The civic record
Read. Follow. Verify.Hearing on the 'Independent State Legislature' Theory
Record date · January 1, 2022
Track this bill to get notified when it advances a stage. One tap to stop, anytime.
What This Bill Does
The House Committee on Administration held a hearing on July 28, 2022, to examine the 'Independent State Legislature' theory and its potential impact on U.S. elections. The hearing featured testimony from legal experts and included extensive submissions regarding the constitutional authority of state legislatures over federal election processes.
The hearing explores a legal theory that could fundamentally change how federal elections are regulated by determining whether state legislatures have exclusive authority over election rules, potentially bypassing state courts and constitutions.
Who It Affects
Groups the bill's text affects, as described in the record. Being affected is not a position for or against it.
State Legislatures
The theory directly concerns the scope of their constitutional authority to set election rules.
State Courts
The theory addresses whether state courts have the power to review or strike down election laws passed by state legislatures.
Voters
Changes to election administration rules could impact how federal elections are conducted and how legal challenges to those elections are resolved.
Key Facts
- The hearing was held on July 28, 2022, by the Committee on House Administration.
- The primary subject was the 'Independent State Legislature' theory, which concerns the scope of state legislative power over federal elections under the U.S. Constitution.
- Three expert witnesses provided testimony: Richard Pildes, Carolyn Shapiro, and Eliza Sweren-Becker.
- The record includes numerous submissions, including legal analyses of the Elections Clause and various court cases such as Bush v. Gore and Rucho v. Common Cause.
Show all 6 facts
- Ranking Member Rodney Davis submitted materials related to the American Confidence in Elections (ACE) Act.
- The hearing record spans two books of documentation, including questions for the record and extensive academic and legal submissions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 'Independent State Legislature' theory?
What was the purpose of this hearing?
What else do you want to know?
News Coverage
Follow the record
Votes, people, money & the original sourceFull breakdown
Who this bill affects and the strongest case for and against it, written only from the bill’s own text.
Discoveries
Patterns POLISCOPE noticed across the record. These are observations to investigate, not conclusions.
Focus on Constitutional Authority
The hearing highlights a shift toward litigating the fundamental constitutional source of election administration power rather than just specific voting procedures.
Connected Entities
Sources
www.govinfo.gov
Analysis Score
0–100- Significance85How much this matters to a regular citizen
- Controversy80Intensity of disagreement among stakeholders
- Entertainment20Compellingness for a non-policy-wonk reader
- Buzz30Current news / social attention level
Publisher tools