINE OWN SELF. HE HAS HAD VERBALLY SPOKEN INCREDIBLY NEGATIVE THINGS ABOUT QUOTE DDI, ABOUT SLAVERY TO BLACK PEOPLE AND I THINK WE REALLY DO HAVE TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT WHO SITS ON THIS BOARD. THAT WAY AS SO MANY WHO'VE ALREADY SPOKE TO HIM THAT THE TRUTH IS ACTUALLY WRITTEN. AND NOT SOMETHING THAT IS WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, WHITEWASHED. AND MADE OTHERS COMFORTABLE. HISTORY IS NOT ABOUT MAKING PEOPLE COMFORTABLE ABOUT TELLING AND SPEAKING THE TRUTH. SO I DO SUPPORT THIS BILL. I HOPE THAT WANT TO BECOMES REALITY THAT HISTORY IS ACTUALLY SPOKEN TRUTHFULLY. >> Chair: GENESIS ROBINSON. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> THANK YOU AND GOOD MORNING TO MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME AND SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL FROM MY HOMETOWN SENATOR LEEK. I AM GENESIS ROBINSON AND I'M THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE EQUAL BROWN EDUCATION FUNDING BLACK LEAD VOTING RIGHTS ORGANIZATION THROUGHOUT THE STATE INCREASING CIVIC ENGAGEMENT ARE THE BLACK COMMUNITY. TODAY WE HIT THIS WE KICKED OFF EQUAL BROWN DAY IN THE CAPITAL BRINGING ADVOCATES ACROSS THE STATE TO THE CAPITAL TO TALK TO THE LEGISLATURES DISH LEGISLATORS BUT THE ISSUES THAT MATTER MOST TO THE COMMUNITY. AS WE ALSO CELEBRATE THE BEGINNING OF BLACK HISTORY MONTH I THINK IT IS QUITE BEFITTING THAT WE HAVE THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT THE CREATION OF A BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM OF FLORIDA. A MUSEUM DEDICATED TO THE BLACK EXPERIENCE IN THE STATE IS LONG OVERDUE. BLACK FLORIDIANS HELP BUILD FLORIDA ECONOMICALLY, CULTURALLY, POLITICALLY, SOCIALLY. IN AGRICULTURE TO MILITARY SERVICE TO CIVIL RIGHTS LEADERSHIP IN TODAY'S WORKFORCE AND CULTURAL INFLUENCE. THAT HISTORY DESERVES AND MADE VISIBLE. BUT AS WE ALL KNOW FLORIDA'S HISTORY IS COMPLICATED. THIS IS THE STATE WHERE JULY. HE WAS LYNCHED. IN THE TOWN OF OCOEE IT WAS DESTROYED SOLELY BECAUSE THEY WANT TO ENGAGE BLACK RESIDENTS. AND THE CO COY MASSACRE WIPED AN ENTIRE POPULATION OF BLACK PEOPLE AWAY FROM THEIR HOMES. THIS IS THE STATE THAT ATTEMPTED TO SECEDE FROM THE UNION TO PRESERVE THE INSTITUTION OF SLAVERY. THIS IS THE STATE WHERE EMANCIPATION DID NOT COME ON JANUARY 1st BECAME HENCE WHY WE CELEBRATE EMANCIPATION DAY IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA. THIS IS ALSO THE STATE WHERE BLACK CHILDREN WERE DENIED EQUAL EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR GENERATIONS. AND YET THIS IS ALL THE STATE WERE BLACK FLORIDIANS HAVE ORGANIZED AND BUILD SCHOOLS AND CHURCHES AND FORMED MUTUAL AID AND FOUGHT IN WARS AND CHALLENGED AND JUSTICE IN COURTS. THE FULL STORY DOES MATTER. WHAT WE UNEQUIVOCALLY SUPPORT THE IDEA OF BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM IN CONCEPT A BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM MUST REFLECT BOTH THE HARM AND THE HERALD AND THE BRUTALITY AND THE AND THE OPPRESSION AND THE RESISTANCE. FLORIDA HAS RECENTLY MOVED TO RESTRICT HOW RACE, RACISM, AND BLACK HISTORY CAN BE TAUGHT IN CLASSROOMS AND PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS. WE BANNED BOOKS THAT TEACH ABOUT THE BLACK EXPERIENCE. AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSES HAVE BEEN DENIED AS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR CHILDREN TO LEARN. CONVERSATION ABOUT RACE, PRIVILEGE, AND DEPRESSION HAVE BEEN CENSORED. SO, YES WE DO SUPPORT THE FLORIDA BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM BUT WE ALSO HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT THE MAKEUP OF THAT MUSEUM. A MUSEUM CANNOT PRESENT A SANITIZED VERSION OF HISTORY. IT CANNOT AVOID THE TRUTH ABOUT SLAVERY, SEGREGATION, RACIAL TERROR AND VOTER SUPPRESSION OR THE THAT IS IN EXCUSE ME, HISTORY THAT IS INCOMPLETE IS HISTORY THAT IS DISTORTED AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE CALLING ON THE STATE AND THE NEWLY ESTABLISHED MUSEUM BOARD TO MEANINGFULLY CONSULT WITH BLACK HISTORIANS, PROFESSORS, MUSEUM PROFESSIONALS, CURATORS, RESEARCHERS, AND COMMUNITY ELDERS, THE PEOPLE OF STUDIED AND PRESERVE THE HISTORY MUST BE CENTRAL TO DETERMINING WHAT IS TAUGHT AND DISPLAYED. IF DONE RIGHT THE FLORIDA BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM CAN BE A POWERFUL EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION THAT HONORS THE FULL EXPERIENCE OF BLACK FLORIDIANS AND HELPS RESIDENTS BETTER UNDERSTAND OUR HISTORY. EQUAL GROUND SUPPORTS THIS BILL AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH ALL INVOLVED TO ENSURE THAT THE MUSEUM TELLS THE TRUTH AND REFLECTS OUR TRUE HISTORY. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. BILL LOUIS WAIVES IN SUPPORT. IS THERE DEBATE ON THIS BILL? SENATOR HARRELL. >> Senator Harrell: THANK YOU AND THANK YOU SENATOR LEEK FOR PRESENTING THIS EXCELLENT BILL AND I DO HAVE ONE SUGGESTION HOWEVER. I THINK WE HAVE HEARD SUCH BRILLIANT TESTIMONY THIS MORNING ON HOW WE MUST PRESENT A REALISTIC VIEW OF BLACK HISTORY IN FLORIDA. THAT IS ACTUALLY ESSENTIAL. BUT ALSO I DID ONE ASK YOU TO INCLUDE WHEN I LOOK AT THE LIST OF THINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ARTIFACTS AND ACQUISITIONS AND RESEARCH. I WANT TO ADD A CLASSIC EXAMPLE OF THE POSITIVE CONTRIBUTIONS THAT SO MANY BLACK ARTISTS AND THAT'S THAT HAVE OFFERED AND GIVEN TO THE STATE OF FLORIDA NOT JUST ART BUT CULTURE SO I WANT TO SEE A POSITIVE ADDITION HERE THAT WE EMPHASIZE AS WELL THE POSITIVE CONTRIBUTIONS THAT ARE BEING MADE THAT HAVE BEEN MADE IN THE PAST AND I WOULD LIKE A SPECIAL SECTION DEDICATED TO THE HIGHWAY. >> Chair: OTHER DEBATE? SENATOR LEEK, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE. I'M SORRY I DID NOT SEE YOU THERE. >> Senator Rouson: I WILL SAVE MUCH OF MY, FOR WHEN THIS BILL HITS THE BUT I DO WANT TO TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO THANK YOU SENATOR LEEK FOR FOLLOWING THROUGH ON THIS LEGISLATION. AT A TIME WHEN IT'S NOT POPULAR TO HIGHLIGHT BLACK HISTORY AND I HOPE THAT YOU WILL JOIN US TODAY AT 4:00 P.M. WHEN HISTORY ONCE AGAIN WILL BE MADE AS CHAIR OF THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS ON BEHALF OF OUR MEMBERS WE WILL BE DEDICATING THE CIRCLE OF CHANGE MEMORIAL TO THE ENSLAVED PEOPLE IN FLORIDA THAT SUFFER THE INDIGNITY OF SLAVERY. WE DO SO AND AT THE SAME TIME WE DO SO WE THINK THE DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT SERVICES AND THE GOVERNOR FOR FOLLOWING THROUGH ON LEGISLATION THAT FORMER REPRESENTATIVE MAGEE SPONSORED IN THE HOUSE AND I SPONSORED IN THE SENATE THAT CREATED THIS MEMORIAL. THOSE WHO WERE ENSLAVED IN THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF A FLORIDA TO SLAVERY WERE NOT NAMELESS, FACELESS, THEY ARE NOT VISIBLE. THEY WERE PEOPLE. AND WE HONOR THEIR MEMORY TODAY AT 4:00 AT 19 APALACHEE PARKWAY. ACROSS THE STREET FROM [INAUDIBLE]. I THINK WE ARE ACROSS FROM THE CAPITOL. I THINK WE’RE THE ONLY CAPITOL IN THE UNITED STATES WITH SUCH MEMORIAL. AND I LOOK FORWARD TO MAKING IT INTO THE MUSEUM. THANK YOU. >> Chair: SENATOR OSGOOD. >> Senator Osgood: THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THANK YOU SENATOR LEEK FOR BRINGING THIS TO BILL AT THIS TIME WE HAVE BEEN LISTENING TO THE TESTIMONIES. WE CELEBRATED MLK DAY AND WE HAD A MEMO COME OUT FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE THAT REALLY IN A POSTURE A FEELING ATTACKED AND HURT. JUST REFLECTING BACK ON WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO OUR ANCESTORS AND THE CONSTANT STRUGGLE WE HAVE HAD TO ENDURE JUST TRYING TO GET AND LIVE THE AMERICAN DREAM. I'M HAPPY WITH THIS BILL TODAY ESPECIALLY AT THIS PARTICULAR TIME DURING BLACK HISTORY MONTH. WE KNOW THE STATE OF FLORIDA HAS NO SHORTAGE ON HISTORY MUSEUMS. BUT WHAT WE LIKE IS BALANCE. WE HAVE MUSEUMS FOR MILITARY HISTORY, POLITICAL HISTORY, REGIONAL HISTORY, BUT IN NO STATE LEVEL INSTITUTION IS DEDICATED TO BLACK. DESPITE BLACK FLORIDIANS SHAPING EVERY CHAPTER OF THIS. SO SENATE BILL 308 DOES NOT REPLACE THOSE MUSEUMS BUT IT CONNECTS ELEVATES AND COMPLEMENTS FLORIDA'S HISTORICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND IN MY OPINION I BELIEVE IT COMPLETES IT. FLORIDA'S HISTORY IS ALREADY PRESERVED BUT IT IS NOT FULLY TOLD AND AS WE THINK ABOUT THIS MUSEUM THAT WILL PRESERVE BLACK HISTORY AND WILL PRESERVE THE DIVINE NINE ANOTHER GROUP THAT IS VERY HISTORIC THAT IS OFTEN LEFT OUT OF MUSEUM CIRCLES THE RELATIONSHIP WITH FLORIDA MEMORIAL, THE EDUCATIONAL PIECE, A LOT OF THE WORK THAT IS ALREADY DONE AND I BELIEVE THAT THIS ALLOWS THE STATE OF FLORIDA TO LEAD AND TELL THE FULL STORY OF HISTORY TO INCLUDE BLACK HISTORY. SEVERAL OF THE SPEAKERS MENTIONED ABOUT BLACK HISTORY BEING TOLD IN A TRUTHFUL WAY. FOR PEOPLE OF COLOR THAT THE TRUST THING. SOMETIMES WE FEEL LIKE OUR STORY IS TOLD BY OTHER PEOPLE AND IT'S NOT COMPLETE. BUT BECAUSE I AND I KNOW WHAT WE ARE DOING AND I HAVE BEEN INVOLVED THIS WILL BE YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO TELL THE COMPLETE AND FULL HISTORY. I BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL SPEAKS VOLUMES AND IS AN EXPRESSION OF OUR COMMITMENT TO TRUTH OF HISTORY AND DIGNITY OF ALL FLORIDIANS WITH AN EMPHASIS ON AFRICAN AMERICAN. THANK YOU SENATOR LEEK. >> Chair: OKAY SENATOR LEEK YOU MAY CLOSE. >> Senator Leek: BRIEFLY, FIRST I CANNOT ADDRESS EVERY CONCERN RAISED HERE TODAY BUT I WILL ADDRESS TWO. FIRST AND MY FRIENDS ARE BISHOP TRIPLETT AND GENESIS ROBINSON I CAN ADDRESS THE CONCERN OF WHETHER MARY MACLEOD WOULD CONTINUE TO BE PUSHED FORWARD IF THAT HAD NOT BEEN PASSED PRIOR, PREVIOUSLY, I CAN TELL HE WAS ONE OF THE TWO PRIME SPONSORS OF THAT BILL THAT HAD NOT PASSED SINCE SHE WAS FROM OUR COMMUNITY I PROMISE YOU THAT SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN BROUGHT UP EVERY YEAR UNTIL PAST. SECOND, AND I MUST RESPECTFULLY TELL SENATOR HARRELL KNOW, WE WILL NOT DO THAT BECAUSE I COMMITTED THAT THE STORY WILL BE TOLD NOT DIRECTED FROM TALLAHASSEE WHICH I WOULD MAKE THIS AKIN TO BUT BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND THE COMMITTEES THAT ARE PUT TOGETHER BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS THAT WILL OVERSEE THE BLACK HISTORY MUSEUM. FINALLY, AS I SAID MANY TIMES I DON'T THINK THE HISTORY OF FLORIDA CAN BE TOLD WITHOUT ALSO TELLING THE HISTORY OF BLACK FLORIDA. WHAT THIS DOES IS GIVE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE HISTORY TO BE TOLD IN THE STORY TO BE COMPLETE. WITH THAT I CLOSE. >> Chair: PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. VICE CHAIR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SP 308 REPORTS FAVORABLY. NEXT WE WILL TAKE UP TO EIGHT CS FOR SB 564 ON STUDENT VOLUNTEERS AT POLLING LOCATIONS BY SENATOR YARBOROUGH. >> Senator Yarborough: GOOD MORNING. THANK YOU FOR PUTTING THIS ON YOUR AGENDA. THIS IS FOR ELECTION RELATED EXPENSES BY AUTHORIZING FLORIDA HIGH SCHOOL REGISTERED OR PRE REGISTER TO VOTE VOLUNTEER TO ASSIST POLL WORKERS FOR RECEIVING COMMITTEE SERVICE HOURS TO MEET CERTAIN EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS. MADAM CHAIR THAT'S THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? THERE ARE A PLETHORA OF APPEARANCE FORMS. LET'S GO DOWN TO THREE MINUTES. WE WILL START WITH JACQUELINE STEELE FOLLOWED BY ZACHARY [INAUDIBLE]. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY IN SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL 564. ON JACQUELINE STEELE AS SERVE AS THE NORTH FLORIDA FIELD MANAGER OF EQUAL GROUND A BLACK LEAD VOTER EDUCATION ENGAGEMENT ORGANIZATION HERE IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA. I AM ALSO WEARING TWO OTHER HATS. AND THE MOTHER OF TEN AND ALSO HAVE WORK TO THE POLLS AND I WANT TO MAKE THIS REAL FOR YOU BECAUSE IT SITTING IN THE AUDIENCE TODAY IS MY DAUGHTER WHO IS IN EIGHTH GRADE AND SHE IS MONTHS AWAY FROM BEING ELIGIBLE TO PREREGISTER AND STEP INTO THE KIND OF CIVIC PARTICIPATION THAT THIS BILL MAKES POSSIBLE. I AM NOT SPEAKING ABOUT THIS AS AN ABSTRACT POLICY IDEA I'M SPEAKING AS A PARENT LOOKING AT MY CHILD AND THINKING THIS IS EXACTLY THE KIND OF STRUCTURED SUPERVISED COMMUNITY CENTERED OPPORTUNITY WE SHOULD BE OFFERING FOR OUR YOUNG PEOPLE. AS SOMEONE WHO HAS WORKED TO THE POLLS I CAN TELL YOU THE BIGGEST STRESS POINTS ARE NOT POLITICAL BUT OPERATIONAL. IT IS THE FLOW OF VOTERS, THE LINES BUILDING UP, MAKING SURE THAT VOTERS ARE GREETED, DIRECTED, AND SUPPORTED, ESPECIALLY THE SENIORS. FIRST TIME VOTERS, AND PEOPLE WHO NEED ACCESSIBILITY ASSISTANCE. IT'S KEEPING THE ENVIRONMENT CALM, EFFICIENT, AND RESPECTFUL SO PEOPLE FEEL CONFIDENT AND CARED FOR SO IN A POLLING PLACE IS SHORTSTAFFED EVERYTHING SLOWS DOWN, CONFUSION INCREASES, FRUSTRATION RISES, AND VOTER EXPERIENCE SUFFERS. SENATE BILL 564 OFFERS A PRACTICAL SOLUTION BY ALLOWING OUR STUDENTS WHO ARE REGISTERED OR PREREGISTER TO VOLUNTEER IN A STRUCTURED WAY UNDER ELECTION OFFICIALS FOR COMMITTEE SERVICE HOURS. IT IS A WIN ON A MULTIPLE FRONT. IT SUPPORTS ELECTION SUPERVISORS, STRENGTHENS VOTER EXPERIENCE, AND SEE FOR THE NEXT GENERATION. STUDENTS DON'T JUST LEARN IT THEY SEE IT IN ACTION. SO AS A MOTHER OF TEN I AM HERE FOR ANYTHING THAT TURNS CIVIC RESPONSIBILITY AND REAL LIFE LESSONS. WITH ADULT SUPERVISION, CLEAR RULES, AND SAFE STRUCTURE MY DAUGHTER IS BRIGHT, OBSERVANT, AND LIKE MANY KIDS OF HER AGE IT MATTERS AND WANTS TO CONTRIBUTE. I THINK THIS BILL GIVES THIS IN A VERY SUPERVISED MANNER. AND I DO SUPPORT THIS BILL AND WANT TO SUCCEED IN ITS OF LIMITATION AND I ENCOURAGE A FEW FRIENDLY GUARD THAT DO NOT CHAIR THE DEBTS CHANGE THE INTENT BUT STRENGTH CLARITY AND CONFIDENCE SPECIFICALLY DEFINING WHAT ASSISTANT POLL WORKERS MEANS AS NONSENSITIVE SUPPORT TASK REQUIRING THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS TRAINING APPROPRIATE TO THE DUTIES ASSIGNED, AND REQUIRED DIRECT SUPERVISION IN BASIC CONFIDENTIALITY ACKNOWLEDGMENTS PROTECTING THE INTEGRITY OF THIS VERY VERY IMPORTANT PROCESS AND PROTECTS VOTERS INFORMATION AND PROTECT STUDENTS LIKE MY DAUGHTER. THIS BECOMES A PROGRAM THEN ELECTION OFFICES FEEL CONFIDENT IN USING CONSISTENTLY ACROSS COUNTIES BUT AT ITS CORE SENATE BILL. >> Chair: PLEASE WRAP IT UP. WE OVERSHOT THE THREE MINUTES. >> I THINK YOU GOT THE POINT. JUST SOME GUARDRAILS AND THIS IS A GREAT PROGRAM AND I SUPPORT IT. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR THE TESTIMONY. WE HAVE A LOT OF APPEARANCE FORMS TODAY. WE WANT TO GET TO THE AGENDA SO I'M SORRY WE WILL BRING IT DOWN TO TWO MINUTES SO EVERYONE CAN GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK AND WE CAN GET THROUGH THE SENATE RIGHTS BILL AT THE END. PLEASE KEEP YOUR COMMENTS DOWN TO TWO MINUTES. ALSO IF SOMEONE HAS SAID WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY WAIVE IN SUPPORT OR JUST STAND UP AND SAY I REALLY LIKE WHAT THEY LEAGUER FOLLOWED BY INCA REMBRANDTS SMITH. >> HELLO I'M ZACHARY A TEACH FINANCIAL AND SMALL WORLD WHEN I WALKED IN THIS MORNING FOR SOMETHING COMPLETELY DIFFERENT I RAN INTO SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS FOR MARTIN COUNTY WHO I WORKED WITH FOR TWO YEARS AND I TOLD HER STORY THAT I GOT MY SISTER AND MY MOTHER TO BOTH VOLUNTEER AND WORK AS POLL WORKERS AND THEY STILL WORK TO THIS DAY IN MARTIN COUNTY AND WHEN I SAW THIS BILL IS THAT THIS IS PROBABLY THE BEST THING. I TEACH SEVENTEEN AND 18 YEAR OLD HOW TO BE FINANCIALLY READY AND WHAT TO EXPECT AS ADULTS MOVING FORWARD IN THIS WORLD AND WHAT THEIR OBLIGATION IS TO BE A GOOD AMERICAN AND A GOOD CITIZEN AND ONE THING IS TO VOLUNTEER AS MUCH AS YOU POSSIBLY CAN IN YOUR LOCAL COMMUNITY AND I THINK THIS BILL OFFERS THEM THE ABILITY TO NOT ONLY PROVIDE HELP AND ASSISTANCE FOR THEIR COMMUNITY BUT TO BE CYNICALLY INVOLVED IN THOSE AROUND YOU. THE MORE YOU ARE INVOLVED IN YOUR LOCAL COUNTY GOVERNMENT AND THE LOCAL CITY GOVERNMENT THE MORE YOU UNDERSTAND THE MACHINATIONS OF LIFE AND WHAT IT TAKES TO BUILD COMMUNITY AND COALITIONS AND WHAT IT TAKES TO LOOK AT YOUR NEIGHBOR AND NOT THINK OF THEM AS SOMEONE ELSE BUT AS A PARTNER IN WHAT YOU ARE DOING AND HOW YOU LIVE YOUR DAY TO DAY LIFE. I WANT TO SAY THAT I AM VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT OF THAT PORTION OF THE BILL FOR ALLOWING HIGH SCHOOLERS TO VOLUNTEER EVEN IF THEY ARE PREREGISTERED. THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. ERIKA REMBRANDT SMITH FOLLOWED BY ERIK TRIPLETT. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED FOR TWO MINUTES. >> THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THIS BILL. I SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THIS BILL BECAUSE IT ALLOWS STUDENTS AN OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN THE PROCESS THAT HELPS SHAPE AND AFFECT THEIR LIVES, LIKE OF THEIR FAMILY, AND LIVES OF THOSE WHO LIVE IN THEIR COMMUNITIES. THIS BILL ALLOWS YOUNG PEOPLE TO SEE FIRSTHAND HOW ELECTIONS WORK AND IT INCLUDES THEM IN THE PROCESS OF DEMOCRACY. DEMOCRACY THAT HELP SHAPE DESTINIES. THEIR DESTINIES AND THE DESTINIES OF THOSE WHO LIVE AROUND THEM AND DESTINIES OF THOSE THAT WILL COME AFTER AND AFRICAN AMERICAN YOUTH HAVE ALWAYS BEEN INVOLVED IN THE PROCESS OF DEMOCRACY AND GETTING EXPERIENCE IS VERY HELPFUL AND WOULD BE BENEFICIAL TO YOUNG PEOPLE NOT ONLY TO YOUNG PEOPLE BUT ALSO TO THOSE IN THE COMMUNITY. VOTING IS A WAY OF LIFTING OUR VOICES AND IT ALLOWS YOUNG PEOPLE TO BEGIN TO HAVE THE ENERGY TO USE THEIR VOICES IN A REAL IMPORTANT WAY. I STAND IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL AND ENCOURAGE YOU TO AS WELL, THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. JARRARD TRIPLETT FOLLOWED BY LARRY COLTON. DOUBLE TEAM. IT'S ALL GOOD. OKAY TWO MINUTES THOUGH. >> I'LL GIVE YOU 30 SECONDS BACK. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THANK YOU MEMBERS. I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT A COUPLE OTHER THINGS HAPPENING. ONE OF COURSE OUR YOUNG PEOPLE CAN BE IMMERSED IN OUR DEMOCRACY EARLY THAT'S A GOOD THING. BUT ALSO THERE IS A LOT OF ISOLATION GOING ON WITH TEENAGERS. AND THEY ARE BY THEMSELVES A LOT. THEY ARE WITH THEMSELVES A LOT. AND IT IS DECREASING SOCIAL SKILLS, COMMUNICATION SKILLS, THE ABILITY TO EMBRACE DIVERSITY. THESE ARE ANCILLARY REASONS THAT THIS PARTICULAR BILL WORKS FOR OUR YOUNG PEOPLE. ALSO, FINALLY, WHAT YOU SEE DEPENDS ON WHERE YOU GET TO SEE IT. SO WE GET TO SEE IN THE VOTING BOOTHS THE DIVERSITY AND DIFFERENT PEOPLE PASSIONATE ABOUT DIFFERENT THINGS AND THAT IS GOOD FOR TEENAGERS TO SEE EARLY. I'M VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT OF THIS PARTICULAR BILL. >> Chair: THANK YOU. LARRY COLTON FOLLOWED BY JERRY COLLINS. >> GOOD MORNING CHAIR, VICE CHAIR, AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. THIS MONTH MARKS 50 YEARS AGO THAT I BECAME A REGISTERED NOT IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA BUT IN THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA. IT WAS ALSO 50 YEARS AGO THAT I VOLUNTEERED AS A COLLEGE STUDENT TO WORK AT THE POLLS. I STAND HERE TODAY HOWEVER AS PRESIDENT OF THE FLORIDA VOTERS LEAGUE AND WE HAVE THREE SPECIFIC GOALS. REGISTERING VOTERS, EDUCATING VOTERS, AND ENCOURAGING THEM TO PARTICIPATE IN THE VOTING PROCESS. AND AS SOMEONE WHO WORKED AT THE POLLS THROUGH THE ADOPT A PRECINCT PROCESS IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA IN ORANGE COUNTY IN PARTICULAR WE KNOW THAT YOUNG BENEFIT FROM THE EXPERIENCE OF THE SUPERVISORS OF ELECTIONS OFFICE TYPICALLY WILL TRAIN EVERYONE WHO WILL WORK AS A POLL WORKER SO THE STUDENTS WOULD BE TRAINED AS WELL AND I THINK IT WOULD BE TO BE IN THE PROCESS TO SEE THE POLITICAL PROCESS IN ACTION AT A YOUNG AGE. BECAUSE, LOOK, THEIR FUTURE IS JUST BEGINNING. THIS IS WHAT THEIR LIFE WILL BE LIKE AND POLITICIANS LIKE YOURSELVES IT WILL IMPACT THEIR LIVES. I THINK IT'S A GREAT BENEFIT TO SUPPORT THIS BILL AND TO PASS IT SO THAT THIS COULD BE A COMMUNITY SERVICE OPPORTUNITY FOR YOUNG PEOPLE. I THINK IT IS GREAT CIVIC OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM. AN INCREDIBLY GREAT LEARNING EXPERIENCE FOR THEM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR THE TESTIMONY. JERRY WHOLE. >> THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS I WANT TO TELL YOU HOW THIS BILL CAME ABOUT. I WAS SITTING DOWN WITH MY OLDEST GRANDSON ETHAN WHO GOES TO DECOY CREEK HIGH SCHOOL IN ST. JOHNS COUNTY AND WE WERE LOOKING OVER AT THE SCHOOL'S WEBSITE OF THE DIFFERENT COMMUNITY PROJECTS HE COULD DO TO GET HIS COMMUNITY SERVICE HOURS. AND MANY WERE MEANINGFUL BUT I SAW NOTHING THAT WOULD INSTILL MY PASSION WHICH IS ELECTIONS AND RUNNING ELECTIONS AND AS I SPOKE TO HIM ABOUT IT HE SAID I WOULD LIKE TO VOLUNTEER THERE AND AS I DID MORE RESEARCH AND FOUND OUT WE COULD NOT DO IT WITHOUT A CHANGE IN THE LAW I WANT TO MY SENATOR AND MY REPRESENTATIVE AND ASK HIM TO INTRODUCE THIS. I DO APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT ON THIS. I LOOK FORWARD TO YOUNG PEOPLE GETTING INVOLVED AND MAY BE COMING BACK AND BEING POLL WORKERS LATER IN LIFE. OBVIOUSLY SEEING THE PASSION WE ALL HAVE FOR ELECTIONS. THANK YOU AGAIN FOR YOUR SUPPORT. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. LEONARD THOMPSON U.S. DEMOCRACY WAIVES IN SUPPORT. DEMOCRACY USA WAIVES IN SUPPORT. CLEARED DOLT WAIVES IN SUPPORT. JIM LOUIS WAIVES IN SUPPORT. JONATHAN WEBER SOUTHERN POVERTY LAW CENTER WAIVES IN SUPPORT AND AMY MCKEITH COMMON CAUSE WAIVES IN SUPPORT. IS THERE ANY DEBATE? SENATOR YARBOROUGH YOU MAY CLOSE. >> Senator Yarborough: THANK YOU GOOD SPEAKERS WHO CAME OUT AND OFFERED REASONS WHY YOU SHOULD SUPPORT THIS GOOD BILL. THANK YOU SUPERVISOR HOLLAND DUAL ALL COUNTY SUPERVISORS OF ELECTIONS FOR BRINGING THIS TO ME AND LETTING ME PLAY A PART IN THIS AND THANK YOU AND EQUAL GROUND AND OTHERS FOR SPEAKING TODAY. I MADE NOTES WHEN THE MOM CAME UP AND OFFERED OBSERVATIONS. WE WILL LOOK AT THAT AND SEE ABOUT MAKING ADJUSTMENTS AND MAKE IT A BETTER PRODUCT AND WITH THIS I ASKED FOR YOUR FAVORABLE SUPPORT. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL ON CS FOR SB 564. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. SENATOR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE CS IS FOR SB 564 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. THANK YOU. NEXT TAB NUMBER ONE SB 14 ON RELIEF OF JOSÉ KOREA MIAMI DADE COUNTY. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >> Senator Rodriguez: THIS IS A SETTLED CLAIMS BILL FOR THE RELIEF OF JOSÉ KOREA FOR INJURIES SUSTAINED DUE TO THE NEGLIGENCE OF MIAMI DADE COUNTY. HE WAS LAWFULLY CROSSING SOUTHWEST 40th STREET AT THE INTERSECTION OF LEJEUNE. A MIAMI DADE BUS DRIVER FAILED TO OBSERVE HIM IN THE CROSS WALK WHILE MAKING A LEFT TURN CAUSING A COLLISION. MIAMI DADE COUNTY ADMITTED FAULT IN THE INCIDENT AND SETTLED WITH HIM WITHOUT A TRIAL. THE CLAIMS BILL IS FOR $4.1 MILLION AND IS SUPPORTED BY THE CLAIMANT AND MIAMI DADE COUNTY AND THAT IS THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? THERE ARE NO APPEARANCE FORMS. IS THERE DEBATE? OKAY SENATOR RODRIGUEZ YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE. >> Senator Rodriguez: I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. SENATOR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SB 14 REPORTS FAVORABLY. I APOLOGIZE FOR MY PHONE I DID NOT TOUCH IT. I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT'S GOING ON. WE WILL TAKE UP TAB THREE SB 24 RELIEF BOARDS LOOK TOUR AND EDWARD LOOKED FOR. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ YOU ARE RECOGNIZED ON THE BILL. >> Senator Rodriguez: THANK YOU CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE THIS IS AN UNCONTESTED CLAIMANT BILL FOR LOCAL FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT OF $500,000 PAYABLE FROM UNENCUMBERED FUNDS OF MIAMI DADE COUNTY. BASED ON A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN LORDES AND EDWARD OF THE TOUR AND MIAMI DADE COUNTY. THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT RESOLVES A CIVIL ACTION THAT AROSE FROM THE ALLEGED NEGLIGENCE OF THE COUNTY THAT CAUSED INJURIES TO LORDES AND HER HUSBAND. THAT IS THE BILL. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? NO APPEARANCE FORMS. IS THERE DEBATE? SENATOR RODRIGUEZ YOU MAY CLOSE. >> Senator Rodriguez: I ASK FOR YOUR FAVORABLE SUPPORT. >> Chair: CALL THE ROLL ON SB 24. >> SENATOR AVILA. SENATOR BERMAN. SENATOR BOYD. SENATOR BRADLEY. SENATOR BRODEUR. SENATOR BURGESS. SENATOR BURTON. SENATOR DAVIS. SENATOR DICEGLIE. SENATOR GAETZ. SENATOR GARCIA. SENATOR GRALL. SENATOR HARRELL. SENATOR HOOPER. SENATOR MARTIN. SENATOR OSGOOD. SENATOR PIZZO. SENATOR RODRIGUEZ. SENATOR ROUSON. SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR TRUMBULL. SENATOR WRIGHT. SENATOR JONES. CHAIR PASSIDOMO. >> Chair: BY YOUR VOTE SB 24 REPORTS FAVORABLY. NEXT WE WILL TAKE UP TAB 14 SB 1396 ON LITIGATION FINANCE AND CONSUMER PROTECTION BY SENATOR BURTON. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >> Senator Burton: WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS PROTECT FOREIGN RESIDENTS SUPPORT BY PROVIDING LITIGATION FINANCING SAFEGUARDS AND TRANSPARENCY OF FOREIGN FUNDING. HOW DOES IT PROTECT FLORIDIANS RELATED TO LITIGATION? IT DOES IT BY DIRECTING REGULAR LITIGATION FINANCING ACTIVITIES APPLYING THAT FINANCIERS MAY NOT FORCE LEGAL PROCEEDINGS OR SHARE PROCEEDS OF LEGAL PROCEEDINGS AND THE SHARE IS RECOVERED BY THE PLAINTIFFS AND PAY AND OFFERED TO PAY REFERRAL FEES ANYONE RECEIVING ANYTHING OTHER THAN THE ARTHUR I SHARE THE PROCEEDS. PROVIDE THIS GROWING CONCERN IN OUR COUNTRY AND THE BILL REQUIRES THE EXISTENCE OF LITIGATION FUNDS BE DISCLOSED IF THE AGREEMENT INVOLVES A FOREIGN PERSON, PRINCIPAL, OR SOVEREIGN WEALTH FUND. DISCLOSURE OF THIS AGREEMENT HOWEVER IS NOT REQUIRED TO INCLUDE THE SPECIFIC TERMS OF THIS. THOSE ARE THE TWO SECTIONS OF THE BILL. >> Chair: BEFORE QUESTIONS LET'S DO AMENDMENTS. THERE IS ONE. SENATORS THE LATE FILED AMENDMENT BARCODE 007190. WITHOUT OBJECTION SHOW THE AMENDMENT INTRODUCED. SENATOR BURTON YOU MAY EXPLAIN THE AMENDMENT. >> Senator Burton: SENATORS, THIS AMENDMENT IS MEANT TO CLARIFY THAT THE STATUTE REQUIREMENTS DO NOT APPLY TO A FOREIGN CLASS ACTION OR U.S. PARTIES THAT ARE NON ACTIVE CLASS MEMBERS IN A FOREIGN CONCEPT. >> Chair: QUESTIONS ON THE AMENDMENT? NO APPEARANCE FORMS ON THE AMENDMENT. DEBATE? YOU MAY CLOSE. >> Senator Burton: WAIVE CLOSE. >> Chair: THOSE IN FAVOR? THOSE OPPOSED? THIS AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. WE ARE BACK ON THE BILL AS AMENDED. ARE THERE QUESTIONS ON THE BILL AS AMENDED? SENATOR BERMAN YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> Senator Berman: THANK YOU. HAVE OTHER STATES REQUIREE DISCLOSURE OF FINANCING AND WHAT IMPACT HAVE THEY SEEN IF THEY HAVE DONE SO? >> Senator Burton: I HAVE NOT PERSONALLY READ THE STATEMENTS RELATED ABOUT THE ANSWER TO THAT BUT I HAVE BEEN PROVIDE INFORMATION BUT YES OTHER STATES ARE REQUIRING DISCLOSURES AND FINANCING. >> Chair: ANY MORE QUESTIONS? OKAY THERE ARE A NUMBER OF APPEARANCE FORMS. WE WILL START WITH THE BILL CARTER ALL FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION. FOR TWO MINUTES. YOU ARE A LAWYER. >> I WILL TRY TO KEEP IT BRIEF. I WILL DO MY BEST. THANK YOU I KNOW THE SPONSORS SPENT A LOT OF TIME WITH US AND WE DO APPRECIATE THAT TRYING TO UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER'S POSITIONS ON THIS AND I DO LOOK FORWARD TO FURTHER DISCUSSIONS AS WELL. FIRST I WANT TO START WITH A BIT ABOUT WHAT TYPES OF CASES MAY INVOLVE LITIGATION FINANCING BECAUSE I THINK THERE MAY BE PEOPLE NOT UNDERSTANDING AND LUMPING IT INTO A COUPLE CATEGORIES BUT LITIGATION FINANCING CAN BE INVOLVED IN COMMERCIAL LITIGATION WHERE YOU HAVE LARGE CORPORATIONS IN THE LITIGATION AGAINST EACH OTHER THAT COULD BE INVOLVED IN SMALLER COMMERCIAL LITIGATION WHERE YOU HAVE FAMILY RUN BUSINESSES NEEDING CAPITAL TO GO AGAINST A LARGER COMPANY THAT COULD EVEN BE SOMETHING LIKE A PHYSICIANS GROUP GOING AGAINST A LARGER COMPANY OR A FARMER THAT HAS IN A DISTRIBUTION CHAIN OR SOMETHING TO THAT NATURE. MASSIVE TORTS WHERE THERE IS A PRODUCT THAT IS OUT THERE AND A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE INJURED AND ALSO IN AN INDIVIDUAL CASE WHERE THERE IS JUST A SINGLE CATASTROPHIC INCIDENT WERE SOMEBODY HAS TO HAVE THE FUNDS AND THERE NEEDS TO BE FUNDS TO GO AGAINST SOMEONE THAT HAS BETTER CAPITAL. BUT WE DO HAVE A COUPLE DIFFERENT CONCERNS AND ONE IS WITH THE PROHIBITIONS. THERE IS NOTHING IN THE BILL THAT ADDRESSES THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE DEFENDANT. EVERYTHING IS FOCUSED ON THE PLAINTIFF. SO ANY PROHIBITIONS THAT ARE IN THEIR DO NOT APPLY TO DEFENSE FIRMS OR DEFENSE LITIGATION FINANCERS. ANYONE PROVIDING FUNDING OR CAPITAL FOR THOSE DEFENSE SIZE OF LITIGATION BUT ALSO ON THE DISCLOSURE. IF THERE IS ANY FOREIGN FUNDS. IS THAT THERE NEEDS TO BE AN UNDERSTANDING OF FOREIGN FUNDS BEING INVOLVED BUT AGAIN THERE IS NOTHING REQUIRING THE DEFENSE SIDE TO PROVIDE ANY TYPE OF NOTICE OF DISCLOSURE OF ANY FOREIGN FUNDING. ONE OF THE CONCERNS IS WITH HOW THE DISCLOSURE IS AND WHO IT GOES TO. IT GOES TO ALL THE PARTIES AND THIS INCLUDES THE DEFENSE COUNSEL BECAUSE WHAT IS SERVED IT GOES TO THE COURT AND DFS AND THE ATTORNEY GENERAL. EVEN IF THE TERMS AND THE EXACT TERMS OF THE FINANCING AGREEMENT ARE NOT DISCLOSED THE FACT THAT THE FUNDING AGREEMENT IS INVOLVED DOES PROVIDE A STRATEGIC ADVANTAGE IN LITIGATION TO KNOW OR HAVE AN IDEA OF HOW TO DRAG SOMETHING OUT. THEY KNOW THERE IS LITIGATION FUNDING INVOLVED IN DRAGGING OUT THE DISCOVERY PROCESS CONTINUANCE, ET CETERA, BUT ALSO THE INTENT OF WHAT ARE THEY SUPPOSED TO DO WITH IT? WHAT IS THE DEFENSE ATTORNEY SUPPOSED TO DO WITH HIS INFORMATION? IF THERE IS CONCERN ABOUT FOREIGN FUNDS BEING INVOLVED THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT FOR THE DEFENSE ATTORNEY TO DO ANYTHING WITH THAT INFORMATION. WILL THEY REPORT IT TO THE DEPARTMENT OF STATE? THERE IS NO ADMINISTRATIVE RULEMAKING AUTHORITY FOR EVEN AT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE TO DO ANYTHING WITH THAT INFORMATION. ARE THEY GATHERING THE INFORMATION TO FIND OUT THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR. I THINK THERE IS I UNDERSTAND THE INTENT BUT THERE IS OR ANYTHING THAT WOULD BE DONE WITH THIS INFORMATION ONCE IT IS PROVIDED AND FOR THAT REASON WE DO OPPOSE THE BILL. WE LOOK FORWARD TO FURTHER CONVERSATIONS. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR. >> Chair: THANK YOU. ROBERT SCHOLZ FLORIDA JUSTICE REFORM. TWO MINUTES. >> THANK YOU PRESIDENT PASSIDOMO AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. I AM ROBERT SCHOLL TEAM A MEMBER OF THE FLORIDA BAR REPRESENTING THE FLORIDA JUSTICE PERFORM INSTITUTE TODAY. I RISE IN SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL 1396. MY LAW FIRM MUNSON LAW FIRM IN THE LOUISIANA WE HAVE TERMED LITIGATION HARVESTING FINANCE IN CONNECTION WITH HURRICANE INSURANCE CLAIMS IN THAT STATE AND LITIGATION HARVESTING FINANCING OUTSIDE CAPITAL IS USED TO MASS SOLICIT CLIENTS. MASS SOLICIT LEGAL CLAIMS AND CONVERT THEM TO LITIGATION INVENTORY AND PURSUE A LEGAL STRATEGIES THAT ARE OPTIMIZED FOR THE PORTFOLIO AS A WHOLE AT THE VALUE VERSUS INDIVIDUAL OUTCOMES. CLIENTS BENEFIT WHEN THEIR ATTORNEY IS MAKING DECISIONS BASED ON THE CLIENTS INTERESTS. SUBSEQUENT COURT FILINGS AFTER THAT LOUISIANA LAW FROM COLLAPSE REVEAL THAT APPROXIMATELY $30 MILLION AND OUTSIDE LITIGATION FINANCING HAD COME FROM INVESTMENT FIRMS. THE LAW FIRM REPRESENTED A FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY DISCLOSURE THAT HAD ITS ADVERTISING AND REFERRALS NOT BEEN STOPPED THEY EXPECTED 50,000 CLAIMS IN LOUISIANA ALONG WITH SIMILARLY SIZED PORTFOLIOS IN TEXAS, COLORADO, AND FLORIDA. 50,000 IN FLORIDA. SENATE BILL 1396 IT DOES DAM LITIGATION FINANCING OR CONTINGENCY FEES BUT PROVIDES TRANSPARENCY AND ALLOWS COURTS TO SEE WHO IS FUNDING THE CASES IN THEIR DOCKETS AND CONFIRMED THAT THE DECISIONS ARE BEING MADE BY THE LITIGANTS AND NOT UNDISCLOSED POTENTIALLY FOREIGN FINANCIAL INTERESTS AND WHAT OUR LAW FIRM FOUGHT FOR IN LOUISIANA IS WHAT WE DON'T WANT TO SEE IN FLORIDA FOR THIS REASON WE RISE IN SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL 1396. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS. TOM FEIGE U.S. CHAMBER INSTITUTE FOR LEGAL REFORM YOU ARE RECOGNIZED FOR TWO MINUTES. >> WE RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. FIRST TO ADDRESS SOME COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE FROM EARLIER FOLKS THIS BILL DOES NOT DISTINGUISH AND SAY THAT ONLY THE PLAINTIFF HAS TO ABIDE BY THIS DISCLOSURE. IT IS PRETTY NEUTRAL. BOTH PARTIES. THAT'S NUMBER ONE. IT GOES BOTH WAYS IT. NUMBER TWO ON PROHIBITED CONDUCT AGAIN IT IS PARTY NEUTRAL. THE ONLY PLACE WHERE THIS BILL I THINK SPECIFIES FOR THE PLAINTIFF AN ADDITIONAL PROTECTION IS A LITIGATION FUNDER CANNOT TAKE MORE THEN THE PLAINTIFF WOULD TAKE WHICH I WOULD HOPE THAT THE PLAINTIFFS A BAR WOULD SUPPORT PLAINTIFFS BEING THE INJURED PARTY THE ONE THAT TAKES MORE MONEY OUT OF THIS BECAUSE AS THE CEO OF THE LARGEST LITIGATION FUND PERFECT CAPITAL SAID YES SOMETIMES YOU DO TAKE MORE THAN THE PLAINTIFFS. SO THIS BILL IS ABOUT PROTECTING CONSUMERS, PROTECTING LITIGANTS, THE PLAINTIFFS THEMSELVES, AND THE DEFENSE SIDE. IT SAID THE DEFENSE IS NOT IN THIS BUT THERE IS DEFENSE SIDE LITIGATION FINANCING THAT IS ALSO BUILT ON CONTINGENCY BASED UPON THE SAVINGS THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN MADE. THAT IS ON THOSE ISSUES BUT WHAT IS THIS BILL ABOUT? THIRD PARTY LITIGATION. THERE ARE NO REGULATIONS ON THESE FOLKS. I'VE HEARD IT BROUGHT UP ABOUT INSURANCE AND REINSURANCE ALSO INTERNATIONAL MONEY THERE'S A WHOLE AGENCY OFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION THAT REGULATES THOSE FOLKS ENSURES HAVE A DUTY OF GOOD FAITH IF THEY DON'T PROTECT YOU AND DEFEND YOU AS IF THEY WERE IN YOUR SHOES THEY GET SUED FOR BAD FAITH. THERE IS NO FIDUCIARY DUTY FROM THESE THIRD PARTY FUNDERS TO THE FOLKS THAT THEY FUND AND THERE IS NO LAWS OR BOOKS ON IT. SO THIS IS A STEP FORWARD INTO THAT TRANSPARENCY FOR THESE FOLKS AND PROTECTIONS FOR LITIGANTS. QUICKLY, THE BIGGEST CASE THIS IS NOT DAVID VERSUS GOLIATH WITH DAVID LOSING HIS FUNDING. SISCO VERSUS BURFORD CISCO'S GOLIATH THE WORLD'S LARGEST FOOD DISTRIBUTED THEY WERE SUING SMALLER DAVID'S MEET PRODUCERS. THEY GOT BURFORD CAPITAL ANOTHER GLIDE BEHIND IT FOR HUNDRED $40 MILLION. WHEN CISCO WAS READY TO SETTLE THE CASE BURFORD CAPITAL SAID IT IS NOT ENOUGH RETURN FOR US. THEN THEY WERE READY TO SETTLE THE CASE THAT'S WHAT EVERYONE WANTED. BURFORD CAPITAL WANTS TO FUEL THE PROFITS. THEY SAID NO. WE ONLY KNOW THIS BECAUSE CISCO SUES ITS OWN LITIGATION FINANCE OR WHAT DO WE FIND OUT LATER? CISCO'S OWN LAWYER WAS IN CAHOOTS OR ALLEGEDLY IN CAHOOTS WITH BURFORD CAPITAL NOT DOING WHAT WAS FOR THE PLAINTIFF. AND HERE'S THE NEXT PART. BURFORD CAPITAL'S LARGEST SHAREHOLDER CAPITAL IS A SAUDI ARABIAN BANK, THE LARGEST INVESTOR OF UNDISCLOSED SOVEREIGN FUNDS. FORTRESS CAPITAL OWNED 68 PERCENT BY THE INVESTMENT COMPANY. THE SOVEREIGN WEALTH FUND OF ABU DHABI. SIXTY EIGHT PERCENT. THESE FOLKS ARE BUILDING ISLANDS OVER THERE AND WE HAVE A STUDY FROM DECEMBER THAT SHOWS A 600 DOLLAR HIT ON AFFORDABILITY COST TO EVERY HOUSEHOLD IN AMERICA BECAUSE OF LITIGATION FUNDING. >> Chair: WE HAVE A QUESTION. >> QUICKLY, PLEASE TALK ABOUT THE TERM PARTY NEUTRAL. TALK ABOUT THAT AND THEN PLEA IS IF YOU COULD LET US KNOW HOW THIS IS NOT DEPRIVING PEOPLE ACCESS TO LEGAL SYSTEM? >> GREAT QUESTION. THE FIRST QUESTION, PARTY NEUTRAL IF YOU LOOK THROUGH THE BILL AND THROUGH THE STAFF ANALYSIS AS WELL IT IS THE PROHIBITION ON LITIGATION FUNDERS ARE ANY CLAIMS THAT THEY PROVIDE LITIGATION FUNDING TO WHETHER DEFENSE SIDE OR WHETHER IT IS TO THE PLAINTIFF SIDE. SAME THING WITH DISCLOSURE. I THINK IT IS ON LINE 200 AND IT SAYS DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS APPLY TO ANY CIVIL ACTION, ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING OR OTHER LEGAL PROCEEDING. IT DOES NOT SEEM TO DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE PARTIES. >> WHEN IT COMES TO THE DISCLOSURE IS THE DISCLOSURE ALSO TO THE OTHER PARTY THAT'S IN THE LITIGATION? AND WHAT PURPOSE DOES IT SERVE? >> Chair: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> THANK YOU. YES TO THE OTHER PARTY IS THAT REPORTS TO DFS AND THE AG SO WHEN THESE SMALLER DAVID'S MEET PRODUCERS WERE UP AGAINST THEM THEY THOUGHT THEY WERE GOING AGAINST CISCO THEY DID NOT KNOW THAT THERE WAS A LARGER LITIGATION FINANCING COMPANY BEHIND THEM AND WHO MIGHT BE FINANCING THEM THAT I DON'T LIKE THE IDEA OF A FOREIGN COUNTRY MESSING WITH OUR MEET PRICES. AND IT IS NOT MY TINFOIL HAT. THIS IS MARCO RUBIO RICK SCOTT WILL THEY WERE SENATOR SAYING HOW FOREIGN COUNTRIES ARE SOWING DISCORD THROUGH THIRD PARTY FINANCING IN THE COURT STEALING CORPORATE ESPIONAGE IS INTEREST THIS IS A SMALL STEP TO FIND OUT WHAT IS THE EXTENT OF THIS THAT'S GOING ON TO FURTHER FUTURE POLICY MAKING BY YOU ALL BUT THE MOST IMPORTANT THING IS THERE IS NO EXCHANGE OF ACTUAL AGREEMENTS IN THIS BILL. >> Chair: THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. OKAY THE REST ARE WAIVING. WE HAVE ALEX MILLER FLORIDA ASSOCIATION WAIVING IN SUPPORT. DAVID JUNIOR FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION WAIVING IN SUPPORT. CAMERON FINK ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF FLORIDA WAIVING IN SUPPORT. GARY GREW FLORIDA INSURANCE COUNCIL WAIVING IN SUPPORT. AMANDA FRASER AIA WAIVING IN SUPPORT. KATIE WEBB GEICO WAIVING IN SUPPORT. CAROLYN JOHNSON FLORIDA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE WAIVES IN SUPPORT. IS THERE ANY DEBATE ON THIS BILL AS AMENDED? SENATOR BURTON YOU MAY CLOSE. ALL RIGHT. BACK HERE. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> I APPRECIATE SENATOR BURTON CALLING ME AND DISCUSSING THIS ISSUE. FIRST AND FOREMOST I THINK THIS IS NOT PROHIBITION I THINK THIS IS OVERSIGHT AND THIS IS WHAT THIS LEGISLATION SEEKS TO PROVIDE. I WANT TO BE CLEAR I THINK LITIGATION SHOULD BE PERMITTED IN FLORIDA BUT ONLY WITH CLEAR REGULATORY FRAMEWORK AND I THINK THIS IS A STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. I AM NOT SAYING THAT THERE ARE NOT SALIENT POINTS TO BE MADE TO THE CONTRARY OF WHAT WE ARE MISSING HERE IN THIS BILL BUT WANT TO LOOKED AT WHETHER OR NOT I WOULD SUPPORT IT WE WOULD CHECK THIS LITIGATION FINANCING THAT'S THE FIRST STEP. SECOND IS TO TRY TO MITIGATE ABUSE BUT THIS REALLY HANDED TO ME AT THE NEED TO BE TRANSPARENT WITH FOREIGN FINANCING. THAT, TO ME IS A CONCERN. WE SEE THIS AND OTHER AREAS AND RETRYING IT CRACK DOWN ON IT AND THAT WAS A KEY PROVISION AND I CAN SEE WHERE IT COULD BE USED AND ABUSED AND THAT WOULD BE INFORMATION THAT WE AS A STATE SHOULD KNOW. WE SHOULD HAVE THIS AT OUR DISPOSAL. ALSO I KNOW THESE ARE APPLES AND ORANGES. I'M ACTUALLY NOT SAYING THAT THEY ARE THE EXACT SAME BUT TO GET TO YES I ALSO THOUGHT ABOUT BAIL AGENTS AND BOND IN THE CRIMINAL SPACE. AND WE CERTAINLY DO ALLOW THAT. IN ESSENCE IT IS THIRD PARTY GUARANTEES BUT WE ALSO PROVIDE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK AROUND THAT UNIVERSE AGAIN CRIMINAL VERSUS CIVIL. I AM NOT SAYING THEY ARE THE SAME BUT I DO THINK THERE IS AN APPROPRIATE PARALLEL HERE WITH LITIGATION FINANCING IN THE CIVIL ARENA AND A PARRALEL CAN BE DRAWN AND SHOULD BE DRAWN AS TO WHY MAYBE THERE SHOULD BE GUARDRAILS HERE. FOR THESE REASONS I CAN GET TO YES. AGAIN THE ULTIMATE BARRIER WOULD BE WHETHER OR NOT WE ARE ALLOWING IT. WE ARE. I DO THINK IT IS APPROPRIATE AS A FRAMEWORK AROUND IT. SO I WILL BE YES. >> THANK YOU FOR REACHING OUT SENATOR BURTON AND FOR YOU ALSO KNOWING WHERE I WOULD LAND ON THIS AND ALTHOUGH I AM TROUBLED BY THE WORST VERSIONS OF THE STORIES WE HEARD ABOUT WHAT HAPPENS IN VARIOUS SITUATIONS I JUST DON'T THINK THAT THIS BILL ACCOMPLISHES THAT. I THINK IT PROVIDES A FRAMEWORK FOR EVENTUALLY TRYING TO PUT THIS INFORMATION IN FRONT OF A JURY, WHICH I DON'T THINK IS RELEVANT AS ALL. I THINK IT AND THAT ACCESS TO FUNDING AND WHEN WE HEAR PARTY NEUTRAL I THINK SOME OF THESE OPINIONS ARE DEFINITELY BASED ON MY EXPERIENCE IN THIS SPACE AND SEEING YOU KNOW I NEVER HAD TO USE A LITIGATION FINANCING COMPANY. INSTEAD I MIGHT TAKE OUT A LINE OF CREDIT WHICH I SEE IS EXEMPTED IN THE BILL. SO I APPRECIATE THAT KIND OF CHANGE BUT WHEN IT'S PARTY NEUTRAL YOU HAVE A PLAINTIFF WHO DOES NOT HAVE ACCESS TO RESOURCES AND YOU GENERALLY HAVE AN INSURANCE COMPANY WHO HAS ACCESS TO MASSIVE RESOURCES AND WOULDN'T HAVE TO FIND THE TYPE OF FUNDING IN ORDER TO DEFEND A CLAIM THAT A PLAINTIFF MAY HAVE TO FIND. I ALSO THINK THAT IT SOUNDS APPEALING TO SAY THE FINANCING COMPANY CAN'T TAKE MORE THAN THE PLAINTIFF WOULD TAKE. IT SOUNDS APPEALING WHEN WE SAY THAT ABOUT ATTORNEYS FEES. THE PROBLEM IS ON THE OTHER SIDE YOU HAVE A PARTY WHO KNOWS THAT IF THERE IS A CAPPED AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT ANY INDIVIDUAL CAN SPEND THEY JUST NEED TO SPEND MORE. AND THEY ARE ABLE TO SPEND MORE. SO AS SOON THE OTHER PARTY KNOWS THAT THERE IS SOMEONE THAT HAS SOUGHT SOME SORT OF FUNDING IN ORDER TO MOVE FORWARD WITH WHAT VERY WELL MAY BE. I THINK IT ALWAYS ASSUMES THE CLAIMS ARE NOT LEGITIMATE BUT I THINK THESE CLASS ACTION SUITS MANY TIME RESULT IN SAFETY CHANGES OF A PRODUCT THAT ARE IMPORTANT ALL OF US. SO TO SAY THAT THEY CANNOT TAKE ANY MORE THAN THE PLAINTIFF WOULD TAKE THEM THAT IS JUST A WAY IN WHICH TO INTERFERE WITH THE HANDLING OF THAT CASE. I MAY NEED TO SPEND MONEY ON A CERTAIN NUMBER OF EXPERTS BECAUSE THE OTHER SIDE HAS AN UNLIMITED CHECKBOOK FOR HOW MUCH THEY CAN SPEND ON EXPERTS. AND THE GOAL IS ALWAYS TO PUT MORE MONEY IN THE CLIENTS POCKET. SOMETIMES IT ALSO MEANS THAT THEY HAVE HAD EXCESSIVE MEDICAL BILLS. THEY WILL NOT GET THE MONEY. IT GOES TO THEIR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER. THEY WON'T SEE CERTAIN MONEY. IT SOUNDS APPEALING BUT I THINK THAT THERE IS A REALITY THAT EXISTS IN EACH CASE THAT IS DIFFERENT. FINALLY, WITH REGARD TO THE REVIEW OF YOU KNOW, THE REVIEW OF THE THEY WON'T GET DOLLAR AMOUNTS FOR FINANCING TERMS OR OTHER PROPRIETARY AND TRADE SECRETS CONTAINED WITHIN -- WHAT IS IT THEN? WHAT IS THE POINT OF SAYING WHAT CAN THE JUDGE DO WITH IT? CAN THE JUDGE LITERALLY LOOK AT AN ATTORNEY WHO PEOPLE HAVE SELECTED TO REPRESENT THEM AND SAY I AM SORRY I DON'T THANK YOU ARE QUALIFIED? WE HAVE THE RIGHT TO SELECT THE COUNCIL THAT WE WANT TO REPRESENT US AND I HAVE SO MANY OBLIGATIONS PURSUANT TO MY LICENSE AT THE FLORIDA BAR TO DISCLOSE ALL OF THIS INFORMATION AND THIS INFORMATION TO A CLIENT ABOUT WHAT THEIR EXPOSURE MIGHT BE AND THAT IS A LICENSING BODY TO DO THAT AND IF I'M ACTING INAPPROPRIATELY AND ENGAGING IN CONTRACTS THAT ARE TO THE DETRIMENT OF MY CLIENT THEY SHOULD FILE A COMPLAINT WITH THE FLORIDA BAR AND I SHOULD BE DISCIPLINED. BUT HERE WE ARE ASKING A JUDGE TO LOOK AT THIS AND PRESUMABLY DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT THIS IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CLASS AND IF THE JUDGE DECIDES

Meeting record textRules

Skip to Navigation | Skip to Main Content | Skip to Site Map

FLHouse.gov | Mobile Site

Senate Tracker: Sign Up | Login

Go to Bill:

Session:

2026F

2026E

2026D

2026

2025

2025C

2025B

2025A

2024 Org.

2024

2023C

2023

2023B

2022A

2022 Org.

2022D

2022C

2022

2021B

2021A

2021

2020 Org.

2020

2019 I

2019

2018 Org.

2018

2017A

2017

2016 Org.

2016

2015C

2015B

2015A

2015

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Rules

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e5597455c8f03ad77c793380819b7170. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record