POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsWFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough CountyOctober 28, 2026Hillsborough County

Witness Testifies in Tampa Murder Trial About Seeing Man Dump Storage Bins into McKay Bay

Photo: WFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough County

During the third day of a Tampa murder trial, a witness testified he saw a man unloading storage bins containing black sludge off a bridge near McKay Bay in November 2021. Prosecutors are attempting to prove the man seen on the bridge was Robert Kessler, who is accused of killing Stephanie Crone-Overholtz and disposing of her body parts. The testimony follows the discovery of human remains in the bay by investigators and fishermen.

Read the full story at WFLA (NBC 8) — Hillsborough County

Why It Matters

The ongoing criminal trial determines the legal accountability and potential penalties for a defendant accused of a violent homicide, involving evidence collection and eyewitness testimony concerning the disposal of human remains.

Key Facts

  • The murder trial focuses on the death of 47-year-old Stephanie Crone-Overholtz, whose status changed from a missing person to a murder victim after investigators found evidence.
  • Witness Lazzaro Castro testified that on Nov. 9, 2021, while fishing near McKay Bay at sunset, he saw a man throw multiple storage bins over the side of a bridge.
  • Castro stated he looked inside one of the floating bins and saw what he described as 'black sludge.'
  • Prosecutors are working to prove that the man Castro saw on the bridge was Robert Kessler, the defendant accused of killing Crone-Overholtz.
  • Investigative searches of the bay utilized drones, boats, dive teams, and cadaver dogs following tips from fishermen.
  • Fisherman Stuart Welch reported seeing what looked like the lower half of a human leg floating near the 22nd Street bridge.
  • Police contacted Castro four days after the search began, and he identified Kessler's mugshot as looking like the man he saw on the bridge.
  • Defendant Robert Kessler waived his right to appear in the courtroom and listened to proceedings over Zoom from the jail.

Who's Mentioned