
NewsWFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough CountyOctober 28, 2026Hillsborough County
Witness Testifies in Tampa Murder Trial About Seeing Man Dump Storage Bins into McKay Bay
Photo: WFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough County
During the third day of a Tampa murder trial, a witness testified he saw a man unloading storage bins containing black sludge off a bridge near McKay Bay in November 2021. Prosecutors are attempting to prove the man seen on the bridge was Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Stephanie Crone-Overholtz and disposing of her body parts. The testimony follows the discovery of human remains in the bay by investigators and fishermen.
Read the full story at WFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough CountyWhy It Matters
The ongoing criminal trial determines the legal accountability and potential penalties for a defendant accused of a violent homicide, involving evidence collection and eyewitness testimony concerning the disposal of human remains.
Key Facts
- The murder trial focuses on the death of 47-year-old Stephanie Crone-Overholtz, whose status changed from a missing person to a murder victim after investigators found evidence.
- Witness Lazzaro Castro testified that on Nov. 9, 2021, while fishing near McKay Bay at sunset, he saw a man throw multiple storage bins over the side of a bridge.
- Castro stated he looked inside one of the floating bins and saw what he described as 'black sludge.'
- Prosecutors are working to prove that the man Castro saw on the bridge was Robert Kessler, the defendant accused of killing Crone-Overholtz.
- Investigative searches of the bay utilized drones, boats, dive teams, and cadaver dogs following tips from fishermen.
- Fisherman Stuart Welch reported seeing what looked like the lower half of a human leg floating near the 22nd Street bridge.
- Police contacted Castro four days after the search began, and he identified Kessler's mugshot as looking like the man he saw on the bridge.
- Defendant Robert Kessler waived his right to appear in the courtroom and listened to proceedings over Zoom from the jail.
Who's Mentioned
locationFlorida“State where the prosecutors are trying the case.”PersonScott Harmon“Prosecutor questioning a Tampa Police officer during the trial.”locationTampa“City where the trial and alleged crimes took place.”PersonRobert Kessler“Defendant accused of killing Crone-Overholtz.”locationMcKay Bay“Body of water where evidence and human remains were reportedly dumped and search”PersonStuart Welch“Fisherman who reported seeing a human leg floating in the water.”PersonStephanie Crone-Overholtz“Victim whose disappearance and murder are the subject of the trial.”PersonLazzaro Castro“Witness who testified to seeing a man dump storage bins into McKay Bay.”
