POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Council Regular Meeting

Wednesday, December 11, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Naples City Council met to discuss infrastructure projects, including the $24 million Naples Pier reconstruction, and approved various administrative and investment agreements. The council also recognized community award winners and set the agenda for upcoming legislative priorities.

Why it matters

The city is moving forward with the $24 million reconstruction of the Naples Pier, which is expected to take 18 months to complete once construction begins.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 70,886 characters. The full document is at the source.

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; 2) experts who testified during quasi-judicial hearings were accepted as qualified to do so in their respective fields of expertise; and 3) added attachments are referenced in red as “ADDED ATTACHMENT”. 1) CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL City Council Members Present Teresa Heitmann, Mayor Terry Hutchison, Vice Mayor Staff Present: Jay Boodheshwar, City Manager Robert Middleton, Public Works Director Erica Martin, Planning Director Leslee Dulmer, Deputy Planning Director Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, Facilities Director Danielle Futia, Special Events and Marketing Sup. Kyle Rambosk, Fire Marshal Others Present: James Henderson Vincent Keeys Richard Ruppert Clay Brooker Mark McLean Andrew Rath Christian Andrea Francesca Passidomo Tim McCarthy Jay Newman Noel Davies Kristen Coury Bob Vayda Jeff Stevens Mitchell Hertz Peter Voss Febi Gouda Fatma Acar Joel Molard Berne Barton Ray Christman Bill Kramer Linda Penniman Beth Petrunoff Matthew McConnell, City Attorney Nathan Jones, Senior Planner Jeffrey Brammer, Planner II Dan Ohrenstein, City Engineer Kimberly Nudi, Planner I Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Jessica Hernandez, Deputy City Clerk Shawn Connors Harry Zea James Whittaker Donald Sheehan Curtis Williams Mark DiMaio Falconer Jones Mike Myers Cindy Myers Edward Negley Deno Yiankes Pete Tierney Cliff Holland Mary Young Gordon Stojkoski Rachael Norton Lynda Wolk Maria Mair 2) INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Pastor James Henderson, Celebration Community Church, gave an invocation. Mayor Heitmann subsequently led in the Pledge of Allegiance.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 2 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 3) SET AGENDA (add or remove items) City Manager Jay Boodheshwar reviewed three Supplemental Agenda items that were distributed the previous day. Among these were Item 8.A, a Consent Agenda item related to legislative priorities and appropriation requests, and Items 11.A and 11.J, land use matters. In addition, he said staff requested continuing the November 7, 2024 City Council and Naples Airport Authority Joint Workshop meeting minutes, which are included under Item 6.A, until the January 15, 2025 Regular City Council meeting. City Manager Boodheshwar announced that with the approval of Consent Agenda Items 7.C and 7.D, agreements with Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc., for the design, permitting, construction, engineering, and inspection of the Naples Pier, the City will have completed all preparations needed to begin construction. He provided a reconstruction timeline, emphasizing that while meeting Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) requirements had been time- consuming, it is essential to secure $14 million in funding for the project. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Public Works Director Robert Middleton stated that the total cost of the Naples Pier reconstruction is projected to be $24 million. City Manager Boodheshwar estimated that, once underway, construction should take approximately 18 months to complete. MOTION by Hutchison to SET AGENDA, subject to accepting Supplement 1 Agenda items and continuing the November 7, 2024, City Council and Naples Airport Authority Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes (Item 6.A) until the January 15, 2025 City Council Regular Meeting; seconded by Petrunoff and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 4) ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS 4.A) 28th Annual Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Parade and Celebration Proclamation. Mayor Heitmann read a proclamation designating January 20, 2025 as the 28th Annual Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day Parade and Celebration. Vincent Keeys, President of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in Collier County, invited Council Members and the public to attend the parade. 4.B) Recognition of Naples Airport Authority Commissioner Richard Ruppert for his Four Years of Service to the City of Naples. Mayor Heitmann acknowledged Richard Ruppert for his four years of service on the Naples Airport Authority. Mr. Ruppert expressed his gratitude with brief remarks. 4.C) Recognition of 2024 Christmas Parade Winners. Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director, expressed gratitude to individuals and groups who contributed to the success of the 2024 Christmas Parade. Danielle Futia, Special Events and Marketing Supervisor, announced the following winners for the 2024 Naples Christmas Parade: Most Illuminated High School Band – Golden Gate High School Titan Marching Band; Best Non-Profit Winners – Pursue Church, The Posh Mamas Club, and Night to Shine; Best Business Winner – Gulf Coast International Properties; Best Float Winner – Collier Area Transit (CAT). Mayor Heitmann thanked the staff and the community for making the Christmas Parade a success. Christmas Parade Winners Presentation (Staff/Added Attachment) 5) PUBLIC COMMENTS Shawn Conners, (sworn in separately for Item 11.C), shared examples of the Athens Groups positive contributions as a partner and neighbor in the Naples community. He voiced support for approving the requested changes for Phase II of the Naples Beach Club redevelopment. Harry Zea voiced concern about a past court case involving the City of Naples and the Dock Restaurant and thanked the current City Attorney for taking appropriate action.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 3 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA City Attorney Matthew McConnell noted that the service consultant requested changes regarding Item 7.A. He requested that the Consent Agenda approval include a condition requiring changes to the agreement to receive final approval from the City Attorney. MOTION by Christman to APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA subject to removing the November 7, 2024, City Council and Naples Airport Authority Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes (Item 6.A) and approving Item 7.A subject to authorizing the City Attorney to make additional changes to the Agreement; seconded by Barton and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 6) MINUTES 6.A) Approval of the November 6, 2024, Regular Meeting Minutes, the November 7, 2024, City Council and Naples Airport Authority Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes, and the November 18, 2024, Workshop Meeting Minutes. The November 7, 2024 City Council and Naples Airport Authority Joint Workshop Meeting minutes were continued until the January 15, 2025 Regular City Council meeting. (See Item 3.) Agenda Memorandum November 6, 2024 Regular Meeting Minutes November 7, 2024 Joint Council/NAA Workshop Meeting Minutes November 18, 2024 Workshop Meeting Minutes 7) RESOLUTIONS 7.A) RESOLUTION 2024-15510 - A Resolution Approving a Professional Services Consultant’s Agreement Between the City of Naples and Public Trust Advisors, LLC for the Investment Advisory Services for a Three-Year Period Beginning on January 1, 2025, with the Option of Two Additional One-Year Renewals; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Professional Services Agreement: and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution 25-001 Bid Analysis for Investment Advisory Services Agreement - Public Trust Advisors - Unsigned 7.B) RESOLUTION 2024-15511 - A Resolution Approving a Contractor’s Services Agreement Between ABG Fabrication, LLC, and the City of Naples, for Annual Welding and Fabrication Services Necessary for Fleet Maintenance and Repair, Pursuant to City Bid 24-029; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Contractor’s Services Agreement; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution Analysis of Bid - ITB 24-029 Contractor’s Services Agreement - ABG Fabrication, LLC 7.C) RESOLUTION 2024-15512 - A Resolution Approving a First Amendment to the Professional Services Consultant’s Agreement with Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc.; Extending the Completion Date of the Agreement for the Construction Engineering and Inspection Phase of the Naples Pier Reconstruction Project from December 1, 2023 to November 15, 2026 and a Subsequent Administrative 60-Day Project Close- Out Beginning after the Date of Completion; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the First Amendment; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution RFP No. 23-009 Naples Pier Design Amendment 1 (THA ex) THA Professional Services Consultant’s Agreement

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 4 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 7.D) RESOLUTION 2024-15513 - A Resolution Approving a Second Amendment to the Professional Services Consultant’s Agreement With Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc. to Provide Design And Engineering Services for the Repair of the Naples Pier that was Damaged By Hurricane Ian in the Additional Amount of $1,382,185.00 and Additional Contract Terms; Amending the FY 2024-25 Budget Adopted by Resolution 2024-15463 in Order to Provide the Additional Funding Required to Complete Design and Engineering Services for the Naples Pier Reconstruction Project; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Second Amendment; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution RFP No. 23-009 Naples Pier Design Amendment 2 (THA ex) THA Professional Services Consultant’s Agreement 7.E) RESOLUTION 2024-15514 - A Resolution Approving an Additional Standard Grant Agreement (L0079) between the State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the City of Naples Accepting an additional $25 Million in Funding for the Naples Gulf of Mexico Beach Stormwater Outfall Pipe Removal and Water Quality Project; Increasing the Total Funding to $40 Million; Authorizing the Mayor to Execute the Agreement; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution DEP Agreement L0079 7.F) RESOLUTION 2024-15515 - A Resolution Declaring that City Council Will Not Be In Session From 8:00 A.M. December 12, 2024 to 8:30 A.M. January 13, 2025; Providing that the Mayor Shall Inform the Council of Actions Taken During this Period Pursuant to Section 2.4 of the Charter; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution 7.G) RESOLUTION 2024-15516 - A Resolution Amending Resolution 2024-15474 Relating to a Subdivision Replat; Approving and Accepting the Preliminary and Final (Record) Plat for 900 Block 5th Avenue Replat, a Replat of a Portion of Block 15, Tier 10, Replat of Naples Seaboard and Gulf Railway Company Subdivision, Recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 59, Public Records of Collier County, Florida, Lying in Section 9, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, City of Naples, Florida, Pursuant to Chapter 54, Subdivision Standards, of the Code of Ordinances, City of Naples, for Property Located at 900 and 936 5th Avenue South and 975 6th Avenue South, Containing Approximately 2.472 Acres and Owned by 5th Avenue South Holdings, LP, and NECO 900 5th Avenue South, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, More Fully Described Herein; Repealing and Superseding Resolution 2024-15474; Requiring Recording; and Providing an Effective Date. (Continued from the December 4, 2024 City Council Regular Meeting). Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution 12.3.2024 Supplemental Letter from Petitioner’s Agent Letter from Petitioner’s Agent Plat - SUB 3 - 900 5th Ave REPLAT COMPLETE 12-03-24 Affidavit of Sign Posting Affidavit of Sign Posting for 12-11-2024 Meeting 8) OTHER 8.A) Approval of Legislative Priorities and Appropriation Requests for the 2025 Florida State Legislative Session. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum (SUPPLEMENT 1/ADDED ATTACHMENT)

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 5 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 2025 Legislative Priorities and Appropriation Requests (SUPPLEMENT 1/ADDED ATTACHMENT) END OF CONSENT AGENDA 9) PUBLIC HEARINGS None. REGULAR AGENDA 10) ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT AGENDA (If Needed) None. 11) LAND USE MATTERS 11.A) RESOLUTION 2024-15517 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Conditional Use Petition 24-CU8 Pursuant to Section 46-34 and Section 58-593 of the Code of Ordinances, for a Mixed-Use Building Containing Five Residential Condominium Units, for the Property Owned by NaplesComA, LLC, a Florida Limited Liability Company, and Located at 500 Goodlette-Frank Road, and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman, Petrunoff / had not had contact but were familiar with the site; Barton / was familiar with the site and had brief contact with the petitioner; Christman / was familiar with the site and had conversations with staff regarding the project; Kramer / was familiar with the site and had conversations with both staff and the petitioner; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had meetings with staff related to the project, had not had contact, and had kept an open mind about the project; and Heitmann / was familiar with the site, had met with the petitioner and staff regarding the project, and had not had any other contact. Clay Brooker, Attorney at Cheffy Passidomo, utilized an electronic presentation to outline details of the subject property, including its location, examples of permitted uses, a list of conditional uses, and a site plan for the proposed mixed-use building. He asserted that the project represents the least intense and most compatible use allowed under the City’s regulations for the property. Attorney Brooker highlighted support from residential neighbors and noted that City staff found that the proposal met the conditional use criteria in the Code. He added that the Planning Advisory Board (PAB) had recommended approval of the request. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, continued the electronic presentation with an overview of the proposed site and ground floor plans, second-floor layout, roof design, building elevations, and building interior illustrations. Andrew Rath, Licensed Professional Engineer at Davidson Engineering, explained that vehicular access to the property is limited by Code to 5th Avenue North and provided details on the parking and stormwater management plans. Christian Andrea, Landscape Architect at Architectural Land Design, concluded the presentation with a review of the landscape plan. In response to Council Members’ questions, Architect McLean stated that signage would be located above the commercial space awning. He estimated that residential units would be priced around $1 million and confirmed that each 400 to 500 square-foot, second floor, one-bedroom condominium includes a first-floor garage. He explained that the goal is to foster a small car- culture community and described the potential buyer as a single individual with multiple vehicles or a Naples resident seeking housing for a guest. Planning Director Erica Martin clarified that the residential units and their associated garages are not permitted to be rented as transient units. Engineer Rath provided details regarding the stormwater system, the building roof, and the property seawall, while also noting that the existing five-foot sidewalk will be replaced with an eight-foot sidewalk. Council Member Penniman suggested making the use of pervious pavers on the property a condition for approval.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 6 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Planner Jeffrey Brammer, reviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. He noted that staff found that the standards for approval had been met, however recommend the following conditions: 1) the hours of operation for the commercial space shall be restricted to between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m.; 2) all signage shall be required to adhere to the signage standards in Chapter 50 of the Code of Ordinances; 3) the landscape architect shall provide certification that the landscaping installed is consistent with the plans as approved by City Council prior to final Planning inspection. In addition, he shared the following PAB recommendations; 4) the applicant will include in the condominium documents an actual maintenance plan for the stormwater system that includes means, methods, and required time periods for maintenance; and 5) the garages will be utilized as residential garages, and no car shows, rallies, or gatherings will be held on the property. Architect McLean noted that the commercial space will include seven parking spaces. Planning Director Martin highlighted the low intensity of the proposed mixed-use project. Council Member Kramer expressed concern regarding a previous suggestion to require pervious pavers, noting that it would be unfair to impose additional requirements if the original request met the Stormwater Code. He added that the location would be an ideal spot for beachside residents to move their vehicles during storms. James Whittaker, a River Park resident, raised concerns about the proposed projects elevation and the potential for water runoff onto nearby properties. He also voiced concerns about traffic issues that could result from the increased intensity that may arise from the project. Additionally, he questioned why the Land Management, Stormwater, Traffic, Utility, and Solid Waste Departments had not provided input on the request. Donald Sheehan, a resident of 5th Avenue North, voiced concerns about the number of parking spaces at the proposed location and the potential issues it could create for the neighborhood. Curtis Williams, also a 5th Avenue North resident, highlighted past flooding in the area during storms and expressed concern that the proposed project might worsen the situation. He also questioned why the projects entrance could not be placed on Goodlette Road instead of 5th Avenue North. Vincent Keeys, (sworn in separately) claimed that the River Park Homeowner’s Association (HOA) was not contacted regarding the proposed project. He highlighted the need for improvement in his neighborhood’s stormwater system. Planner Brammer explained that the City’s Streets and Stormwater Division participated in the planning process for the proposed project and proceeded to read their comments. City Engineer Dan Ohrenstein, (sworn in separately), provided additional details about the Stormwater Division’s review process. Planning Director Martin also elaborated on the review process conducted by other departments. Council Member Christman asked to what degree stormwater runoff will impact the River Park community. He suggested continuing the item to allow the opportunity to further study stormwater issues in the area. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar offered details regarding his recent appearance at the River Park HOA meeting. He said short and long-term plans to address stormwater issues were discussed. In response to Mayor Heitmann, City Engineer Ohrenstein explained that rainwater from the property will pass through the stormwater system into the retention pond before flowing into the nearby canal. Architect McLean clarified that under current conditions, rainwater flows directly into the canal. With the proposed site development, he noted that the property will retain four feet of rainwater on-site. He added that in the event of a community-wide flooding event, the overflow system will release water into the canal. Architect McLean attributed much of the flooding in the River Park neighborhood to the low location of overflow levels in the area and concluded that the planned improvements to the property would help alleviate flooding issues in the immediate surroundings. He concluded by agreeing to the stipulation to utilize permeable pavers throughout the site.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 7 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. In response to Council Member Kramer, Planning Director Martin said if a project did not meet the Stormwater Code, it would not come before City Council. If a department’s comments are not included in a report, that would indicate that previous comments have been resolved and there are no conditions moving forward, she added. Council Member Kramer emphasized that the flooding issues in the River Park Community are unrelated to the petitioner’s request. Planning Director Martin pointed out that the Code requires 15 parking spaces for the project, while the petitioner has provided 17. Vice Mayor Hutchison reviewed Section 46-34(d) of the Land Development Code, which outlines the standards for approving a Conditional Use, and stated that, based on those standards, there is no justification to deny the request. Vice Mayor Hutchison further noted that the petitioner had the right to utilize one of the 17 permitted uses for the land, all of which would likely be more intensive than the proposed conditional use request and could include fewer stormwater remediation measures. Council Member Barton highlighted the positive aesthetic appeal of the proposed project, noting its potential to serve as an attractive gateway into the River Park neighborhood. MOTION by Penniman to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15517 subject to adding the following condition: The petitioner has agreed to install permeable pavers throughout the entire driveway and parking area; seconded by Hutchison and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Penniman- yes, Hutchison-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Warranty Deed Survey Aerial Architectural Plans Civil Plans Landscaping Plans Landscaping Plans - Supplemental Vehicle Tracking Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting - October PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - November PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - City Council Correspondence Petitioner Presentation - Design Team (SUPPLEMENT 1/UPDATED TITLE) Petitioner’s Presentation - Cheffy Passidomo (SUPPLEMENT 1/ADDED ATTACHMENT) Recess: 11:38 a.m. to 11:56 a.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. 11.B) RESOLUTION 2024-15518 - A Resolution Relating to a Nonconformity; Determining Nonconformity Petition 24-N2 to Allow for the Vertical and Horizontal Expansion of a Nonconforming Single Family House Pursuant to Section 46-35 of the Code of Ordinances for Property in the R1-10A, Residence District Owned by Mark and Michelle DiMaio, Located at 3888 Crayton Road; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman and Heitmann / had driven by the site but had not had contact; Barton / was familiar with the site and had no contact; Christman / had visited the site, met with the petitioner’s agent, had reviewed the matter with the planning staff, and had reviewed the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) discussion; Kramer / had visited the site and had spoken with the petitioner’s agent and City staff; Petrunoff / had visited the site but had not had contact; and Hutchison / had visited the site, had reviewed the matter with staff, had not had contact with the petitioner, and had maintained an open mind on the project. Francesca Passidomo, Attorney at Coleman Yovanovich Koester, provided a brief overview of the agenda memorandum. Falconer Jones, (sworn in separately), explained that the DiMaio residence was severely damaged during Hurricane Ian in 2022. He noted that the City issued a

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 8 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. demolition permit for the residence in October 2023 and that a petition to allow for rebuilding under nonconformity standards was subsequently submitted by the petitioner. Mr. Jones utilized an electronic presentation that featured an elevation rendering of the proposed home. Planner Jeffrey Brammer reviewed the staff report and outlined the conditions contained therein. He explained that the original house, built in 1970, was situated 31 feet from the front property line, meeting the 30-foot minimum front setback requirement at the time. However, he noted that in 2008, the City amended the Code to impose a 40-foot front setback requirement for residences along Crayton Road, rendering the home a legal nonconformity. Planner Brammer stated that in September 2023, as a result of damage inflicted by Hurricane Ian, City Council approved a 12- month extension for the property owners to rebuild the nonconforming structure. In May 2024, the property owners applied for a building permit to rebuild their house, but the permit was denied because the plans proposed an expansion of the previously existing nonconformity, Planner Brammer explained. He noted that the original house was 60 feet wide, with approximately 22 feet constructed along the existing nonconforming front setback. However, the proposed plans for the new residence expanded the nonconforming area to approximately 80 feet, the entire front length of the new house, and thereby increasing the nonconforming space to 420 square feet. MOTION by Petrunoff to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15518; seconded by Barton and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Hutchison-yes, Penniman-yes, Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Warranty Deed Survey Aerial Architectural Plans Renderings Neighborhood Perspectives Plat Book Ordinance 2008-12049 Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Affidavit of Sign Posting 2 Affidavit of Sign Posting 3 Supplemental - Neighboring Surveys Supplemental - Neighboring Surveys Key Petitioner Presentation 11.C) RESOLUTION 2024-15519 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Amendment No.6 to Site Plan Petition 19-SP8, Approved by Resolution 2019-14421, Relating to a Site Plan for Tract RT-1, and Portions of Tract OS-1, Tract H-1 and Tract BE of The Naples Beach Club Plat for Property Owned by Naples Beach Club Land Trust I, Naples Beach Club Land Trust II, and NBC Club Owner, LLC, Located Within the Naples Beach Club Residences and Golf Club Planned Development at 1090 Crayton Road, More Fully Described Herein, and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / was familiar with the site and had met with the petitioner’s agents; Barton / was familiar with the site, and had met with the petitioner’s agents and staff; Christman / was familiar with the site, had met with the petitioner and petitioner’s agents, and had discussed the matter with the planning staff; Kramer / was familiar with the site and had met with the petitioner and staff; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site, had met with the Planning staff, and had met with advisory groups from the Moorings, Coquina Sands, and Old Naples; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had been to the site, had received communication related to the project, had met with City staff, had met with the petitioner’s agent to discuss the project, had discussions with community residents contiguous to the site, had made no commitments to anyone related to how he would vote on the project, and had kept an open mind; and Heitmann / had met with the petitioner’s agent and petitioners, had received correspondences from the community, and had met with staff.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 9 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Jay Newman, Principal and Chief Operating Officer at The Athens Group, (sworn in separately), announced that as part of the Shade Tree Initiative, the Naples Beach Club had donated shade trees along Gulf Shore Boulevard North, with additional plans to donate trees to Oleander Drive and Crayton Road. Tim McCarthy, Architect, Partner and Managing Principal at Hart Howerton, followed with an electronic presentation detailing the specifics of the Shade Tree Initiative. Clay Brooker, Attorney at Cheffy Passidomo, P.A., stated that the Development Agreement and the Planned Development Document, both approved by City Council in 2019, serve as the governing documents for the Planned Development (PD) lands. He asserted that the request for that day, Amendment Number 6, fully complies with the provisions outlined in both documents. He then utilized an electronic presentation to highlight the setback lines and the approved building envelopes for residences in Phase II, specifically buildings D, F, G, and H, stating that these buildings may be relocated within the envelopes without limitation. He further made the claim that, according to the Development Agreement, the request is consistent with the Naples Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Code. Attorney Brooker provided an overview of the site plan refinement requests for Phase II, stating that the proposed changes would result in an approximately nine percent increase in interior, air- conditioned square footage. However, he emphasized that the PD lot coverage would remain under five percent, and the overall PD density would be reduced from 175 units to 141, with 83 units proposed specifically for the PD. Architect McCarthy utilized an electronic presentation to provide a site plan, a timeline of project approvals, and a list of site plan refinements. He highlighted that the refinements would not affect building height, number of stories, building envelopes, yard setbacks, vehicular access, curb cuts, or traffic impacts. He explained that the original design for the PD Residential District positioned all units to face the Gulf of Mexico. However, the floor plates were adjusted to increase the separation between the buildings. This alteration, he noted, would enhance viewing corridors, improve air circulation, and provide greater separation and privacy between the homes. The presentation concluded with maps revealing the changes to the buildings’ relationship to the public right-of-way, area comparisons, PD density, and safety access. Architect McCarthy then provided details related to the Naples Beach Clubs stormwater management system, emphasizing that it exceeds the City of Naples stormwater requirements by 496 percent. He explained that this was accomplished by redesigning the stormwater system to replace underground vaults with lakes, significantly enhancing their capacity and effectiveness. In response to Mayor Heitmann, Architect McCarthy provided details about the location of the Naples Beach Club Conservation Easement in relation to elements of the PD. He explained the configuration of the three water basins situated within the Conservation Easement, noting that the initial plan for the golf course stormwater system included underground storage vaults. However, the design was revised in favor of a lake system, which he claimed would be more accessible and easier to maintain. Architect McCarthy noted that the addition of four pickleball courts is being considered as part of the Watkins Tennis Centers future enhancements , which would require between 12 and 20 additional parking spaces. He then detailed proposed additions and enhancements to the golf course. Public Comment: Mike Myers expressed gratitude to City Council, staff, and the PAB for their efforts regarding the Naples Beach Club PD amendment petition. Cliff Holland, President of the Moorings Property Owners Association, voiced his support for The Athens Groups work on the Naples Beach Club renovations, and more specifically the PD petition. He added that residents in the Moorings are eager for the work to be completed. Deno Yiankes expressed frustration over delays in approving the Naples Beach Club project, emphasizing that the Four Seasons is a strong community partner providing a project that will benefit the area. Cindy Myers voiced her support for the project and the site plan amendment, adding that her Crayton Road and Oleander

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 10 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Drive neighbors directly affected also support it. Mary Young, (sworn in separately), and representing her neighbors on South Golf Drive, stressed the importance of fully understanding the details of the golf course buildout before the City Council considers approval of the golf course condominiums. She also expressed opposition to the proposed pickleball courts at the Watkins Tennis Center, the use of South Golf Drive for trash and recycling collection and maintaining an 18-hole golf course. In addition, she asked that plantings along the perimeter of the property do not obscure the views of the golf course. Recess: 1:50 p.m. to 2:20 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer reviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. She emphasized that the amendment would reduce the number of dwelling units from 147 to 141. She noted that the PAB recommended approval of the amendment subject to the following condition: should stacking encroach onto Crayton Road or the public sidewalk, the access gate at Crayton must either be eliminated entirely or relocated to the individual garage entrances of Residence G and Residence H. In response to Council Member Barton, Deputy Planning Director Dulmer confirmed that the request stays consistent with the development regulations provided in the planned development, however, the buildings have been moved slightly while staying within the building envelopes. Vice Mayor Hutchison attributed delays in the completion of the project to negotiations regarding the Conservation Easement, and petitioner amendments to the approved site plan. City Attorney McConnell announced that the applicant agreed to provide a gate in the fence around the lake adjacent to Phase II, which is located in the Conservation Easement. He added that the gate is needed to allow for annual inspections of the lake. MOTION by Penniman to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15519; subject to the following changes: 1) removing Condition No. Two and referencing the Water Quality Plan and date in Section 3; and 2) adding the condition regarding the access gate and authorizing the City Attorney to amend the language; seconded by Christman and carried 6-1, all members present and voting (Christman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Hutchison-yes, Penniman-yes, Heitmann-no). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Disclosure of Interest - TRACT BE and TRACT H-1 Disclosure of Interest - TRACT OS-1 Disclosure of Interest - TRACT RT-1 Parcel Sketch and Legal Description Architectural Plans Civil Plans Landscape Plans TIS Section 1 TIS Section 2 Lighting Plans Site Plan Overview Site Plan Supplemental Overview Naples Beach Club Residences and Golf Course - 2019-14420 Declaration of Restrictive Covenants - Residential District of PD Land Reciprocal Access Easement Stormwater Maintenance Plan Affidavit of Sign Posting - PAB November Affidavit of Sign Posting - October PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting- December City Council Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Planning Department Public Notice Mailing Addresses Petitioner Presentation - HH Petitioner Presentation - Owner Remarks Petitioner Presentation - Cheffy Passidomo It is noted for the record that Items 11.D and 11.E were considered concurrently.

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 11 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 11.D) RESOLUTION 2024-15520 - A Resolution Determining Conditional Use Petition 24- CU6 Pursuant to Section X of the Naples Square Planned Development and Section 46-34 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Naples to Allow for a 17-Unit Transient Lodging Establishment as Part of a Mixed-Use Development on the Property Located at 1090 1st Avenue South and Owned by Downtown Naples, LLC, More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution for Item 11.D. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer announced that the petitioner had requested that Items 11.D and 11.E be considered concurrently. City Attorney McConnell recommended allowing the petitioner to present the request for Item 11.D first and then incorporate the presentation into Item 11.E, with City Council proceeding to hold separate motions for each item. He then read the title of the Resolution for Item 11.E. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / was familiar with the site but had not had any contact; Barton / was familiar with the site and had conversations with the petitioner; Christman / was familiar with the site, had met with the petitioner and petitioner’s agent, had met with staff to discuss the project, and reviewed the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) discussion; Kramer / spoke with the petitioner’s agent and spoke with staff; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site but had not had contact; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had been to the site, had received communication related to the project, had met with City staff, had made no commitments on the project, and had kept an open mind; and Heitmann / was familiar with the site, did not meet with the petitioner’s agent, and had no other contact. Kristen Coury, CEO of the Gulfshore Playhouse, addressed the challenges of housing cast members for productions noting that, in the past, accommodations included the Jade at Olde Naples Apartments which were damaged by flooding during Hurricane Ian. She said her request that day was for approval of a new three-story mixed-use development at 1090 1st Avenue South. The proposed building would feature ground-floor commercial or restaurant space with outdoor dining areas, second-floor office space, and 17 transient lodging units, along with one dwelling unit, on the third floor. She added that the 400-square-foot studio apartments would include efficiency kitchens. Ms. Coury clarified that while the request is for transient lodging, Gulfshore Playhouse intends to secure a 20-year lease to provide housing for cast members in future productions, likening the lodging request to corporate housing. Noel Davies, attorney at Davies Duke, utilized an electronic presentation to provide details about the subject property, the Playhouse lodging operations, and benefits of the request. Bob Vayda, architect at Beck Architecture Group, followed with a presentation that included details related to the site plan and elevation renderings of the proposed building. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Ms. Coury explained that hotel rooms were not considered adequate housing for actors due to cost concerns and a union requirement that housing must include kitchens. Deputy Planning Director Dulmer reviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. She clarified, in response to Council Member Petrunoff, that creating a new lodging category, such as Corporate Housing, was not considered. Instead, it was determined that Transient Lodging was the most appropriate existing category. A discussion ensued regarding the City and County rules and requirements for transient lodging. City Attorney McConnell proposed a condition of approval, which included the requirement that the Transient Lodging Use established by the Resolution shall be limited to guest artists and performers of the Gulfshore Playhouse only. City Council may review the Conditional Use permit periodically to determine whether the order complies with the terms and conditions therein. He

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 12 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. emphasized that while Code Enforcement would typically oversee transient lodging compliance, City Council should monitor this specific request, as it has the authority to modify or rescind the Conditional Use approval if necessary. Council Member Barton suggested including a restrictive covenant in the Agreement. Council Member Christman suggested that the lodging language in the City Code is outdated. He noted that, given the scarcity of workforce housing within the City, requests for corporate housing, similar to the one under discussion, might become more frequent in the future. City Attorney McConnell responded by explaining that the City has a grandfathered ordinance governing transient lodging, which was adopted before 2011. He cautioned that if the language in the ordinance were modified, it could lose its grandfathered status. This loss could potentially open the door to allowing Airbnb-style short-term rentals within the City, he cautioned. A discussion ensued regarding whether the units, currently labeled Transient Lodging, could be considered Residential. Planning Director Erica Martin stated that the planned 17 units would exceed the residential density maximum of 12 units on a property less than one acre. Public Comments: Edward Negley declined to speak when called. Mitchell Hertz, a Gulfshore Playhouse Board member, spoke in support of the Gulfshore Playhouse staff housing request. Council Member Petrunoff noted that transient lodging is subject to a six percent tax imposed by the County. She suggested that staff verify whether the Gulfshore Playhouse transient lodging would be exempt from this tax. MOTION by Christman to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15520 subject to adding the following conditions: “the transient lodging use established by the Resolution shall be limited to guest artists and performers of the Gulfshore Playhouse only; and 2) the City Council may review the Conditional Use permit periodically to determine whether the order is in compliance with the terms and conditions herein; seconded by Barton and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Penniman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Kramer-yes, Heitmann-yes). 11.D Attachments Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Deeds Disclosure of Interest Survey Transient Lodging Operations Outline Architectural Plans Area Location Map Renderings Landscape Plans Lighting Plan Civil Plans Traffic Impact Statement Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Planning Department Naples Square Planned Development - Ordinance 2021-14658 Affidavit of Sign Posting - October PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - November PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - City Council Public Notice Mailing Addresses Correspondence Petitioner’s Presentation Petitioner’s Presentation - Civil 11.E) RESOLUTION 2024-15521 - A Resolution Determining Site Plan Petition 23-SP20 for a New Three-Story Mixed-Use Development on Property Owned by Downtown Naples, LLC and Located at 1090 1st Avenue South, More Fully Described Herein and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / had nothing to disclose; Barton / was familiar with the site and had spoken to staff and the petitioner; Christman / was familiar with the site, had spoken with the

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 13 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. petitioner and petitioner’s agent, had spoken with staff to discuss the project, and reviewed the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) discussion; Kramer / was familiar with the site, had spoken to staff, and spoke with the petitioner’s agent; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site, and had nothing to disclose; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had been to the site, had received communication related to the project, had met with City staff, had made no commitments on the project, and had discussed the project extensively that day; and Heitmann / was familiar with the site, and had numerous conversations with staff, the public, and the petitioner. MOTION by Kramer to INCORPORATE the record of Item 11.D into the record of Item 11.E; seconded by Penniman and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer announced that there were four conditions that staff and the PAB recommended: 1) a contribution shall be required for the 1st Avenue South turn lanes or a portion of a potential alternative in advance of the Certificate of Occupancy; 2) improvements along 1st Avenue South shall be coordinated with the Community Redevelopment Agency project for this area. Payment-in-lieu or construction of the improvements fronting the property will be required depending on project timing prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy; 3) the payment-in-lieu amount of $27,495.06 for the 3rd Avenue South and 12th Street South roundabout improvements shall be paid at the time of building permit review and in advance of the Certificate of Occupancy; and 4) the payment-in-lieu cost associated to satisfy 25 of the required parking spaces will be calculated consistent with the Code and payment must be satisfied at the time of building permit review. In response to Council Member Christman, City Engineer Dan Ohrenstein stated that the proposed roundabout at the intersection of 3rd Avenue South and 12th Street South was not feasible. He added that alternative intersection designs were currently being studied. Council Member Christman then inquired whether the payment-in-lieu would be refunded if the roundabout is not constructed. City Attorney McConnell responded by stating he would investigate the matter. MOTION by Hutchison to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15521; seconded by Kramer and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Petrunoff- yes, Hutchison-yes, Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Heitmann-yes). 11.E Attachments Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Deeds Disclosure of Interest Evidence of Signature Authority Survey Architectural Plans Civil Plans Proportionate Share Memorandum Surface Water Management Calculations Solid Waste Generation Calculations Vehicle Tracking Exhibit Landscape Plans Traffic Impact Statement Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Planning Department Naples Square Planned Development - Ord. 2021-14658 Lighting Plan Stormwater Operation & Maintenance Plan Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting - October PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - November PAB Affidavit of Sign Posting - City Council Correspondence Petitioner’s Presentation Petitioner’s Presentation - Civil Recess: 4:09 p.m. to 4:24 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. 11.F) RESOLUTION 2024-15522 - A Resolution Determining Conditional Use Petition 24- CU11 Pursuant to Section 46-34 and Section 58-904 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Naples, to Allow for a Mixed-Use Development including Eighteen (18) Transient Lodging Units to be Located on the Second and Third Floors of the Property Owned

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 14 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. by 590 Tamiami Trial North, Inc. and Located at 570 9th Street North, More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / had driven by the site but had not had contact; Barton / was familiar with the site but had not had contact; Christman / was familiar with the site, had spoken with the petitioner, had spoken with staff to discuss the project, and reviewed the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) discussion; Kramer / was familiar with the site, had spoken with the petitioner, and had spoken with staff; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site and had met with the petitioner; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had been to the site, had spoken to staff about the project, had reviewed the pertinent PAB discussion, had spoken to the petitioner, had made no commitments to anyone on the project, and had kept an open mind; and Heitmann / had spoken to the petitioner, watched the pertinent Design Review Board (DRB) and the PAB discussions, and met with staff. Property owner Gordon Stojkoski delivered opening remarks, followed by Noel Davies, Attorney at Davies Duke, who utilized an electronic presentation to summarize the Conditional Use request for a luxury boutique hotel at 590 Tamiami Trail North. He remarked that the proposed hotel would feature 18 suites on the second and third floors, with a 6,500-square-foot restaurant on the ground floor. Attorney Davies explained that, given the hotels proximity to Naples Community Hospital, he anticipated that many guests would likely be visitors to hospital patients. He noted that parking would be located behind the hotel, eliminating the dangerous parking situation along Tamiami Trail that exists at the present location. He then spoke about how the project would reinforce redevelopment themes found in the Comprehensive Plan. He claimed that the proposed project fits the redevelopment vision of the D-Downtown district and meets all elements of the Code. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, continued the presentation by sharing a site plan and announced the ground floor would be occupied by Aqua restaurant and would include outdoor dining. He then offered details regarding parking and the location of living spaces and amenities on the floor plan. He also shared renderings featuring building elevations, hotel amenities, and interior features. Architect McLean noted that arriving guests could either park along 6th Street North or utilize the covered drop off / valet area behind the building. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Architect McLean explained that rainwater would be directed to drain internally, preventing staining on the buildings exterior façade. A discussion ensued regarding the term "true hotel" as mentioned in one of the PAB’s conditions for approval. In response to Council Member Barton, Architect McLean clarified that all parking in the D- Downtown District is designated as shared parking. Architect McLean then outlined the noise mitigation measures incorporated into the hotels design. Planner Jeffrey Brammer reviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. He then reviewed the nine conditions offered by the PAB for approval. MOTION by Kramer to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15522 subject to authorizing the City Attorney to modify Condition No. 9 by replacing “true hotel” with a legal definition; seconded by Hutchison and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Kramer-yes, Hutchison-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Disclosure of Interest - Owner Warranty Deed Affidavit of Authorization Survey Aerial Architectural Plans Landscape Plans Civil Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Affidavit of Sign Posting - City Council

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 15 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Petitioner Presentation 11.G) RESOLUTION 2024-15523 - A Resolution Determining Variance Petition 24-V2 Pursuant to Section 58-176 of the City of Naples Code of Ordinances to Allow for Encroachment into the Rear Yard Setback for the Purpose of Installing a Whole Home Emergency Generator at the Property Owned by the Sissel H. Cooper Revocable Living Trust Located at 656 5th Avenue North, More Fully Described Herein with a Date Effective. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / had driven by the site but had not had contact; Barton / no contact; Christman and Kramer / were familiar with the site and reviewed the project with staff; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site but had not had contact; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had discussions with staff, but had no other contact; and Heitmann / had reviewed the information but had not had contact. Peter Voss, a resident of 656 5th Avenue North, stated that he was requesting a variance to accommodate an emergency generator on his property. He then used an electronic presentation to illustrate how the houses footprint utilizes the propertys setbacks. Senior Planner Nathan Jones reviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. Council Member Christman expressed the opinion that the current request did not meet the City’s established variance criteria. He proposed adding a discussion to a future agenda aimed at revising the City’s variance regulations to address similar concerns in the future. Specifically, the suggested focus should be on revisions for single-family residences to allow for minor variance approvals, ensuring clearer and more accommodating guidelines moving forward, he noted. In response, Planning Director Erica Martin suggested that residents incorporate ample setbacks into their home designs to accommodate the inclusion of a generator. MOTION by Kramer to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15523; seconded by Penniman and carried 4-3, all members present and voting (Hutchison-no, Penniman-yes, Christman-no, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Petrunoff-no, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution PAB Staff Report Application Disclosure of Interest- Property Owner Warranty Deed Proof of Ownership Survey Credentials- Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting 11.H) RESOLUTION 2024-15524 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Live Entertainment Petition 24-LE3, Amending Indoor and Outdoor Live Entertainment Established by Resolution 2023-15221; Providing Indoor Live Entertainment with Doors and Windows Closed with a Maximum of Two Entertainers Wednesday through Saturday from 12:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. and Sunday from 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.; Providing Outdoor Amplified Live Entertainment with a Maximum of Two Entertainers Wednesday through Saturday from 12:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. and Sunday from 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. for the AC Marriott Hotel on Property Owned by Palmetto Hospitality of Naples, a Florida Limited Liability Company and Located at 455 12th Street South, More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex-parte disclosures: Penniman / was familiar with the site but had not had contact; Barton / had met with the petitioner and staff; Christman / was familiar with the site, had met with the petitioner and staff, and listened to the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) discussion; Kramer / was familiar with the site and had met with the petitioner and staff; Petrunoff / was familiar with the site

City Council Regular Meeting – December 11, 2024 – 8:33 a.m. 16 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. but had not had contact; Hutchison / was familiar with the site, had been to the site, had spoken to staff, had attempted to meet with the petitioner to discuss the project, and had made no commitments related to the project; and Heitmann / had spoken to the petitioner but had no further contact. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to review the petitioner’s request to allow amplified music in areas on property that currently accommodate non-amplified entertainment. He emphasized that the request is needed to attract additional entertainers. Council Member Petrunoff raised concerns about a $20 parking fee for hotel guests, noting that she had received complaints that it often leads to guests parking in the neighboring Naples Square residential areas. In response, Planning Director Erica Martin clarified that charging for parking at the hotel was prohibited. Architect McLean stated that his client was unaware of such practices but indicated that it would stop immediately. Council Member Petrunoff also addressed concerns regarding amplified music disrupting Bayfront residents. Architect McLean explained that sound studies indicate that amplified music should not carry to Bayfront. City Attorney McConnell noted that staff recommendations require all amplified music to be played through centralized speakers with volume controls secured in a lockbox accessible only to the General Manager, ensuring individuals could not adjust the amplification. Planning Director Martin outlined the noise violation enforcement policy, noting the City allows a six-month prohibitionary period followed by a limit of two verified violations within a calendar year. Vice Mayor Hutchison suggested a condition that a hotel staff member should always have access to the volume control, ensuring the ability to manage sound levels promptly if needed. Planner Jeffrey Brammer reviewed

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Regular Meeting — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 149c1c3341fb78065a010538b1336ee5. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record