POLISCOPE

The public record

ST. LUCIE COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners- Informal Meeting

Tuesday, April 15, 2025 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

St. Lucie County Pavement Management Plan

The Board discussed a regional flood vulnerability assessment, conceptual plans for the Harbour Pointe Park boat ramp, a new data-driven pavement management strategy, and potential revisions to economic incentive programs. Commissioners also reached a 4-1 consensus to pursue the acquisition of 400 acres of environmentally sensitive land in partnership with Oak Ridge Ranches.

Why it matters

Residents may see changes in road maintenance priorities, future boat ramp access, and the criteria used to award tax breaks and grants to local businesses.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

Official minutes publish outcomes and identify speakers and the topics they addressed.

Captured actions

4

Recorded outcomes

4

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

4 captured items have a publicly linked outcome.

Search all 4 meeting actions

Recorded votes

2 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (2)

approved

St. Lucie County Pavement Management Plan — Consensus reached to prioritize discussed roadways.

approved

Land Acquisition (400 acres) — Passed 4-1

Money

People and votes

Erin Lowry

Present at this meeting

3 statements

  1. Statement

    Commented on the safety issues and damage to vehicles on the roadways.

    Official record
  2. Statement

    Commented on increasing the percentage of the average wage, being in favor of.

    Official record
  3. Statement

    Commented on the preservation of the land, blocking mechanisms for the County to.

    Official record
See all 2 roll calls with named votes

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 63,437 characters. The full document is at the source.

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Informal Meeting April 15, 2025 Convened: 9:00 AM Adjourned: 12:06 AM 1. CALL TO ORDER - JAMIE FOWLER, CHAIR, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS The meeting was called to order at 9:00 AM by Chair Jamie Fowler, District No. 4. Present Commissioner Jamie Fowler, District 4; Commissioner Larry Leet, District 2; Commissioner James Clasby, District 1; Commissioner Erin Lowry, District 3; Commissioner Cathy Townsend, District 5 Also Present Dan McIntyre, County Attorney George Landry, County Administrator Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator Jason Davis, Deputy County Administrator Sandra Bogan, Resilience Navigator Georgia Vince, Tetra Tech Marcy Frick, Tetra Tech Joshua Revord, Port Director Duncan Greer, Taylor Engineering Patrick Dayan, Public Works Director Benjamin Balcer, Planning & Development Services Director Wes McCurry, St. Lucie County Economic Development Council Senior Vice President Sydney Halleran, Agenda Coordinator Vera Smith, Deputy Clerk Recording Secretary 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Draft St. Lucie County Regional Resilience Vulnerability Assessment Sandra Bogan, Innovation Resilience and Performance Division, Resilience Navigator, Georgia Vince, and Marcy Frick of Tetra Tech presented this item to the Board. The County drafted the Regional Resilience Vulnerability Assessment. The assessment results from a collaborative effort between St Lucie County and Port St. Lucie, Fort Pierce, and St. Lucie Village, aimed at evaluating the vulnerability of the existing infrastructure to various flooding hazards. Completing the assessment is an essential step in ensuring eligibility for Resilient Florida Infrastructure funding through their grant process and can provide the opportunity to support projects that address future community needs. This is the first of two public

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 2 | P a g e meetings required by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection grant agreement. The final vulnerability assessment will be presented for adoption in early June after incorporating Board/community input. Georgia Vince of Tetra Tech advised that the vulnerability assessment is funded through a Florida Department of Environmental Protection planning grant, ensuring eligibility for future implementation grants. The assessment is a collaborative effort with other municipalities and stakeholders, and has involved a robust steering committee since 2021. The assessment evaluates present and future flood risks based on state criteria, synergizing groups, resources, and assists with the timing of projects. This allows diverse groups to coordinate more fluidly at the regional level. The Resilient Florida program was enacted in 2021 through Florida statute, requiring the creation of the Florida Flood Hub through the University of South Florida (USF). The program updates the statewide sea level rise and flooding vulnerability assessment every five years. The Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) develops an annual sea level rise and flooding variance plan, identifying projects for funding. Planning grants require no match, while infrastructure grants provide a 50% match to local governments, encouraging nature- based solutions. She provided a map showing various locations of both planning and project implementation grants. She advised that to date, there has been $1.8 billion awarded through the program. The County vulnerability assessment developed a comprehensive strategy to identify flood risks, types of flooding hazards, assets at risk, and encompass the entire County boundary. The assessment uses the most recent elevation data and NOAA sea level rise projections for 2017, 2040, and 2070. It includes evaluating high tide, storm surge, rainfall-induced flooding, and compound flooding, which are all of those put together. Data is collected on community assets, including transportation, critical infrastructure, emergency facilities, and natural, cultural, and historic resources. The assessment includes a sensitivity analysis to prioritize assets most at risk, with community and stakeholder input sought for asset importance. She advised that sea level rise is defined as the increase in ocean levels, while high tide flooding is characterized by contemporary inundation of low-lying areas, often named king tides. Storm surges are associated with extreme weather events like tropical storms and hurricanes, and rainfall- induced flooding occurs when existing systems are overwhelmed by excessive rainfall. Compound flooding combines high tide, storm surge, rainfall, and other factors in a worst-case scenario. Ms. Vince presented a diagram illustrating the progression of flooding events from the present day to future scenarios, highlighting the severity of compound events. Critical assets that are outlined in the statute include transportation, critical infrastructure, critical community and emergency facilities, natural, cultural, and historical resources. The statute also requests the identification of regional assets for coordination with other entities, such as FDEP, I-95, the turnpike, and other regional assets. The exposure and sensitivity analysis completed determines which assets are exposed to specific flood events and to what level. The assets are written to identify current and future needs. The maps utilized are GIS-based maps and show the elevation of land with the depth of flooding, without incorporating existing stormwater management infrastructure. She advised that the component is being managed by Marcy Frick in stormwater management plan separately. The sea level rise maps show present-day, intermediate high for 2040, and 2070 scenarios, highlighting low-lying areas at risk. The maps prepared are county- wide and are specific to just one map within that whole map series. The flood depth maps are GIS-based, showing the expected increase in days of tidal flooding, with some areas experiencing over 150 days of tidal flooding. The 100-year 24-hour storm event is compared across different planning horizons, showing the expected increase in storm surge. In the present day, storm surges Category 3 and 5 along the

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 3 | P a g e coastline of the St. Lucie River are tidally influenced. Compound flooding maps combine all components, illustrating the severity of future flooding scenarios. The sensitivity analysis overlays flooding maps with asset locations, using color dots to indicate flooding depths. Assets are ranked by vulnerability level: high, medium, and low, with high being red and low being yellow. Examples of maps for White City, Port St. Lucie, Fort Pierce, and St. Lucie Village show the impact of flooding on various infrastructure and community assets. The final vulnerability assessment will integrate community comments and be presented for adoption in early June. The takeaways from the presentation are that the County will be affected by increased flooding in the future. The vulnerability assessment is required by the County or the municipalities to qualify for the implementation grants through the Resilience Florida Program. The final vulnerability assessment will integrate comments from the community and be presented for adoption. Commissioner Leet inquired about the current status of projections and the timeframe of the analysis. In response, Ms. Vince explained that the Department of Environmental Protection has updated the NOAA projections to use 2022 data. The analysis now considers planning horizons of 2050 and 2080, with increasing confidence in results over time. She advised that the analysis has been conducted for five years, starting in 2021. Commissioner Townsend mentioned the ongoing projects with NOAA and upcoming grant approvals. Commissioner Clasby asked about the cost of the studies versus grant funding in the County. In response, Ms. Bogan advised that three grants were received from the Resilient Florida program, totaling $400,000. The initial funding in 2021 included state and federal ARPA funds, with matching funds required. She explained that the amount of funding depends on matching funds and state criteria. She advised that the study began last year, and the grant portal opens July 1 st through September, and then the state ranks the projects submitted statewide in December, and the list is published in December of the ranked projects around the state. The state legislature determines the amount of funding for the projects. Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator, mentioned that the presented vulnerability study was grant-funded, and there was a minimal match. So, of the $400,000, the County’s share was 10% ($30,000), and with the study, the County will be eligible for future grants. Chair Fowler questioned the total funding pot for resiliency projects. In response, Ms. Bogan explained that though the legislature is required to fund at least $100 million, recent funding has reached $200 million. Commissioner Leet inquired about other municipalities' access to grants and the need for vulnerability studies. In response, Ms. Bogan advised that the vulnerability assessment makes the entire St Lucie County eligible for funding. Collaboration with other municipalities can lead to common projects that benefit the entire community. The Board discussed the vulnerability assessment and benefits for the community. No consensus was made; the presentation was for informational purposes. B. Harbour Pointe Park Regional Boat Ramp - Preferred Alternative (Conceptual) Joshua Revord, Port, Inlet & Beaches Director, and Duncan Grier of Taylor Engineering presented to the

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 4 | P a g e Board an updated conceptual design with design phase elements for the Harbour Pointe Park Regional Boat Ramp. The project for consideration has three main components: New Harbour Pointe Access Corridor, Harbour Pointe Regional Boat Ramp, and a Regional Stormwater Management Facility. The New Harbour Pointe Access Corridor is fully funded with $6 million from the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT). It is on track to be fully designed and ready for construction by next year, with 30% to 60% completion expected by the middle of summer. The project is on track to potentially be fully designed for next year and going out to bid to construct the access corridor, which will allow the County legal access to the property in over 20 years. The Harbour Pointe Regional Boat Ramp to date has a 10% basis of design that helped establish a baseline elevation for future build out and is consistent with the vulnerability assessment for the RFQ with Taylor Engineering for design services. Surveying has been conducted to improve the space, including geotechnical studies, assessments of upland and nearshore environments, and initial permitting discussions with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). Staff recommended continued due diligence to support more effective use of the park. The project emphasizes resiliency, featuring a finished floor elevation of 7.5 feet to accommodate projected sea-level rise over the next 50 years, in line with state requirements and to support future grant eligibility. The design incorporates strategies to manage storm surge by directing water off-site. Staff presented an overview of the 2020 Port Master Plan in support of the current preferred alternative. This plan includes 79 dedicated trailer parking spaces, with the option of 14 additional overflow spaces, bringing the total to 93. For comparison, the County’s largest existing boat ramp, the Stan Blum Boat Ramp, offers 50 trailer parking spaces. The preferred alternative also includes 70 standard vehicle parking spaces, a multipurpose staging area, and a commercial waterfront zone. This waterfront space is envisioned for marine-related initiatives by the Erosion District and Artificial Reef Program. Additionally, the plan features a hardscape area designed to accommodate potential vendors, including food trucks and Conex units. The goal is to enhance community appeal and maximize the use of the park. A roundabout is also included in the conceptual plan to facilitate future traffic flow within the site. Duncan Grier of Taylor Engineering provided an overview of the design configuration, guiding principles for the project, and reiterated portions of the staff's presentation. He advised that the project focus on clean user functionality, green space, and clear recreational benefits. The design includes the separation of trailer vehicle movements from vehicle-only parking movements, pedestrian circulation, floating docks, flexible/temporary mooring use, separation of launching lanes, a separate multi-function commercial waterfront, and wide drive aisles for easy access. The launching lanes are designed to be wide for faster entry and exit, reducing turning and backing movements. Mr. Revord continued and provided an overview of the identified funding and advised that the project is fully funded at this time from a design standpoint, with $0.5 million being approved as part of the current budget, a new grant opportunity with Florida Inland Navigation District (F.I.N.D.) securing $250,000, with an upwards $750,000 total for design. There is also an active Florida Boater Improvement Program (FBIP) application with the Florida Wildlife Commission (FWC) submitted for an additional $250,000. With the preferred alternatives, the construction elements will be phased out, with Phase I being the total cost of the Boat Ramp Facility, absent the multipurpose station and commercial waterfront area. Phase II is identified at $4.1 million, with the contingency slightly higher, and at this time, PIB is exploring the possibility of utilizing Erosion District funding. Phase III is a smaller phase tied

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 5 | P a g e to the master plan update. In terms of construction funding, it includes the sale of Chuck's Seafood/Fire Station Property, which is estimated at $2.6 million and tentatively earmarked for this project as an addition to being fully funded. There is an interlocal agreement with the City of Fort Pierce Redevelopment Agency, and in a recent meeting, there was a consensus that this was an appropriate use of the interlocal agreement funding. This brings the funding up to an estimated $4.6 million, and with the current $0.5 million in Port Reserves and an estimated $5 million with the potential to flex the remaining reserves depending on the outcome of the terminal improvements. The two big remaining factors left are the F.I.N.D. and Cooperative Assistance Program (CAP) funding to pursue next year, and the FWC-FBIP Program also provided additional funding for construction. Based on the trajectory of the new access road, there will likely be construction on the road by this time next year to be substantially complete with roadway improvements. The goal is to secure funding in the current and next fiscal years to start construction on the roadway improvement by next year. Staff highlighted the statistical need for more dedicated trailer parking spaces within the County, with only 147 spaces within a 3-mile radius of the inlet and an estimated 14,000 registered vessels under 40 ft, creating a major deficiency. As of May 2024, there are 50 dedicated parking spaces for over 90 boat trailers at the Stan Blum Boat Ramp, and 11 dedicated spaces for over 40 boat trailers at the Black Pearl Boat Ramp. The project aims to address the deficit in trailer parking spaces and improve access to the waterfront. The proposed design is plus or minus 10 acres, leaving 11 acres unencumbered, 3 acres potentially decommissioned after the Regional Stormwater Pond is aligned. The project aims to provide a better experience for boaters and improve the overall utilization of the park and waterfront areas. Commissioner Townsend asked for clarification on the completion of the roadway. In response, Mr. Revord advised that the roadway should be completed by the end of 2026. They are currently at 30% completion and expect to reach 60% soon. The permitting phase is anticipated to be completed later this year, with full design expected by the end of the year. Construction is expected to start early next year, with an estimated duration of six to nine months, and the goal is to have the project completed by the end of 2026. Commissioner Townsend mentioned that the Board voted against the Shelley Project, which is not supported at the Port, and there was confusion in the community about the Board's stance on the project. She also mentioned a lawsuit involving the City of Fort Pierce and the city's attempt to involve the County in the lawsuit. She questioned the Board's consideration of the legal path forward to taking control of the Port Authority to take over the Port directorship, given their financial contributions and resources. In response, Dan McIntyre advised that, from his understanding that the County oversees the current Port; however, being that the Port is inside the City, they have land use and zoning control over the property. The Board has been cooperating with the City and jointly adopting plans, such as the Port Master Plan, years ago. The County could collaborate with the City to address the Port's land use and zoning issues and jointly develop a vision to incorporate into the Port Master Plan, which would be the preferred alternative. Commissioner Townsend suggested incorporating Joshua Revord, Port, Inlet & Beaches Director, in the decision-making to expedite the project. She also mentioned the importance of tourism, economic drivers to benefit the County, budget allocations for the Port, Inlet & Beaches Director, and opportunities for small businesses.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 6 | P a g e Commissioner Clasby discussed the City's rezoning process and the preference for conditional uses over permitted uses, land use rights to the Port, and interlocal agreements with the City. He suggested involving the Tourist Development Council in renaming the road to create a tourist-friendly area with commercial operations and public access. For the record, he stated he is in favor of utilizing funding from the Erosion District to fund parts of the project if allowed. Commissioner Lowry and Commissioner Leet commented on the project design and public access. Commissioner Clasby mentioned including amenities like food vendors, ice machines, and wash-down stations to generate revenue and suggested charging for additional service stations to cover maintenance costs. The Board and staff discussed the increase in boat ramps/lanes, floating docks, parking, the importance of protecting public access to the waterfront, options for food trucks and other vendors to generate revenue, meeting with City officials to share the Board's vision, permits for vendors to operate at the site, and availability of space. No consensus was made; the presentation was for informational purposes. C. St. Lucie County Pavement Management Plan Patrick Dayan, Public Works Director, presented an overview of the County’s data-driven Pavement Management Plan to the Board, highlighting the long-term strategy for maintaining and improving road infrastructure. The plan outlines the structure of the County's roadway network, funding sources, pavement management framework, analysis, outcomes, and the proposed five-year plan. The County’s roads are categorized into local, collector, and arterial roads, with arterial roads being the primary focus of this study. Every ten years, the Federal Highway Administration evaluates local roads to determine their eligibility for federal disaster assistance. The County maintains approximately 600 centerline miles of roadway, about two-thirds are local roads, while the remaining third are collector and arterial roads. Nearly all major roadways are surfaced with asphalt. As with other municipalities, road repaving is primarily funded through fuel taxes. Revenue is generated from both a state constitutional fuel tax and a local fuel tax on each gallon of fuel sold. Most of this revenue supports operations, covering staff, materials, and equipment, with only a small portion, historically about $650,000, allocated to actual repaving. A major turning point came in 2018, when a voter-approved surtax provided a significant boost to repaving funds, supplemented further by general fund contributions. Historical funding data shows increased capital investment in recent years in road repaving. Historically, road repaving decisions have been based on public complaints and pothole reports—a reactive method that does not optimize spending. The County is now facing poor road conditions, with the cost of repair, restoration, or reconstruction escalating. Additionally, a large portion of current investments is being used on only a small segment of the network. Post-pandemic inflation has further driven up resurfacing costs, prompting a shift from reactive pavement maintenance to proactive pavement management. The strategy is shifting from pavement maintenance to pavement management, focusing on proactive maintenance to prevent road degradation. Staff explained the benefits of preventative maintenance using relatable analogies to avoid more expensive repairs. Mr. Dayan advised that the data collected in December 2023 and 2024 involved a consultant using advanced technology to assess road rideability, cracks, and conduct structural tests for the major road network. The data was used to develop a GIS-based Pavement Condition Index (PCI) for each segment,

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 7 | P a g e rated on a scale of 0 to 100. The average PCI for the County’s major roads is currently 80, reflecting the positive effects of the surtax investment. In comparison, Port St. Lucie and West Palm Beach have citywide PCIs of 64 and 71, respectively. Data collection for local roads is pending, but overall scores are expected to decrease slightly once those figures are included. Staff also shared photos illustrating road conditions of very poor, poor, marginal, fair, good, and very good roads. The roads represent a small portion of the County’s network, estimated at 1.5% of the total road network. These are referred to as backlog roads and are suggested to be placed at the end of the cycle. Repair strategies vary depending on road conditions. For example, full-depth reclamation, used for fair roads, involves milling, injecting asphalt emulsion and concrete, and repaving, at a cost of roughly $50 per square yard. Staff provided an overview of how the pavement condition index is used to optimize expenditure and ensure that resources are allocated effectively, with various funding scenarios ranging from a very high budget to a more moderate budget over 5 years. The PCI data is central to optimizing expenditures and planning under various budget scenarios. The plan proposes targeted investments, including Shinn Road in year one and Sneed Road in year two, selected due to alignment with sales tax revenue and growth patterns. The recommended five- year plan calls for a $4.7 million annual allocation, with an additional $1 million being pursued through the FY 2026 budget process. The aim is to maintain an average PCI of 80 and protect the County’s road infrastructure investment. The staff's recommendations to the Board include: 1. Transition from a "worst-first" approach to a “cost of deferred maintenance” strategy to preserve recent investments. 2. Maintain a target PCI of 80 for the arterial and collector road network. 3. Allocate $4 million annually from the surtax, plus $1 million through the FY 2026 budget process, to fund arterial and collector roads. 4. Reevaluate major roadways in the future to confirm model accuracy. 5. Dedicate $650,000 in fuel tax revenue and pursue an additional $1 million through FY 2026 to repave local roads and assess their conditions. Staff requested that the Board consider and adopt the plan’s findings and recommendations. Commissioner Clasby discussed the importance of reallocating existing budget funds for road improvements rather than raising taxes. He suggested scanning local roads for potholes and questioned the frequency of road scanning. He discussed CIP sheets and funding to rebuild roadways, and specified Glades Cut-Off Road between Selvitz and Midway Road. He also raised an issue with the stripping and cracking of Delaware Avenue and the feasibility of having an in-house striping crew. In response, Mr. Dayan agrees with the need to scan local roads, and that the frequency of scanning should be based on the municipality's needs, typically three to five years. Staff discussed the high costs of thermoplastic striping and the benefits of having an in-house striping crew. Staff will gather information and report back to the Board regarding the in-house striping. Commissioner Townsend mentioned that the focus on road maintenance has been a priority for all Boards, and that $6 million was left over in 2023 and split between the Sheriff's Department and the County to

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 8 | P a g e catch up on road maintenance. Chair Fowler asked about the life expectancy of different overlay options, for alternative surfaces such as slurry versus chip seal milling. In response, Mr. Dayan explained that the life expectancy of the strategies depends on the number of vehicles and the ageing of the road. Commissioner Leet asked about repairs to Glades Cut-Off Road and the priority of the roadway. In response, Mr. Dayam advised that per the plan, the roadway was scheduled to be done in year four from Midway Road to the Turnpike, but with the additional road strategy, it could be limited from the turnpike to Selvitz Road to be done within the next 5 years. The timing of the additional road may be dependent upon how the costs are for the remainder projects, which can be seen in years three and four. Commissioner Townsend commented that she disagrees with the priority of the roadway being a 4 to 5- year project out. She mentioned that from Selvitz Road to Midway Road is the worst at causing vehicle damage and should be the number one road moving forward, at the beginning of the project. Commissioner Lowry commented on the safety issues and damage to vehicles on the roadways. Mr. Dayan advised that the priority of the roads is at the will of the Board. The data is not optimized, and if any road segments need to be accelerated despite the data, staff will follow the direction of the Board. In response, Commissioner Townsend expressed the need for better communication among the Board members to ensure the roads are prioritized correctly. Commissioner Clasby discussed the priority of Glades Cut-Off Road between Selvitz Road and Midway Road, improvements to the Delaware Avenue and 33 rd Street projects. He also suggested that the road projects not be completed during school hours. In response, Mr. Dayan advised that there is a reconstruction project for 33 rd Street and Delaware, which is under design in the 30-60% plans, and there is an interlocal agreement with the City of Fort Pierce to assist in participation in construction funding. The Glades Cut-Off Road between Selvitz Road project is continuing at 60% design, and work is being done with property owners to obtain pond sites, with the need for one pond site south of Ten Mile Creek. There is a plan to realign the intersection and remove the dangerous offset skewed intersection and relocate the roadway away from the railroad tracks, which is a benefit for the FEC and the County. George Landry, County Administrator, reiterated the importance of Board feedback in prioritizing road projects and the flexibility of staff adjusting based on Board decisions. He mentioned that presentations are based on data but open to Board adjustments for prioritization. He discussed the Delaware Avenue interchange and interlocal agreement with Fort Pierce, with shared cost, and the plan to schedule the project outside of school times. Chair Fowler requested an emailed list of County roadways to the Board and their rating to help identify the priority roads for maintenance. In response, Mr. Dayan advised that he would provide the list to the Board. Upon discussion of the Board and staff, a consensus was reached to prioritize the discussed roadways. D. Targeted Industry Incentives - ADD ON

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 9 | P a g e Benjamin Balcer, Planning & Development Services Director, and Wes McCurry, Senior VP of SLC Economic Development Council (EDC), presented the Board with an overview of the County’s existing economic incentive programs for targeted industries. The relevant state statute that empowers counties to actively invest in economic development is specifically section 125.045 of the Florida Statutes (F.S.). The statute allows counties to spend public funds to attract and retain businesses, including providing grants or loans to private entities, marketing efforts to attract businesses, and funding for economic development organizations such as the St. Lucie County EDC. The statute recognizes economic development as a valid public purpose and requires transparency. Currently, staff is working with the EDC to file an annual report with the state’s Office of Economic and Demographic Research outlining the County’s expenditures related to economic development incentives. Section 196.1995 of the F.S. allows local governments to grant ad valorem tax exemptions to new and expanding businesses as an incentive for economic development. This exemption requires voter approval by referendum, and if approved, they are granted a period of up to 10 years. The tax exemptions can apply to real property improvements and tangible personal property, and encourage job creation and promote capital investment in the County. The tax exemption requires improvements to real property to be made where the tangible personal property is added after the local government body approves an incentive resolution and requires Board approval of a tax exemption ordinance at a public hearing. The tax exemption only applies to taxes levied by the unit of government granting that exemption. Section 196.012 of the F.S. provides key definitions on who and what qualify for economic incentive programs such as the ad valorem tax exemptions. This section defines a new business and an expansion of an existing business as an organization that establishes 10 or more new jobs to employ 10 or more full-time employees, paying an average wage for the new jobs that is above the average wage for the area. Section 288.005 of the F.S. provides multiple definitions used in state-level economic development programs and initiatives. The definitions provide consistency on how economic development terms are used across different jurisdictions. The term "targeted industry" is defined as a high-value sector contributing to Florida's economic diversification, likely to pay higher-than-average wages. They fall within industries designated by the Florida Department of Commerce, such as advanced manufacturing, life sciences, aviation, and aerospace. These businesses are generally more stable than others and have a positive economic impact on the state and regional economy. These statutes reinforce that economic development serves a public purpose when used responsibly. Mr. Balcer advised in addition to the expedited permitting that the County offers, there are three performance-based monetary incentives available for new and expanding businesses that fall within the County's targeted industry list. The incentives include the County's Job Growth Investment Grant, Impact Fee Mitigation, and Ad Valorem Tax Exemption. The County's adopted criteria for qualifying for these incentives require the creation of a minimum of 10 jobs with an average wage of 107% of the County's average. The current St. Lucie County average annual wage is $23.85, and 107% of that equates to $25.52 per hour. Staff also included calculations for other percentages in case the Board was interested in discussing the wage eligibility criteria to qualify for the incentive program. He mentioned that the Florida housing programs define moderate income in their workforce housing income categories between 80 and 120% of the area median income. The County median income levels are slightly higher than the average St. Lucie County wage, grouped with Martin County. For housing purposes, 120% of the County area median income weights to $30.42. Staff provide a graph overview of the typical lifecycle of an economic development project, starting with the initial vetting by the St Lucie EDC. County staff verify incentive eligibility and assist in drafting the County's economic incentive

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 10 | P a g e package. The EDC scheduled a time to meet with the Board to discuss the project's scope and public benefits. The County Attorney, staff, and the EDC collaborate on drafting the incentive resolution, which is ultimately brought to the Board for consideration as a regular agenda item and serves as an agreement between the County and the company outlining job creation and capital investment requirements. These are the job growth investment agreement and the impact fee mitigation agreement. These agreements outline the incentive requirements, including performance standards, terms of the agreement, and benchmarks for job creation, and also annual reporting requirements. If the company is eligible for an ad valorem tax exemption, they are required to provide the necessary application to County staff following the construction of the building and investment in their equipment. County staff provides the application to the Property Appraiser, who conducts their separate economic analysis. Concurrently, Planning and Development Services, staff, and the County Attorney work to draft the ad valorem exemption ordinance, which outlines the amount and duration of the company's tax exemption. The proposed tax exemption ordinance must be heard and approved by the Board, which occurs at a public hearing, and once approved, the ordinance will be provided to the Property Appraiser, who then recognizes the tax exemption on the company’s TRIM notice. The company then creates the required jobs following the approved job growth investment grant and provides annual reports to the County and the EDC to verify performance. Mr. Balcer provided an overview of each economic development incentive individually. First, the County’s Job Growth Incentive Program was created in 1994 to stimulate economic growth by attracting new businesses and encouraging expansion. The program pays for a new or expanding target industry company based on the number of jobs created over five years. For eligibility, the company must create at least 10 new jobs paying at least 107% of the County's average wage, which is $25.52. The program pays the company a minimum of $1,500 per new job. However, the company can receive bonuses up to $3,075 per job based on the number of jobs created, paying an average salary of 125% or 150% of the County's average annual wage. Hiring more than 90% of County residents, and using local contractors if the company is proposing a construction activity. The program was amended slightly in 2015 to add new standards for locally owned and operated, owned businesses. They are defined as a targeted industry operating in the County for at least three years, employs 50 or fewer people, and is owned and operated by a St. Lucie, Martin, Indian River, or Okeechobee County resident. For these businesses, they must make a $1 million capital investment, and their wage range is reduced to 100% of the County's average wage. The Job Growth Investment Grant Program is a performance-based incentive where the company meets the job creation and wage requirements outlined in their job growth investment grant award agreement. For the year they receive a grant award, payment funds are distributed by the County over two years if the award is less than $50,000 and over five years if the award exceeds $50,000, at 20% of the award per year. If the company fails to meet the job creation commitment for the year, but achieves at least 85% of the job total. The grant award is recalculated using the actual job creation amount, and it's reduced further by 50%. If the company does not meet at least 85% of their job creation commitment, they forfeit any payment of the grant funds for that year. The agreement between the company and the County also includes clawback provisions if the company relocates within five years of the last job growth investment grant payment. The County requires five years of annual reporting after the last grant payments to verify if that portion of the agreement has been met. Staff provided a graph of the annual job growth investment since 2016, showing growth in the local economy within the manufacturing, distribution, and logistics industries. In 2023/2024, job growth investment payments were made to four targeted industry businesses.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 11 | P a g e The second economic incentive is the Impact Fee Mitigation Program, providing the Board with the ability to grant impact fee mitigation to qualified targeted industry projects. The program could provide mitigation for up to 100% of the County's impact fees due. Three scenarios would qualify a company to request this waiver from the Board. The first is a targeted industry that creates a minimum of 10 jobs for a 10% increase in existing employment, whichever is greater, that pays an average wage of at least 107% of the County's average and provides its employees with a benefits package that includes health insurance. Also, the company must remain in the County for 10 years. The second is a targeted industry that creates a minimum of 10 jobs, or a 10% increase in existing employment, whichever is greater, paying an average of 100% of the County's average wage and making a capital investment of $10 million or more, and the company must remain in the County for more than 10 years. The third qualification for a locally-owned and operated business that uses the same definition of the County Job Growth Investment Grant Program would create 10 jobs with an average wage of 100% of the County's average, and provide employees with benefits, including health insurance, and remain in the County for 10 years. Staff provided a breakdown overview of the criteria and differences in the consideration of calculating the amount of the Impact Fee Mitigation for the company’s eligibility. The Impact Fee Mitigation program is the County's least-used economic development tool. The company that requests the agreement must submit a request before a decision to expand or be located within St. Lucie County, commonly referred to as “But For” incentives, which is a financial incentive that is necessary to make the project happen. The idea is, “But for the incentive, the project would not occur at the location or at all. The agreement must be approved by the Board and can be rejected without cause. If the Board approves the agreement, the County is responsible for paying the impact fees using County fees other than impact fees. Over the last 8 years, the County has provided this incentive to three economic development projects. The terms of the agreement spell out the annual reporting requirements to ensure wage and job creation commitments are met. It also requires a company to remain in St Lucie County for a period of 10 or more years. The third economic incentive is the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption, which is a local tax option tax incentive that exempts a targeted industry that is relocating to or expanding within the County from the portion of the Ad Valorem Millage. The ability for the County to provide this exemption is provided in section 196.1995 of the F.S., requiring voter authorization. Voters have approved the Board to grant these exemptions beginning in 1992, again in 2002, and in 2012, and most recently in 2022. The tax exemption is provided on a declining sliding scale for a maximum of 10 years. There are multiple ways for a new or expanding business to qualify for a tax exemption, including manufacturing of tangible personal property at a fixed location, creating a minimum of 10 jobs, or more, any business with a Sales Factor creating 25 new jobs or more for a facility is less than 0.5, and the third includes the creation of 50 or more new jobs in an office space in Florida which is owned and used by a corporation recently domicile in the state and last any business located in an Enterprise Zone. A business can get a tax exemption on up to 100% of the value of any new buildings for improvements, as well as any new equipment or other tangible personal property purchases. This applies whether it is a brand-new business or an expanding business. For expanding businesses, the exemption only applies to the added value from the improvements and any increase in personal property used for the expansion. Ad Valorem Tax Exemptions are based on the number of jobs created, the annual average wage, and the company's capital investment. The Board can choose to grant or deny the tax incentive at its sole discretion, and each exemption is determined on a case-by-case basis. Staff provided an overview of the

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 12 | P a g e declining scale included within tax abatement ordinances. He advised that the Board could increase or reduce the exemption amount over 10 years. The typical declining scale for tax abatement ordinances provides for a 100% ad valorem exemption for years 1-5, with a declining exemption for years 6-10 ending at a 20% ad valorem exemption at year 10. Once the tax exemption is approved, the company must provide annual reports to the County and the Property Appraiser to verify compliance with the job creation and wage requirements. In 2003, the Board approved a tax exemption program guidelines that created a point system intended to be used to develop a scale for each project. The points were based on the number of jobs created, average hourly wage, and capital investment. In 2024, the ad valorem tax exemption program abated over $2 million in County tax dollars for seven economic development projects. The number has continued to rise as the County has economic growth and supported large targeted industry expansion and relocations. Wes McCurry, Senior VP of the SLC Economic Development Council (EDC), addressed the Board and reiterated staff's presentation while providing an overview of the County's economic competitiveness through strategic improvements to incentive policies. He discussed the importance of aligning community priorities and making incentive strategies transparent and performance-driven. He described Economic Development as a collaborative effort involving local governments, businesses, schools, utilities, nonprofits, and elected leaders. In the fast-moving global marketplace, it's estimated that, on average, around 15,000 communities seek sites for approximately 1500 major industrial development projects in the United States each year. This means St. Lucie County faces increasingly aggressive competition from major business location projects. Within the County, the Economic Development Council (EDC) has successfully assisted 85 projects from 2017 to 2024, with 32 expansions and 53 attractions, resulting in significant investment and job creation. The projects represented an investment of over $2 billion in the County, ultimately resulting in 16.5 million sq. ft. of new facilities, retaining over 6,700 jobs, and a total projection of nearly 13,000 new jobs. Which is a great turnaround from the great depression that affected the area. A recent report by Polycom indicated that Port St. Lucie MSA's economic strength rating improved from 308 in 2017 to 94 in 2024, largely due to the County's growth. The report showed 3,679 new primary jobs were created from 2017 through 2023, which are direct jobs selling goods or services outside of the area, bringing dollars into the local economy. The average wage in the county increased by 33.6% from 2017 to 2024. He emphasized the importance of building on these successes by critically assessing and enhancing economic development programs. He discussed a survey conducted in partnership with the Florida Economic Development Council to assess trends and best practices in performance-based incentives. The survey focused on eligibility criteria, performance measures, and compliance monitoring, and 25 responses were received and analyzed. Key findings indicate that the County's requirements align well with peers but suggest areas for refinement, particularly in average wage criteria. Some peers use scoring matrices and tiered incentive frameworks, and there are opportunities to strengthen compliance and clawback policies, expand JGIG, and room to enhance infrastructure investment support. Some communities offer incentives not currently available in the County, including ad valorem tax rebates in lieu of tax exemptions, pilot programs, payment in lieu of taxes, fee waivers, or deferrals, speculative building incentive programs, and enhanced bonus categories for employer-driven training programs to upskill workers and support industry needs. He advised that some of the incentives are out for consideration and highlighted the incentive regarding training programs because incentivizing workforce training pays dividends. Also, skilled workers remain in the community even if companies leave. Mr. McCurry recommended a county-wide policy framework to align local jurisdictions and partners

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 13 | P a g e under a unified, transparent, and competitive economic development strategy. This would include county-wide consistency, incentive offerings, clear criteria, and adaptable tools for responsive marketing conditions, standardized applications, implementation procedures to streamline the incentive process, and provide clear eligibility approval processes and consistent evaluation criteria. He suggested additional or alternative incentives, including ad valorem rebates, enhanced job growth incentive grant categories that would include additional bonuses, waivers, and deferrals for permit applications and utilization fees, training funds, and supporting the principle of "you can't sell it if you don't have it," by considering incentive policies for speculative building programs to create available space for small and medium-sized businesses and shovel-ready sites for large-scale development. He also recommended creating an objective and equitable method for evaluating incentives via a scoring matrix and incentive tier structure. He suggested prioritizing wages at 115% or more of the current County average wage and strongly encouraging the allowance of flexibility for wages of 100-115% with reduced but available support. Prioritizing high multiplier industries and capital investment thresholds, to focus investments on three tiers to encourage incentives that are matched to community benefits. He also suggested that bonus factors such as workforce training programs, energy efficiency measures, and community engagement initiatives should be considered. Also, location factors should be considered as well. On the compliance clawbacks and accountability, it was recommended that the consideration of a unified development agreement that addresses all incentives in one agreement, including commitments (wage, job), annual reporting/verification, and compliance provisions. The implementation strategy would be a standardized application that the EDC would review and forward to the jurisdictions regarding confidentiality. The initial screening would be done by the EDC to evaluate the economic impacts, scoring, recommend the level of incentives, and confer with the staff on all issues for a final recommendation. In the event there is a disagreement between staff of the EDC on the level of incentives, an incentive review committee would be established with industry sector representatives from the Board of Directors, and staff from the jurisdictions, at a roundtable to resolve the disagreement. The next steps, if the Board decides to move forward with the recommendations, involve engaging with stakeholders, crafting incentive policies, and bringing them back for public review and Board approval for implementation. Mr. Balcer presented an overview of potential policy changes to the County's economic incentive program for discussion, including raising the average wage requirement above 107% of the County's average wage of $25.52 per hour. The suggestion is to revise the Scoring Matrix to award points based on desired outcomes, including higher wages, new job creation, capital investment, and greater minimum thresholds to receive certain incentives. He suggested developing bonuses for targeted industries that are more stable and can support ancillary businesses within the County. Another consideration is to establish sunset provisions for initial incentive resolution offers to avoid unnecessary staff time and ensure companies move forward. He mentioned issues where companies receive incentive offers but take years to move forward or go radio silent. Collaboration between EDC, Planning and Development Services, and the County Attorney to revoke incentive resolutions was originally approved in 2019. Sunset provisions are included in the original incentive award agreement to avoid unnecessary staff time and ensure companies follow through. He discussed the job growth investment grant extension amendment request and the need for guidance on the number of amendments companies can request. Also, the possibility of companies applying for tax abatement exemptions immediately after receiving a Certificate of Occupancy. The concerns regarding companies not meeting their year one job creation commitment, but still receiving the incentive. He mentioned the staff's

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 14 | P a g e recommendation to include clawback language in ad valorem tax exemption ordinances to recover funds if job creation commitments are not met. Chair Fowler asked for clarification on the County’s average wage. In response, Mr. Balcer confirmed that $25.52 is 107% of the average wage, with the 100% being $23.85, which is the average wage in St. Lucie County. Commissioner Clasby commented that the County should not offer 100% incentive for 107% anymore. He mentioned that when the County started the JGIG incentive program, they did not have to deal with the Live Local Act. He asked if the average daily wage was the same as AMI. In response, Mr. Balcer advised that it was not the same, and the AMI number is higher than the St. Lucie County average. Commissioner Clasby discussed the Live Local Act, Sunset provisions, developer property rights, the need to align incentives, and the importance of not incentivizing jobs that cannot afford the 120% of AMI. He mentioned the need for a sunset provision to limit the number of amendments and to place a cap on the extension request. George Landry, County Administrator, suggested taking time to review the information and revisit the strategies in a future meeting. Chair Fowler commented on the disparity between the average wage and affordable housing income. She mentioned that if businesses are awarded incentives, they need to be at a higher salary, and she is not opposed to completely removing the JGIG Program and limiting the number of attempts to receive incentives. Commissioner Lowry commented on increasing the percentage of the average wage, being in favor of the scoring matrix, and establishing deadline provisions for businesses that fail to meet their commitments. She mentioned that if businesses are given a tax break, they need to adhere to the regulations. Commissioner Leet inquired about how the average wage in St. Lucie County compares to that of other counties. In response, Mr. Wes advised that the average wage in the County is $9 per hour, less than in Martin and Palm Beach, Broward, and Miami-Dade Counties, where the average wage is higher. This is an advantage to the County as lower wages in St. Lucie County can attract companies looking for cost- effective locations. The goal is to increase the average wage. He also discussed the benefits of higher wages for local workers, including reduced commuting and family time. Commissioner Leet asked about the 10-year renewal possibility for tax exemptions and whether any companies have renewed. In response, Mr. Wes advised that tax exemptions are for 10 years and require a referendum every 10 years to authorize the ad valorem tax exemption program. He would like to do additional research to determine the average wages companies have been paying over the past 8 years and get back to the Board. Commissioner Leet expressed the need for accountability and potential penalties for companies that fail to meet their commitments.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 15 | P a g e Commissioner Townsend commented in support of accountability for businesses receiving incentives and expressed the need for competitive wages for affordability, companies paying higher wages to attract and retain local talent. She acknowledges the need for exceptions due to unforeseen circumstances like supply chain issues. The Board and staff discussed average/higher wages, affordable housing income, exemption rebate offer, tax exemptions, better incentives for small businesses, economic impacts, scoring matrix, existing businesses, and a tiered system for incentives. Staff will reach out to each commissioner individually to get feedback and create a series of scenarios to further refine the incentive program. No consensus was made. E. Land Acquisition - ADD ON Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator, presented this item to the Board and discussed the opportunity to preserve 400 acres of land on the western side of the County, off Okeechobee Road and immediately north of the Cypress Creek Preserve and the Pineland Preserve, slightly to the east. The property is listed on environmentally sensitive land, with quality habitat. The property, initially listed at $10 million and relisted at $7.6 million, has been appraised at $6 million, which is approximately $15,000 per acre. To acquire the property, funding would need to be moved from the Reserves. The County has an opportunity with Oak Ridge Ranches, where they have some additional litigation that needs to be completed, which is 125 – 130 acres that needs to be satisfied. In partnership with Oak Ridge Ranches, they would be investing just under $2 million at the acreage rate to help purchase and protect the land. The land is currently in the Agricultural-5 (AG-5) future land use/zoning category, which is five units per acre with the potential for 80 homes and 80 guest homes, and includes various non-residential agricultural uses. The conditional uses include air parks, pesticide manufacturing, and all agricultural-related items. This is a vital habitat. Staff would like to move forward with an offer of $6 million to seek a willing seller in partnership with Oak Ridge Ranches. Oak Ridge Ranches will invest in the property, while the County will retain the land and preserve it for the future. Commissioner Townsend commented on the need for development and the potential future use of the land for a landfill, if necessary, and expressed her support for the investment. She mentioned the land that abuts the Okeechobee landfill, making it a strategic reserve for future expansion if needed. She suggests that the ERD should not fund the land because it would remain preserved land; it needs to remain open for potential future use, which could benefit the County in the long run. Commissioner Clasby expressed concerns regarding the property's wetlands and its proximity to the landfill. He stated he did not see the land as a priority for development for some time, and he is not for taking the land off the tax roll unless there is an immediate project for the land. He said that he is not in favor of purchasing the land; he would rather that the funding pay for the Glades Cut-Off Road. He also commented on the expenses of developing the land. He mentioned the purchase is a waste of developer funding since the land would not be developed anytime soon. Commissioner Lowry commented on the preservation of the land, blocking mechanisms for the County to acquire the land, and addressing landowners.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, April 15, 2025 9:00 AM 16 | P a g e Commissioner Clasby questioned the owner of the land. In response, Chair Fowler advised Junior Louis Ranch, LLC. Chair Fowler commented on water quality and the benefits of the properties' wetlands, stating that an acre of wetlands filters a million gallons of water. She advised that the tax roll could forgo the $568 being paid in taxes for the land per year. She expressed the need for more green spaces and the preservation of animals. She said that just over $1.8 million would be funded by the developer, so leaving the County with $4.2 million to fund the property is a good deal. Commissioner Leet commented on the funding being received from Oak Ridge Ranches and asked if there were any other properties the funding could go into. In response, Ms. Santamaria advised that the County has provided a wish list of properties with the same environmentally sensitive lands on the list. They have been actively searching and have not been successful so far. When the proposed land came up, the staff approached them for a partnership to leverage the funds further. Commissioner Leet proposed moving forward with the land acquisition. He mentioned that if the land is not used in the future, it could be sold. Ms. Santamaria clarified that the land acquisition is part of Oak Ridge Ranches' environmental mitigation, which is something they have to satisfy for their development proposal. If approved, it would be satisfied, as part of their accountability for the vegetation they are disturbing on their site. They have preserved a huge area on the physical site, but they had extra space that was needed. Commissioner Townsend clarified that the funding from Oak Ridge Ranches could not be used for Glades Cut-Off Road; it has to be used for wetlands because they are mediating. The land is developable, and the goal is to keep it in the form it is and let it be a part of the preserve and hiking trails. It is very clearly defined what the funding can and cannot be used for, and it cannot be used for roads. Commissioner Clasby mentioned that he was referring to the County’s additional general fund dollars that would go to land acquisition in addition to Oak Ridge Ranches. He feels the County should have Oak Ridge Ranches purchase land that is at risk of being developed, that is more sensitive, and the proposed land is very low on the list. He feels the land will be in the same state for the foreseeable future until all the surrounding land is developed, as the funding could be better utilized elsewhere. George Landry, County Administrator, mentioned the staff searched for land closer to town, and that there was no acreage as such as the proposed land acquisition available and or in the considerable range of price of what Oak Ridge Ranches would need to satisfy. Ms.

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

4 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 4 of 4

Browse by category4 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners- Informal Meeting (2025-04-15)

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: fced142c9ac0edc3b8d095d97863b24c. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record