POLISCOPE

The public record

ORANGEPARK (CLAY COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions published

Selection Advisory Committee

Monday, November 9, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The committee voted to recommend Mauldin & Jenkins for the Town's audit services over incumbent Purvis Gray and Grau & Associates, citing the firm's large-scale Florida experience and competitive pricing.

The Selection Advisory Committee voted 3-0 to recommend Mauldin & Jenkins as the Town's primary auditing firm for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2026. The committee ranked Purvis, Gray & Company second and Grau & Associates third, sending the recommendation to the Town Council for a December 1st vote.

Why it matters

Town taxpayers face a potential change in auditing oversight and fee structures, with Mauldin & Jenkins offering a $53,000 first-year fee that includes single audits, compared to incumbent Purvis Gray's $55,500 base fee with separate charges.

What happens next

Next meeting: Tuesday, December 1, 2026.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

7

Recorded outcomes

2

Source artifacts

3

What changed

Other key decisions

2 captured items have a publicly linked outcome.

Search all 7 meeting actions
  • Item 4

    The committee voted to recommend Mauldin & Jenkins for the Town's audit services over incumbent Purvis Gray and Grau & Associates, citing the firm's large-scale Florida experience and competitive pricing.

    RECOMMENDATION

  • Item 2

    The committee approved the minutes from the November 2, 2026 meeting in a 3-0 vote.

    MINUTES

Recorded votes

1 recorded vote0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (1)

People and votes

Chuck Smithers

Present at this meeting

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

See all 1 roll call with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Town of Orange Park Audit Selection Committee Monday, November 9, 2026 1:55 P.M. Minutes DRAFT 1. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 1:55 p.m. Committee Members in attendance were Ms. Melissa Harris, Mr. Chuck Smithers, and Vice-Mayor Doug Benefield. Others in attendance included: Finance Director John Villanueva and Recording Secretary Ginny York. . 2. MINUTES The committee reviewed the minutes from the previous meeting held on November 2, 2026. A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes as presented, which passed unanimously with a 3-0 vote. 3. PRESENTATIONS A. MAULDIN & JENKINS, LLC Representatives from the accounting firm Malden & Jenkins, including Audit Partner Daniel Anderson and Audit Manager Garrett Marlowe, presented their proposal to provide auditing services for the Town of Orange Park for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2026. The presenters highlighted the firm’s extensive specialization in government accounting, noting that they serve over 800 governmental clients across the Southeast and maintain a high 90% staff retention rate to ensure team continuity. They outlined their collaborative approach to transitioning new clients, utilizing real-time web software called Shurlink to streamline documentation, and offering free quarterly continuing education to their clients. During the subsequent question-and-answer session, the board discussed the potential financial challenges stemming from the passage of Amendment 3 and the resulting increase in the Homestead Exemption. The firm explained that while they anticipate an increase in GASB 102 revenue constraint disclosures across Florida municipalities, they will carefully evaluate individual plans to mitigate property tax revenue declines. Additionally, the presenters addressed the specific focus required for smaller municipalities, emphasizing the evaluation of internal control structures and the segregation of duties in limited finance departments. Finally, the finance director confirmed that the upcoming audit would be for the period ending September 30, 2026, with an expected field work completion timeline around mid-April.

Audit Selection Committee November 9, 2026 2 | P a g e B. PURVIS, GRAY & COMPANY Purvis Gray, the Town’s incumbent auditing firm for 12 years, presented their proposal for the upcoming audit, projecting a 320-hour timeline for a base fee of $55,500. The firm highlighted its deep institutional knowledge and specialized focus on 31 Florida municipalities, noting that over 80% of the audit hours would be handled by senior-level supervisors. They plan to transition roughly two-thirds of their work on-site and introduce a specialized accounting AI tool, Trillion, to analyze large data sets for hidden anomalies and streamline document review. Addressing firm rotation, the presenters noted that authoritative bodies do not recommend automatic rotation, citing studies that show audit failure is three times more likely with a new firm; as an alternative, they offered an internal partner/manager rotation. They reminded the board that upon taking over 12 years ago, they resolved severe, previously unaddressed flaws in internal controls, utilities, and a mismanaged pension plan that ultimately returned over $1 million to the Town. During the question-and-answer session, the firm noted that smaller municipalities require a strict audit focus on fundamental internal controls and segregation of duties rather than the complex economic development risks found in larger cities. Regarding Amendment 3, the firm predicted no immediate balance sheet impact beyond required disclosures but warned that long-term property tax declines would force cities to adopt fire assessments or risk scaling back public safety departments in favor of county services. Finally, the firm explained that single audits are billed separately to avoid unnecessary costs, advising the board to scrutinize competing bids to see if fees are charged "per single audit" or "per major program," as multiple major programs can exponentially multiply a low initial quote. B. GRAU & ASSOCIATES Grau & Associates, represented by Audit Partner David Koplowski, presented their proposal, highlighting that 95% of their firm operates as a dedicated Florida government audit department. Mr, Koplowski noted their nimble size allowed them to outpace larger competitors by custom-building internal AI tools to detect anomalies and look deeper across massive data sets. To demonstrate alignment, he cited their 15-year relationship with the Town of Lantana, whose $26.4 million budget closely mirrors Orange Park’s $20.6 million expenses. The firm offers a transparent digital tracking portal for real-time document exchange and guarantees direct, year-round access to partner leadership. During the question-and-answer session, Mr. Koplowski stated that smaller municipalities require customized audit plans focusing on flexible mitigating controls due to limited resources for the segregation of duties. When questioned on tech proficiency, he detailed a dual top-down and bottom-up training approach; because the firm's strict municipal focus creates a dedicated offseason after June 30th, the entire staff undergoes practical testing to master prompt engineering and task optimization. He emphasized that the firm's partners personally code and build their internal tools rather than outsourcing them to consultants, ensuring strict data security. Regarding logistics, the firm will provide one week of on-site fieldwork during the first-year transition, scaling down to an as-needed basis in subsequent years. Finally, Mr. Koplowski noted that Amendment 3 would require standard subsequent

Audit Selection Committee November 9, 2026 3 | P a g e event and GASB risk disclosures for fiscal year 2026, offering their proprietary AI tools to help the Town forecast operational property tax revenue impacts. 4. RECOMMENDATION Following the interviews, the selection committee voted 3-0 to recommend Malden & Jenkins as the top choice to the Town Council, establishing a final ranking of Malden & Jenkins first, Purvis Gray second, and Grau & Associates third. During the pricing review, Finance Director John Villianueva clarified that Malden & Jenkins' first-year fee of $53,000 includes the single audit fee. In contrast, incumbent Purvis Gray proposed a scaling base fee ($55,500 in Year 1, $58,000 in Year 2, and $60,500 in Year 3) with single audits billed separately at $5,000, while Grau & Associates was ranked third due to a weaker presentation. Mr. Smithers favored Purvis Gray for their institutional continuity amid upcoming municipal financial challenges, but the majority preferred Malden & Jenkins for their large-scale Florida experience and the benefit of a fresh perspective. The recommendation will move forward for formal consideration at the December 1st Town Council meeting. 5. AUDIENCE COMMENTS There were no audience comments at this time. 6. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 3:17 p.m.

Town of Orange Park

Selection Advisory Committee Meeting

Monday, November 9, 2026

1:55 PM

Agenda

1. Call to Order the Audit Selection Committee

2. New Business

a. Approval of the November 2, 2026 Committee Meeting Minutes

b. Presentations

a. 2:00 P.M.-Mauldin & Jenkins, LLC

b. 2:25 P.M.-Purvis, Gray and Company, LLP

c. 2:50 P.M.-Grau & Associates (Virtual)

3. Audience Comments

4. Committee Recommendations

5. Adjournment

2042 PARK AVENUE | ORANGE PARK, FLORIDA 32073 | 904.278.3011 townoforangepark.com

1

Town of Orange Park Selection Advisory Committee Meeting Monday, November 9, 2026 1:55 PM Agenda 1. Call to Order the Audit Selection Committee 2. New Business a. Approval of the November 2, 2026 Committee Meeting Minutes b. Presentations a. 2:00 P.M.-Mauldin & Jenkins, LLC b. 2:25 P.M.-Purvis, Gray and Company, LLP c. 2:50 P.M.-Grau & Associates (Virtual) 3. Audience Comments 4. Committee Recommendations 5. Adjournment 2042 PARK AVENUE | ORANGE PARK, FLORIDA 32073 | 904.278.3011 townoforangepark.com 1

Town of Orange Park Audit Selection Committee Monday, November 2, 2026 5:00 P.M. Minutes 1. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 5:00 p.m. Committee Members in attendance were Ms. Melissa Harris, Mr. Chuck Smithers, and Vice-Mayor Doug Benefield. Others in attendance included: Finance Director John Villanueva and Recording Secretary Ginny York. . 2. MINUTES The committee reviewed the minutes from the previous meeting held on October 19, 2026. A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes as presented, which passed unanimously with a 3-0 vote. 3. DISCLOSURES OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST The Committee Chair inquired whether any committee members or staff possessed existing personal or professional relationships with any of the bidding firms that required official disclosure. All attendees responded in the negative, and no conflicts of interest were reported. 4. REVIEW AND TABULATION OF AUDITOR PROPOSALS The committee evaluated the five timely proposals received from Powell and Jones, Mauldin and Jenkins, Grau and Associates, Purvis Gray, and Moss, Krusick and Associates. Members commended the Finance Department for its strong internal controls and clean numbers, which attracted a high caliber of municipal bids. In their review, members noted that two smaller, non-local firms—specifically Powell and Jones and Grau and Associates—lacked the deep structural resources of larger competitors. Members also identified a clerical template error in the proposal letter from Powell and Jones regarding an existing town relationship. Additionally, it was noted that one firm lacked adequate governmental audit experience, showing an atypical reliance on non- profit pricing discounts. Conversely, firms like Purvis Gray and Moss, Krusick and Associates demonstrated robust public-sector experience. Mr. Villanueva collected individual evaluation sheets and tabulated the final cumulative scores. Mauldin and Jenkins ranked first with a total score of 275.9. Purvis Gray ranked second with a score of 260.1. Grau and Associates ranked third with a score of 248.2. Powell and Jones ranked fourth with a score of 242.1, and Moss, Krusick and Associates ranked fifth with a score of 240.5. 2

Audit Selection Committee November 2, 2026 2 | P a g e 5. SELECTION AND PLANNING FOR ORAL PRESENTATIONS A motion was made and seconded to accept the tabulated rankings and advance the top three firms—Mauldin and Jenkins, Purvis Gray, and Grau and Associates—to personal interviews and oral presentations. The motion passed unanimously with a 3-0 vote. The committee tentatively scheduled the presentations for Monday, November 9, 2026, beginning at 2:00 p.m., subject to firm availability. Mr. Villanueva and Ms. York were directed to randomize the order of the top three firms via a blind draw and issue email invitations the following morning. The committee agreed that virtual participation via Zoom would be acceptable. Should any of the top three firms prove unavailable, the fourth-ranked firm, Powell and Jones, will be invited to fill the slot. Each firm will be allocated approximately 20 minutes for a presentation and question-and-answer period, targeting a total meeting length of 90 minutes to two hours. Following the presentations, the committee will deliberate, rank the finalists, and make a recommendation to the Town Council ahead of their December 1, 2026, meeting, where Council authorization to negotiate a contract will be decided. 6. AUDIENCE COMMENTS There were no comments at this time. 7. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 5:27 p.m. 3

All meeting actions

Published sources processed

7 meeting items captured from the published sources reviewed here, kept in source order.

Showing 7 of 7

Browse by category7 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Selection Advisory Committee — Minutes
  • Selection Advisory Committee
  • Selection Advisory Committee — Packet
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.
  • Low-grade, ungraded, procedural, or superseded items remain in the complete agenda inventory rather than the meeting digest.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 5931533bc189aebd02963e34fd19ab42. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record